TALES OF THE
BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
By the same author:
TRACE YOUR ANCESTORS
THE STORY OF HERALDRY
THEY CAME WITH THE CONQUEROR
THE STORY OF THE PEERAGE
THE MIDDLE SEA
THE GOLDEN BOOK OF THE CORONATION
TEACH YOURSELF HERALDRY AND GENEALOGY
L.G. PINE, B.A., F.S.A. SCOT.
EDITOR OF BURKE’s PEERAGE
TALES
OF THE BRITISH
ARISTOCRACY
BURKE
First published ig^6
?■'- 'r
f
Vi
tIBRAR'*
BURKE PUBLISHING CO. LTD.
55 BRITTON STREET, LONDON, E. C. I
PRINTED IN HOLLAND BY
DRUKKERIJ HOOIBERG, EPE.
CONTENTS
Introduction
1 NORFOLK - The House of Howard
2 WESTMINSTER - The House of Grosvenor
3 NELSON - The House of Nelson
4 WELLINGTON - The House of Wellesley
5 KiNGSALE - The House of De Courcy
6 WAVELL - The House of Wavell
0
7 MONTROSE - The House of Graham
8 MARLBOROUGH - The House
of Spencer-Churchill
9 SAGKVILLE - The House of Sackville-West
10 BEAVERBROOK - The Housc of Aitkcn
11 LEICESTER - The Housc of Coke
12 MUNSTER - The House of Fitzclarence
13 Peerage seekers
14 The Anglo-Jewish Peerage
15
35
47
62
82
95
112
134
160
169
187
202
209
217
Epilogue
224
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The Author and Publishers ivish to thank the following for their permission to
reproduce photographs.
PICTURE POST LIBRARY
WEAVER SMITH PRINTS, LTD.
NATIONAL PORTRAIT GALLERY
IVEAGH BEQ.UEST, KENWOOD
ILLUSTRATIONS
Facing Page
The Duke of Norfolk 4 ®
Thomas William Coke, Esq. 4 ^
The Duke of Wellington, by John Jackson 49
Horatio Viscount Nelson by L. F. Abbott 49
Sir Winston Churchill ®4
1 st Earl Wavell
1 st Duke of Westminster by W. H. Mote i 44
French caricature of the Duke of Marlborough, early
igth century 144
Lord Beaverbrook 145
Thomas, ist Earl of Leicester by Zinks, after
Valentine Green 160
Lord Hore-Belisha 160
King William IV by Sir Martin Archer Shef 161
Mrs. Jordan as Rosalind by John Hoppncr i6i
INTRODUCTION
I n this book I have told the story of some of the great families
of the British aristocracy whose names \viW always be linked
with British history and the greatness of our country.
The story of the British aristocracy cannot be anything but
fascinating or colourful. Even in huge tomes such as Burke
no amount of editorial ingenuity can keep out the romance.
Before however we go on to the story of the peers it is just as
well to know what we mean by nobility. What is a peer? was a
question put to me recently by a most learned man, who hap¬
pened however not to have made this particular branch of
knowledge his study. He went on to say that he knew that a
baron was the lowest rank in the peerage. To answer the question
is not easy; the first Earl of Birkenhead, in one of the most
learned judgements ever delivered by a Lord Chancellor, took
nearly 50 pages to propound the answer. We cannot say simply
that a peer of the realm is a member of the House of Lords.
There are Irish and Scottish peers who do not sit in the House,
there are also Spiritual Lords, 26 of them, who do sit there but
who are not peers in the ordinary sense. When they retire from
office they cease to be members of the House of Lords, unless
they are given a peerage, like Archbishops Davidson or Lang who
received temporal baronies on retirement.
A peerage is an hereditary title, but also there are baronets
whose titles are hereditary but who are not members of the
peerage. Then there are life peers who are cert ainl y noblemen but
who cannot transmit their dignities to their children.
10
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
The easiest way to explain the meaning of peerage is to give
a brief historical sketch of it. After the Norman Conquest in 1066
the kingdom was divided between various persons who held their
land from the King. These were known as the tenants-in-chief
and one of their duties was to advise the king in his Great Coun¬
cil. By the end of the 13 th century Parliament began to be sum¬
moned, and was composed, in the Upper House, of those great
tenants whom the King chose to summon by a writ commanding
their attendance at Westminster or elsewhere. A custom grew up
for a writ of summons to be sent to the son of a man who had
received such a writ himself. Peerage law regards a writ of
summons as the proof of creation of a peerage. At first peerages
were created only in this manner, by writs of summons, though
there were also cases of peerages by the tenure, that is, when a
man held a particular property it entitled him to a peerage, and
so the dignity would pass with the property. Gradually however
a new method was introduced for creating peers, by the issue of
letters patent from the Crown, and since the Tudor period ( 1485 -
1603 ) this has been the only method used. In the case of ver>'
old peerages which go back before 1485 there may be no letters
patent and the present holder of such a peerage enjoys his title
in virtue of his descent from an ancestor to whom an original
vmt of summons had been issued.
As Parliament progressed, the two Houses of Lords and Com¬
mons became sharply differentiated. In the Upper House sat the
Lords Spiritual and Temporal. The former included not only
the Archbishops and Bishops but, before the Reformation, the
abbots of the greater monasteries also. In the Temporal Lords
there were several grades of rank. That of Baron was the lowest,
the word having originally meant the King’s man or tenant and
having been applied to the whole body of nobles. Then came
the Viscounts, and after them in ascending order, Earls, Mar¬
quesses and Dukes. These titles were all foreign widi the excep¬
tion of Earl. The latter was an English word but was itself based
upon the Norse jarl. Earl was the only title of nobility used
before the Norman Conquest; Godwin was an Earl and so was
his son, Harold, who became King of England and was slain at
INTRODUCTION
11
Hastings. Baron was a Norman French term; Viscount was
French, and meant a vice-count, or earl. Marquess meant origi¬
nally the keeper of a march or frontier. It came from Italy. Duke
was derived from the Latin Dux; there were many Duces in the
decline of the western Roman Empire.
The Peerage of England continued until 1707, with every Eng¬
lish peer possessing a seat in Parliament. In 1707 there was a
legislative union between England and Scotland. There was a
Scottish peerage with the same dignities as in England, but in
the Treaty of Union between England and Scotland, it was laid
down that only 16 of the Scots peers should have a seat in the
Parliament of Great Britain. They were to be elected by their
fellow peers. This arrangement still persists and thus some
Scottish peers do not have a seat in the Lords. After 1707 all
peerages were to be of Great Britain, and no more English and
Scottish peerages were to be made. The English peerage and the
Scottish peerage continued but are gradually diminishing in
number. Then in 1800 there was a similar union bet^veen Great
Britain and Ireland. The Irish peers were allowed to elect 26 of
their number to sit in the Lords. It is not clear why more Irish
than Scottish peers should sit. Thenceforward there were the
English peerage, the Scottish peerage, the peerage of Great
Britain, the Irish peerage and the peerage of the United King¬
dom. No Irish peerages have been created since the setting up
of the Irish Free State. To-day all peerages are in fact of the
United Kingdom.
Life peerages are the creation of a special measure, in 1876,
whereby such peerages are conferred on prominent judges whose
presence is desired in the Upper House for the conduct of legal
business. A peerage cannot be surrendered, a resolution of the
Lords in 1678 bars this.
As a compensation to Irish peers for the fact tliat they cannot
all take a seat in the Lords they are allowed to stand for the
House of Commons. This is the explanation of the otherwise
strange phenomenon of an Irish Earl who was for nearly 50
years an M.P. and in fact was father of the House of Commons,
yet was in every sense a peer of the realm except that he had not
12
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
been elected as an Irish representative peer. Earl Winterton
represented Horsham in the House of Commons, his earldom
was created in 1766, and he also held the viscovmty of Tumour
and the barony of Winterton in the Irish peerage; yet when he
retired from the Commons, he had to be given a peerage of the
United Kingdom to enable him to sit in the House of Lords and
this peerage was the barony of Tumour (in Sussex as distinct
from his Irish viscounty of the same name in Galway) which
means that when he sat in the Lords he was two degrees lower
as a peer than when he was an M.P. in the Commons. This is a
paradox sufficient to perplex any native of this country, to say
nothing of a foreigner.
In fact there will not be any more Irish representative peers in
the Lords soon, apart from the five who are there as rehcs of
the last election of Irish peers, which was held before tlie
establishment of the Irish Free State in 1922.
Another feature of the peerage which causes great difficulty
is what is known as the courtesy title. For instance the elder son
of the present Duke of Marlborough is known as the Marquess of
Blandford. Blandford is one of the titles held by the Duke, and
it is a custom in England for his heir to use one of these titles
during the father’s lifetime. The Marquess of Blandford could
however be elected to a seat in the House of Commons and could
hold the seat until his time comes to succeed his father as Duke
of Marlborough. The other titles borne by younger sons and by
daughters of peers are also purely honorary. A Duke’s younger
son is Lord Hugh Smith, and a similar style is used for the
younger son of a Marquess. The younger sons of earls, viscounts
and barons are addressed as the Hon. Alfred Smith. The daugh¬
ters of Dukes, Marquesses and Earls are addressed as Lady Mary
Smith. Should one of these ladies marry a man who is not a
peer she still retains her title, and instead of Lady Mary Smith
becomes Lady Mary Jones. The daughters of Viscounts and
Baions are styled the Hon. Mary Smith etc, and the Hon. is used
before the lady’s name when she marries so that she is known as
the Hon. Mrs Jones or the Hon. Lady Jones according to whether
her husband is an esquire or a knight. Every so often a
INTRODUCTION
13
ridiculous mistake is made in describing the wife of a knight or
baronet as Lady Joan Robinson, when she is not entitled to be
called anything but Lady Robinson, for the simple reason that
she is not the daughter of an earl.
One of the most important points in connection with the
British system of titles is that it is entirely different from that
on the Continent. In France, Spain or Italy every member of a
noble family bears a title. In England on the other hand Sir
Winston Churchill, although the grandson of a Duke, was plain
Mr Churchill until he was made a Knight of the Garter. Even
more interesting, the descendents of our own Royal house can
be plain Mr or Miss Windsor in the third generation, because the
title of Prince or Princess is restricted to a child or grandchild of
tlie sovereign. The British system makes it much more difficult
for false titles to be used, whereas among foreigners they are
of course legion.
Another matter of interest is in the number of peers. Lord
Samuel has recently observed that there are over 850 peers on the
Roll of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal of whom some 230 have
been created in the last 30 years; Lord Samuel also said that at
the present rate of progress we should soon reach a thousand peers
and that this would be a situation unparalleled among the Upper
Chambers of the world. Peerages are certainly increasing in this
country at a much quicker rate than in previous years, but the
proportion of peers per million of the population is now about 16
or 17, whereas 400 years ago it was about 14, so there has not
been after all such an alarming increase as one might imagine.
The above notes are by way of introduction for readers who
want to know the meaning of peerage sufficiently at least to be
able to follow the rules of the game and to know what is the
difference between a Marquess and a Duke; 'is a marquess a
man?' is a question which has quite seriously been addressed to
me on more than one occasion.
In writing this book about the peerage I have drawn to a con¬
siderable extent upon the knowledge and experience which 1 have
gained in the last ten years in connection with Burke’s Peerage.
One of the things which has most irritated elderly pundits and
14
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
those precious young men who seem to be Ibeir counterpart
today, has been the application of a human touch to heraldry,
pedigrees, titles and dignities. I have always been interested in
these matters because they are there, and because I am fascinated
by the spectacle of a human being who imagines that he or she
is elevated by some mere external accident such as a double-
barrelled name or a Dukedom above the ordinary run of humanity.
A working man once remarked to me that he found it very helpful
when contemplating the great ones of the earth to imagine what
they would look like without their clothes 1
Chapter one
«
NORFOLK
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
I turned into the Law Courts on a bright December day, the
21st, in 1954 and made my way through those imposing halls
to the Lord Chief Justice's Court. The Duke of Norfolk, the 16th
of his line had decreed that the Court of Chivalry after dormancy
of 219 years should sit to hear a complaint brought by the Man¬
chester Corporation against the Manchester Palace of Varieties,
a music hall, which it was alleged had been using the arms of the
Corporation unlawfully. By rights the Court should have sat in the
Earl Marshal's old court room in the College of Arms in Queen
Victoria Street, but a court which sits about once every 2J4
centuries is bound to attract a great deal of interest; consequently
the numbers anticipated as attending the court were too great for
the space at Heralds’ College. Admission to the Court which was
therefore to be held in the Lord Chief Justice's court room was by
ticket only, save for a barrister wearing his robes. When I
arrived a few minutes before the court was to meet it was already
crowded, and I had to sit at the back, a position however which
I found preferable from the point of seeing everyone in the court.
I employed the interval in studying the audience. In line with
me were a well known solicitor, the editor of Debrett, and a
third man. one of the most distinguished Welsh scholars in the
country. Just before proceedings began, a famous radio per¬
sonality came in beside me. I saw behind the Judge's seat the
Garter King of Arms and the Norxoy and Ulster King.
In various parts of the Court were other members of the
*5
16
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
College of Arms; tlie founder of tlie Heraldry Society took a
seat below me and in the well of the Court I observed one of
the Heralds Extraordinary, Mr Dermot Morrah, in the state of
academic excitement which seems the prerogative of those jour¬
nalists who work for the Old Lady of Printing House Square. He
moved rapidly from place to place but eventually sat down.
The press boxes on either side of the well were filled up with
journalists, among whom I noticed the correspondent of a very
well known American newspaper.
There was nothing of colour in the scene, for even the women
were quietly dressed, and the panelling of the walls in these
courts is of so dull a colour tliat tlie Royal arms themselves
behind the Judge’s chair did not show up in very much detail.
Had they done so they would have provided a silent but ironical
commentary on the whole proceedings, for they were the arms
of William IV, and must have been brought from Westminster
Hall when the Law Courts in the Strand were opened. As they
included the arms of Hanover, Her Majesty could have no
jurisdiction over them and there they were in a Court the purpose
of which was to vindicate the Royal control of arms in England.
Suddenly however a door behind the dais opened and an usher
entered to proclaim in a loud shrill voice the approach of the
Court. In came first the Registers, Mr Maurice Phillipps, notary
public, and Mr Anthony Wagner, Richmond Herald. Both wore
academic dress, Wagner being garbed as an M.A. of Oxford
University. Their hoods provided a splash of colour but it was
nothing to the grandeur which followed. Six of the Officers of
Arms, four of them Heralds, and two Pursuivants entered, clad
in scarlet tunics, dark blue trousers with gold stripes at the
sides. They wore their full medals and decorations, carried their
cocked hats in their hands and their swords at their sides. They
ranged themselves on either side of the Judge’s seat and behind
them entered the Lord Chief Justice of England. Lord Goddard,
clad in the robes of a Doctor of Civil Law, a crimson gown and
the black doctor’s hat. Then came in the Earl Marshal and
Hereditary Marshal of England, the Premier Duke, Sir Bernard
Marmaduke Fitzalan Ploward, Duke of Norfolk and Knight of
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
17
the Garter. His clothes were similar to those of his Officers,
but with the addition of the blue ribbon and the Star of the
Garter. He wore his magnificent plumed hat. As he took his place
beside Lord Goddard the latter doffed his black cap and bowed.
To some, the proceedings might seem a piece of pageantry
but in fact it was English history alive before one’s eyes. Every¬
thing had a meaning and a place. We all stood while the
Registers began to read the documents which set out the original
authority of the Court, and the letters from the Earl Marshal
which had empowered the Lord Chief Justice to act as his Surr¬
ogate in the present case. Within the compass of twenty minutes
we passed from the atmosphere of 1954 back to the reign of
Charles II three hundred years before, when the Court of
Chivalry had been revived, as it was being revived now, after
the Restoration. Lord Goddard, used for well over half a century
to the normal procedure of the Courts of Common Law and
Equity seemed restive while the letters patent were read, but
when the reading was concluded everyone sat down and he went
at once into the hearing of the case.
The City of Manchester had complained that the Palace of
Varieties had used the City Arms on the pelmet of tlieir drop
curtain for many years and also on their common seal on their
documents. Counsel for the plaintiff began to set out his case
and to cite statutes of Richard II and other sovereigns and to
quote cases to illustrate his points; in due course counsel for the
defendants repUed. Their methods of setting out the case differed
no more than their wigs and gowns from the procedure which
they would have followed had they been addressing Lord
Goddard in a case in his oNvn court. In fact both Judge and
Counsel were dealing with a matter of the Civil Law, for the
Court of Chivalry was the only survival of the old Civil Law
system left in this country. The sense of the falling away of
centuries which the reading of the letters patent had produced
was continued. Counsel spoke famUiarly of cases which had been
heard by the Court of Chivalry 600 years before. Any student of
heraldry would have known that it was inevitable that Scrope
V. Grosvenor would be mentioned, and mentioned the case was.
18
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
When Mr Squibb, Bencher of the Inner Temple, had finished on
behalf of the plaintiffs, Mr Colin Cole of the Middle Temple,
and one of the Heralds Extraordinary appointed at Coronation
time, submitted a most ingenious and learned argument to prove
that the statutes of Richard II referred to by his learned friend
did not mean what that learned friend considered them to mean.
The hearing continued into the afternoon but was not prolonged
unduly and the court was out by four o'clock. Even so the Surr¬
ogate had manifested on several occasions a certain impatience
and at one stage had seemed desirous that everything should
move foward more quickly. The office of Lord Chief Justice is
one of vast importance in the English legal system and Lord
Goddard is an occupant of the post in the great tradition of
Coke and Holt. To him the minutiae of heraldic law, such as it
is, must have seemed of slight importance compared to the
matters with which his legal acumen was normally concerned.
None the less he had consented to hold the Court as deputy of
the Earl Marshal and it was natural for him from time to time
to turn as in enquiry to the magnificent figure at his side. Ad¬
mittedly there is an aridity and apparent lack of air in the Law
Courts in the Strand and this may have something to do with
the failure of the Siurogate to receive any response to his
enquiries. At last the usual resort of a Judge however did not
fail; Lord Goddard asked Mr Cole if a Coat of Arms was a
matter of property or dignity. 'That is a very difficult question
my Lord' was the reply. ‘I thought so, and that is why I asked
it'. There was a slight laugh in Court and the Earl Marshal’s
figure came to life, a smile appearing on his ruddy countenance.
Suddenly as I gazed across theCourtattheEarlMarshallbegan
to ponder on the mysteries of blood, lineage, hereditary. The
sixteenth Duke of Norfolk was the great-great-great-great-great-
great-great-great-great-great-great-great-grandson of the second
Duke of Norfolk who although hampered by illness had dealt
the Scots a knock-out blow at Flodden. That second Duke him¬
self had been the great-great-great-grandson of Sir William
Howard, Justice of the Common Pleas in 1297, who had been
the ‘lad of parts' who founded the great house of Howard. Sir
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
19
William’s father had been a simple yeoman and the man before
me was his nineteenth lineal descendant. From John Howard the
yeoman of Wiggenhall St Peter in Norfolk to the Earl Marshal
was twenty generations, and during that time the Howards had
risen from obscurity to grandeur; dark tragedy and brutal
treatment, romance and triumph, political stupidity and religious
fortitude had all combined to produce the modem representative.
Strip him of the apparel of his office, put him in some home-
spun clothes, and set him somewhere on the South downs and
you would imagine that you were meeting one of those honest
countrymen who for so many centuries have been the backbone
of England. The Earl Marshal’s eyes were closed, he seemed to
resemble somewhat a Dalai Lama of whom I had once read, who
was being doped by his priests with doctored milk and who was
then brought on in a languid condition to pai'ticipate in
ceremonies in which he had no real interest. Yet even while
I thought of these things I was reminded of the immense success
of the Coronation, viewing it, that is, purely from the point of
view of a very great ceremony which had to be prepared by
months of arduous work. The Duke in his capacity of Earl
Marshal had only the most skeleton-like office organization
ready to his hand on the morning when King George VI was
found dead; the thirteen officers of the College of Arms have
their own small staffs which leave only the smallest margin to
deal with e.xtra work. Consequently the Earl Marshal in
preparing for the Coronation had to set up within a matter of
weeks a business department of some sixty persons. No doubt
the experience of the 1937 Coronation was of very great help,
but even so the perfect timing and arrangements in 1953 were a
tribute to efficiency and skill which could not have been
surpassed, and probably not equalled by that of the selfmade
business magnates of Britain. The Duke holds his office
of Earl Marshal by hereditary right under a creation of
Charles II’s time. Is then the force of tradition and upbringing so
great that it can surmount even slender endowments in the
individual?
I began to ponder the history of the Howards. They are of
20
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
course the heads of the Peerage, and at the beginning of their
lineage in Burke comes the proud sentence The Ducal and
illustrious Howards stand next to the Blood Royal, at the head
of the Peerage of England*. From this introduction one might
well expect to pass on to a story of what old Fuller would have
called stupendous antiquity, one of those pedigrees (there are
unfortunately very few) which go back to Saxon times, or at the
best to the Norman Conquest. In fact the Howards begin with
an honest yeoman, John Howaid of the village of Wiggenhall
St Peter in Norfolk where he lived in 1267. We know very little
about him, the principal facts being that Lucy his wife married
a man called John Germund as her second husband, and that he
had as his son the Sir William Howard, who became a Judge.
True enough, a much earlier origin has been assigned to the
Howards, John Howard having been described sometimes as the
descendant of Hereward the Wake. General Harward who him¬
self was certain of his own descent from the Wake had some
very derisive remarks to make about the Howard-Hereward
derivation. It is a curious feature of comparatively modem
genealogy that so many families of eminence have tried to prove
that they are descended from the last of the English. Time
brings strange revenges and it is a decidedly Norman family,
the Wakes of Lincolnshire who assert most strongly their desc¬
ent from Hereward. The story of the Howard descent made its
way into peerage books apparently by the insistence of the
present Duke of Norfolk's mother, Baroness Herries, from whom
he has inherited that title, but the story must be given up be¬
cause even if Howard is a corruption of Hereward we have no
pedigree to link up the 200 years between John Howard and the
Norman Conquest. Considering the great facilities at the disposal
of the Dukes of Norfolk during the last three or four hundred
years, it is curious that no pedigree has been produced earlier
than 1267. If John Howard were a freeholder of a small landed
property, he may well have been of native English origin, and
if so a representative of the old English race now stands at the
head of the peerage, far above the descendants of the usurping
Normans. At least it is a pleasant thought, legend or no legend.
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
21
Some families have ascended the social ladder by succesful
marriage alliances, some by having property in the right place
at a time of industrial or building development, others by pos¬
sessing a daughter or sister who pleased the Kings fancy; the
rise of the Howards was due to solid merit coupled with
marriages which proved extremely useful in the long run. Sir
William Howard, tlie judge, had several children and his elder
son, Sir John Howard, was a Knight Banneret as early as 1307,
possibly having been knighted as one of the 300 young men who
were companions in arms of Edward II as Prince of Wales. In
any event to be a Knight Banneret implied great bravery in war,
for such a distinction in the Middle Ages was much the equiva¬
lent of a V.C. today. Sir John was as capable in court favour
as he was brave in the field, and as proof of this he married Joan,
the daughter of Sir Richard de Cornwall who was the bastard
grandson of King John. It is possible that a large sum of money
may have been owing to Sir John Howard from the Crown and
as the King could not pay he may have been rewarded with this
left handed alliance with the Royal House. It was a favourite
method in olden days as William Canynge (collateral ancestor
of Lord Garvagh) found when Edward IV tried to liquidate his
debts in a similar manner.
From this time forward the Howards were constantly in the
Kings service by sea and land, and in favour at court. The third
generation from Sir John Howard was Sir Robert Howard who
made what would have been a great marriage by any standards,
with the Lady Margaret, the elder daughter of the then Duke
of Norfolk, Thomas Mowbray, who was himself descended from
Edward I, and who held the office of Earl Marshal. It was
through this marriage that a great part of the wealth of the
Mowbrays, Fitzalans and Segraves, not to mention the Planta-
genets came into the possession of the Howards, owing to the
extinction of the male line of Mowbray. The only son of this
marriage, Sir John Howard, had a most distinguished career. Sir
John was a Yorldst, and unlike most of the nobles in the Wars
of the Roses was true to his beliefs. He held many posts of
importance and was created a Knight of the Garter, but his
22
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
great advancement came in 1483 when the Mowbrays had died
out in the male line. Howard was created Earl Marshal of Eng¬
land and Duke of Norfolk and his son was made Earl of Surrey.
The Duke as Earl Marshal was allowed to bear a golden staff
tipped at each end with black, on the upper part of which were
the Koyal Arms and on the lower part those of the Howards. In
order that he should not be short of money to uphold his dignity
he was given a grant of £20 a year to be paid annually out of
the rent of a farm near Ipswich. In addition the Duke, being
Treasurer of the King*s Household, had a grant of the whole
benefit which would accrue to the King by coinage of money in
the City and Tower of London or elsewhere in England, as long
as the Duke continued in that office. He was also made Lord
High Admiral of England, Ireland and Aquitaine for his life,
and received grants of land in six counties. Altogether he was
enormously rich and would have thought the 50,000 acres of the
16th Duke (in 1917) rather a decline in the family wealth. Un¬
fortunately however it was very dangerous for anyone in the
15th century to have reached such heights; the poems of
Chaucer, Gower, Shakespeare, and many others are full of
laments for the fickleness of fortune and the Duke was certainly
an example to justify their remarks. Being loyal to the House of
York, he followed King Richard III to Bosworth Field. On the
night before the battle a notice was pinned on his tent which
must have given the Duke a very unpleasant sensation when he
read it in the morning. It was:
‘Jockey of Norfolk, be not too bold.
For Dickon thy master is bought and sold.’
In the battle the Duke fell fighting bravely like his master
Dickon, and of course his titles and estates were forfeited by
Act of Parliament when the Earl of Richmond who had over¬
thrown Richard III had become Henry VII.
From now on for the next 150 years the Howards ran a series
of hazards, anyone of which might well have been fatal to them,
as they were in the case of other eminent families. It was by pure
good luck that they escaped, for their own political judgement
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
23
was often gravely at fault. The first Duke’s son was involved
in his father’s ruin, to the extent that he lost the Earldom of
Surrey, but after being imprisoned in the Tower for three years
he was restored and was created Duke of Norfolk and Earl
Marshal in 1514. This was after he had beaten the Scots at Flod-
den, a very great victory which is still commemorated in the coat
of arms of the Dukes of Norfolk. As an honourable augmentation
the Howards bear an escutcheon or (gold) which is charged with
a demi lion rampant (the Scottish lion), pierced through the
mouth by an arrow within the tressure (as it is called) of the
Royal Scottish arms. Never was any augmentation of arms more
gallantly earned and Thomas Howard the second Duke of Nor¬
folk may well rank as the great man of the Howard family. He
was a man of spirit and determination and when Sir Andrew
Barton, a Scottish pirate, had begun to plunder English shipping
in the Channel, the Earl of Surrey as the Duke then was, equip¬
ped hvo ships at his own expense and captured the Scotch ships,
Barton being killed in the fight. This was in 1511, and when
James IV of Scotland complained to his brother-in-law, Henry
VIII of Sir Andrew Barton’s death, the bluff king replied gently
that princes did not concern themselves with pirates. James IV
and Henry VIII were not likely to be on good terms with each
other, both being young and high spirited but Henry warned
James of the disasters which would be likely to come to him
if he attacked England. Despite this when Henry was in France,
James with a great army invaded England in August 1513. He
made considerable progress in Northumberland before the Earl
of Surrey at the head of the English army advanced to meet
him. There were challenges between Surrey and the Scotch king,
who naturally was not willing to abandon his strong position near
Flodden. The English troops were short of provisions and if tlie
Scots had stayed in their position Surrey’s army might have
broken up. To avoid this the Earl, like Cromwell afterwards at
Dunbar, relied on strategy. He marched round the Scottish flank
and on 9th September drew up his army in the rear of the Scotch
whom he was able to gall with artillery fire and with archery.
As a result. King James led his whole army against the English.
24
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
The guns of those days were slow in discharge and reloading
and the battle had to be decided by hand-to-hand fighting.
Gradually the Scottish flanks were broken or retreated and
the centre was isolated to bear the full brunt of the English
attack. The battle raged for hours and it is impossible to refrain
from quoting Sir Walter Scott's immortal verse;
The stubborn spearmen still made good,
Their dark impenetrable wood’.
All weapons were used against the Scots, lances, swords, bills,
arrows and musquetry. Whatever King James' faults as a general,
as a soldier he fought magnificently, hand to hand with his en¬
emies, until at last he fell, covered with wounds, only a lance’s
length from the Earl of Surrey. Even then his lords gathered
round the dead body like Harold's housecarles at Hastings, to
die with their chief; in the morning the bodies of 13 earls and
several bishops were found in a ring around King James, while
a host of the lesser nobles and gentry lay near by. None of the
many defeats which Scotland has endured at the hands of Eng¬
land has made so deep an impression upon the Scots. The name
of Flodden is to this day synonymous with national disaster, and
when the Highlanders were compelled to surrender at St Valery
in 1940 it was said in Scotland that there had been no such blow
since Flodden. Red Flodden’s tale is written across the heart of
Scotland.
To the victor the spoils, and appropriately the Earl of Surrey
was created Duke of Norfolk in 1514 within five months of his
great victory.
As Earl Marshal it was also in keeping with his position as
head of the Herald’s College that the ring and sword of the
fallen Scottish monarch should come to be preserved there where
they can still be seen. 'The King's body went through various
fortunes and his brother-in-law, Henry VIII asked leave of the
Pope to bury James with Royal Honours, permission being
necessary as James had died excommunicated. Whatever hap¬
pened to James* body, there was for long a story that it was
preserved in a barber's shop in London where it could be seen
25
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
on payment of a smaU sum; the Scots, probably because the
body had been mutilated, and may therefore not have been
easely recognized, long had the idea that James had escaped tlie
battle and would return to them.
The Howards had now entered upon their hazardous century;
in the Tudor period no great nobleman could think himself safe.
In his play ‘Henry VIII’, Shakespeare describes the fall of
Buckingham and then of Wolsey who had been responsible for
Buckingham’s disgrace. Northumberland, Somerset and Norfolk,
were all exposed to terrible descents from pinnacles of power to
poverty and ruin. The second Duke (the victor of Flodden) died
peacefully in 1524 but two of his sons were in grave danger and
one of them, Thomas Howard was attainted of treason because
he wished to marry the niece of Henry VIII. He died a prisoner
in the Tower and his eldest brother the third Duke very nearly
went to the block, but before describing his fate it is as well
to note the tangle of relationships between the Howards and the
Tudors which was responsible for most of the vicissitudes which
the Howard family experienced at that time. Elizabeth Howard
the daughter of the second Duke was the motlier of Anne
Boleyn. Elizabeth Howard had a brother Edmund, who was
Marshal of the Horse at Flodden Field. Edmund Howard had
three children, a son and two daughters; the younger daughter
Catharine had the misfortune to marry Henry VIII as his fifth
wife in 1540. Eighteen months later she went tlie way of her
cousin and predecessor as Queen, Arme Boleyn, being be¬
headed on a charge of adultery. Catherine’s only brother, Henry
had a wife, Anne, who was attained along with her sister-in-law
Catherine Howard. When it is understood that Edmund Howard
had married into the Culpepper family, and that one of the
Culpeppers was named as paramour (after some knotted cords
had been twisted into his brain) of Queen Catherine, the com¬
plex of relationships, fraught with lurking perils, will be per¬
ceived.
The miracle of the Howards is not that they were nearly
extinguished, but that they survived at all. As Henry VIII grew
older, and as his physical excesses told on him — he listed
26
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
wenching as one of his temporal joys, massing and music being
among his spiritual ones — his temper grew to a hideous fero¬
city, It was dangerous to be near him, favourite after favourite
flourished for a while then came to the inevitable end. At 50 the
King was an old and enfeebled man, rendered bitter by the
memory of his splendid but lost youth, and by the trickery and
infidelities of the various women whom he had married in the
hopes of providing England with a line of sovereigns to follow
him. From 1540 to 1547, the last years of his reign, Henry must
have resembled to some extent his younger contemporary who
became Ivan the Terrible of Russia; his diseased mind caused
him to suspect all his nobles, and on whom should his suspicions
rest more than on the man whose niece he had degraded and
beheaded? Characteristically the King struck first of all at the
Duke of Norfolk’s son, the famous Earl of Surrey. ‘One of the
brightest ornaments of the house of Howard', this brilliant young
man possessed all the qualities which were admired at that
period of flowering in the European mind. The Renaissance had
come late to England, but in Surrey it had found a worthy
e.xponent. He was handsome in body, graceful in all athletic
pursuits, skilled in military exercises and in the tournament, and
a good soldier in the Scottish wars; he was a good scholar, and
a poet. It was due to Surrey along with Sir Thomas Wyatt
(his son was destined to the block imder Bloody Mary) that
English poetry revived after the horrors which had been in¬
flicted upon it by people like Skelton, and others who had tried
in vain to imitate Chaucer. Surrey will always have an honoured
place in English literature and there was a vast amount of
romance made out of his poems to The Fair Geraldine, a lady
who seems to have been a poetic abstraction, rather than one
of flesh and blood. Be that as it may, no one could deny Surrey’s
graces, but they availed him nothing when Henry VIII had him
accused of high treason under one of his newly passed statutes.
It was said in the indictment that Surrey had committed high
treason against the Crown because he had used the arms of King
Edward the Confessor which belonged exclusively to the Royal
house. The truth behind this extraordinary charge was that 150
27
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
years before Surrey’s time. Richard II had had a great veneration
L Edward the Confessor. To show this he produced a very
strange variation of the Royal Arms of England; the shield was
divided in Rvo or impaled, as the term goes, svith the Confessor s
arms on the right and the quarterly arrangement of the arms ot
France and England on the left. Richard was an erratic person
and as a mark of favour he gave the right to bear the arms of
the Confessor to some of the nobles of the day who had royal
blood.
One of these was Thomas Mowbray, Duke of Norfolk, whose
arms were inherited by the Howards. It is not clear whether
Richard’s grant to Mowbray was for life only, or to his heirs as
well, but the Earl of Surrey, whose peerage was not a courtesy
title but a dignity which his father had resigned to him when he
was made Duke of Norfolk, thought that he could use the arms
and in fact did so, using a label to differentiate them from those
of his father. Indeed he took advice from the College of Arms
before he so acted. None of the longs of England after Richard
II had used these arms of the Confessor, and thus quite clearly
the charge was a trumped up one. Surrey defended himself with
courage and ability when he was brought to trial on 13 January,
but he was quickly convicted and executed on 21 January 1547.
His father had also been arrested and proceedings instituted
against him on the plea that he should have prevented Uis son
from using the obnoxious arms. Henry VIII was near the end of
his own life, and his hands were too swollen to guide a pen, so
that a stamp with the initials ‘H.R.’ was made in order that
the conduct of business should not be held up. By this means the
death warrant was signed for Surrey, and the same thing ^vould
have happened for his father, the Duke, if Henry had not died
on 28 January before the sentence could be carried out.
One of the most tragical commentaries on this affair was that
the alleged arms of Edward the Confessor had no real existence.
In the Middle Ages it was usual for every king to have arms
assigned to him. King Herod of Jewry, Judas Maccabeus, the
Nine Worthies, and even Christ were personages credited with
possessing arms; in fact of course it was due to the mediaeval
28
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
habit of seeing the past in contemparory dress. Just as Roman
soldiers at the crucifixion wore armour of the 14th centui-y in
14th century paintings, so all the important Icings and people of
the past were thought to have had coats of arms. When Richard
II had become very fond of Edward the Confessor, someone
invented arms for the latter, and they have been used ever since
in the arms of Westminster, with which Edward as founder of the
Abbey and Richard as restorer were so much associated. Probably
the Confessor’s arms were invented by a monk of Westminster,
who was thus the innocent ultimate cause of poor Surrey’s
death.
After his harrowing experience, the 3rd Duke lived peace¬
fully until 1554 when he was succeeded by his grandson Thomas,
the son of the murdered Surrey. It might have been thought
that a tradition would have been handed down in the family
that the holders of the title should live quietly and avoid
political danger. If any such story were told by the old Duke to
his grandson he did not pay much heed to it, for he involved
himself in the affairs of Mary Queen of Scots. Damley, Douglas,
Bothwell, Norfolk, all who meddled with the fortunes of that
unlucky woman were destined to the same end, death, or at least
disgrace. The fourth Duke stood high in the favour of Queen
Elizabeth I; she made him a Knight of the Garter and Lieutenant
General in the north when he was only 24. It was with the utmost
reluctance that she agreed to charges of treason being brought
against him. Even when she knew that he was corresponding
with Mary, Elizabeth tried her hardest to warn the Duke so
that he would withdraw before it was too late. He was admitted
to an intimate supper party in the Queen's apartments, and
Elizabeth spoke to him as plainly as she could, without divulging
the confidence of her ministers, about the danger in which he
stood; but the infatuated man had persuaded himself that Mary
would marry him. He had had three wives already, all of whom had
conveniently died, and Mary had had three husbands, but Marys
emissaries had made the Duke beHeve that the Scottish Queen
genuinely cared for him and that if he should unite himself wi*
her, they should reign over England and Scotland together. The
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
29
future of EUzabetli seems to have been left somewhat vague.
Thanks to the wonderful intelligence system of Cecil (later Lord
Burghley). the whole of the Duke’s correspondenee with Mary
was known to the government, and as tlie Duke took no notice
of Elizabeth’s warning he was arrested and put in the Tower in
October 1569. There was the clearest ewdence of his guilt, so
that at his trial in January 1571 he was rapidly found guilty and
attainted. In fact he was not in prison for the whole period of
sixteen months, but was allowed out in one of his own houses
where he was stupid enough to resume his intrigues witli Mary.
The final act in his tragedy was his execution on Tower Hill in
1572 before he had reached the age of 36. It is interesting to note
that when he was writing to his children while under sentence
of death, he stated that the Catholic religion ‘Brings nothing but
bondage to men’s consciences', and that it was entirely false that
he was a Cathohc. His death sentenee was revoked more than
once, but Cecil knew that he would never be able to stop
intriguing as long as he lived so he was put to death. His folly
went on in his family, and his eldest son who inherited the
earldom of Arundel from his mother (but not his father’s
dukedom, owing to the attainder) died a prisoner in the
Tower in 1595 having had his earldom also attainted. The Earl¬
dom was restored to Thomas, the grandson of the fourth duke,
imder James I, and he was also given back part of his property
and made Earl Marshal. It was not until 1660 however, that the
Dukedom of Norfolk was restored to the Howards.
From that time forward until the present, the Howards have
avoided the perils of politics and have been distinguished by
two features, the retention of the Earl Marshalship, and, on the
whole, adherence to the Roman Catholic faith. As to the former
this is really a remarkable feat. In the earliest times after the
Norman Conquest the office of the Marshal existed and was
held by a family which took its surname from the office. From
the last of these, Wilham Marshal, Earl of Pembroke, the office
passed to the Bigods, Earls of Norfolk, and from them was
resigned to the Royal house itself whereupon Thomas of
Brotherton, brother of Edward II and Earl of Norfolk was made
30
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Earl Marshal. It was eventually through this connection, and the
alliance of the Howards with the Royal family that the first Duke
was created Earl Marshal. Owing to the various attainders the
office did not really settle in the Howard family until nearly 200
years after the bestowal of it by Richard III on the first Duke.
At last in 1672 the 6th Duke of Norfolk was created Earl Marshal
of England with the right of remainder to several branches of
his family. From that time forward the Dukes of Norfolk have
lived more peaceably and have therefore been able to build up
an immense prestige as the holders of one of the few great
Offices of State which still remain. By an Act of Parliament dated
24 June 1824 it was further laid down that the then Duke (the
twelfth) and his successors should exercise the office of Earl
Marshal although they were Roman Catholics.
This brings us to one of the most extraordinary features in the
story of the Howards. It is of course well known that the Duke
of Norfolk is the chief Roman Catholic layman in England and
it is often pointed out that when he officiates as Earl Marshal at
the marriage, death, or coronation of royalty, he has to obtain a
dispensation from the Archbishop of Westminster, the head of
his own communion, to allow him to take part in what Catholics
deem the heretical worship of the Anglican Church. Stories are
always circulating about ludicrous incidents which arise on these
occasions. The Anglican Bishop Gore was a Canon of West¬
minster at the time of King Edward VHs coronation. As a coron¬
ation approaches it is essential that the Earl Marshal should
have control of the building well in advance of the ceremony.
This involves the virtual abdication of that ecclesiastical autocrat
the Dean of Westminster. Normally the latter could defy Arch¬
bishops of Canterbury and Bishops of London, but when the
Dean was dethroned by the father of the present Duke of Norfolk
in 1902 Canon Gore asked the Duke if he were not sorry for the
Dean and Canons, ‘No, I am only sorry for the monks whom
they displaced'. Again, at the time of the last coronation the
Archbishop of Canterbury is supposed to have asked the Duke
during a rehearsal ‘What do we do now?' "You pray*, was the
answer.
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
31
Of course in any logically run country it would be im¬
possible for one of the great functionaries around the Queen to
belong to a religion other than that of the State, but in England
where compromise and expedience have such an advantage over
political theory, no one takes any notice of little anomalies such
as that. What is even more peculiar is that the Howards, contrary
to what is generally believed, are not an old Catholic family
which adhered to the Catholic faith through thick and thin in
tlie Reformation period. We have seen the denial of Catholicism
by tlie 4th Duke. After the restoration of Charles II which
brought with it the restoration of the Dukedom to the Howards,
we find that the 5th Duke was apparently a Protestant; as he had
brain fever from which his intellect never recovered it is perhaps
not quite fair to claim him for either religion, but he must have
conformed to the established church. The 6th Duke described
himself as having indelibly the character of a Papist and being
forced on that account to live out of England for most of his
time. The 7th Duke conformed to the Church of England by
publicly taking the sacrament in 1679, but this is not a proof of
his religious belief; dissenters often took Communion in the
Church of England when they wanted to obtain office (this
happened in the case of the Chamberlain family) and as the 7th
Duke held several offices it is quite possible that he remained a
Catholic in secret while appearing a Protestant in public. The
8th Duke was probably a Protestant because he was a Mason
and Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of England in 1729. The
9th Duke was rather a throw back to an earlier period. Not only
was he a Catholic but he is the sole instance in the last 300 years
of a Duke of Norfolk acting dangerously in political matters.
He was actually tried for high treason owing to his part in the
Jacobite rebellion in 1715, but was acquitted.
The religion of the 10th Duke is not clear. The 11th Duke
began as a Catholic, but gave up that religion in 1780 when the
Gordon riots were at their height. He too was a distinguished
Freemason. The next and 12th Duke who came from a more
distant line was a CathoHc, and it was in his favour that the Act
of 1824 was passed. Under the Roman Catholic Relief Act he
32
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
was able to take his seat in the Lords in 1829. His son, however,
the 13th Duke, left the Church of Rome and joined the Church
of England in 1851 at the very time when after a wave of
Anglican conversions to Rome, the Pope had decided to set up
an R.C. hierarchy in England. It is not clear whether the 14th
Duke was a convert to Catholicism but he certainly was a keen
Catholic and so was his son the 15th Duke who was the lay
leader of the Roman Catholic Communion in England. The 15th
Duke was responsible for the building at Arundel of that curious
looking excrescence on the hill above the meadows of the Arun,
the church of St. Philip Neri. There was of course already there
the old church of Arundel which has a chapel for the burial of
the Dukes of Norfolk and which contains numerous memorials
of them, but to a devout Catholic this was no good. There had
to be brought into the English scene a building which would
look more in keeping at Liseux, the shrine of the Little Flower
of Jesus in Normandy, but which is out of keeping witli the
atmosphere of Arundel. Similarly Irish tenants were brought
into the district. The 15th Duke had a hard cross to bear. To any
father, the illness — incurable illness — of an only son would be
bad enough but to the possessor of a great title and estates it is
even worse. Philip, Earl of Arundel, was an invalid from birth.
Prayers and pilgrimages, and how earnest must they have been,
availed nothing. He died at the age of 22. The Duke remarried in
1904 and after the birth of a daughter was rewarded with
another son, the present Duke.
Here then is the story of the Howards, their rise to greatness
and the hazards they have run, only to subside very sensibly into
the enjoyment and the responsibilities of a great estate and
position. It is easy to describe the present Duke as hidebound by
tradition and prejudice. When it was suggested that television
should be used in the Abbey, it was at once rejected by the
Coronation Commission and it was only after public agitation
had made it clear that the people wanted to see the crowning of
their sovereign that the project went through. It was a sarcasm
that the Duke when asked about televising the Coronation,
w'as supposed to have remarked They didn't have it in 1135,
THE HOUSE OF HOWARD
33
what?' In fact, the Duke must be seen as the product of his
family and unbringing, like everyone else. Imagine what it must
be like to be, at tlie age of 9, Duke of Norfolk, hereditary Earl
Marshal, with vast responsibilities, not only in this world but in
the next; at every step sometliing is expected of the Duke, he
must go to the Oratory School, not to the less devout life of an
English public school. When he weds the daughter of a Protes¬
tant family, tlie lady is expected to seek instruction in the
Catholic faith and cliildren of the mariage must be brought up as
Catliolics. And so it goes on. Not one dead hand but a multitude
stretch out to guide or push, constrain or frustrate the Duke in the
ways of the world. There is no further eminence to wliich he can
attain. He cannot very well enter politics, though he has been
Mayor of Arundel and Vice-Chairman of the West Sussex
County Council, but even these appointments are not, as tliey
would be in the case of an ordinary man, matters which he has
necessarily sought out, but matters wliich are expected of him.
Here is the zenith of greatness in a family, and under the
conditions which prevailed until 40 years ago, it would have
been possible for the Dukes of Norfolk to have slumbered their
way through office, and through a decorous discharge of their
duties. Now a horrible shadow has fallen across the princely
inheritance. When the Duke succeeded to his estates on coming
of age in 1929, 50,000 acres were in Norfolk ownership, with the
glorious seat of the family at Arundel Castle, a dream fortress
whispering all the romance of Arthurian legend as it rises from
the trees. How much of that inheritance remains now, for the
Duke has had to sell some of his property? Taxation stalks ever
more closely the walls which military enemies have never been
able to overthrow. It is a sad thought that unless there is some
alleviation in the taxation of landed estates, or unless some
special provision is made to allow the Duke to entail or insure his
estates against confiscatory taxation, not even Arundel Castle
itself may be free from the threat of sale.
Occasionally one hears even now the tale of the tenure of tlie
Earldom of Arundel, one of the Duke*s titles, by the holding of
Arundel Castle. This has been disposed of by a ruling of the
34
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
House of Lords in 1861 in the Berkeley Case (and by an Act of
Charles I annexing Arundel Castle to the Earldom in tail), but
at least it has one merit — it draws attention to what is a scan¬
dal. A man in the position of the Duke should have no need to
concern himself about the possibilities of sale. He should be
guaranteed a proper estate free from taxation of the predatory
kind, in order that he may carry out duties which seven centuries
of English history have assigned to him.
Chapter two
WESTMINSTER
THE HOUSE OF GROSVENOR
‘ Y T is Lordship would be glad to know on what grounds the
XX Norman descent of the Grosvenors is denied, why it is
asserted that tlie Grosvenors determined to make their fortunes
by manning and how the particular marriage helped to make
tlieir fortune.’
This was the gist of a letter forwarded to me by the editor of
the Tatler folloNving upon an article of mine in that periodical,
which concerned the late Duke of Westminster’s family. The
Duke’s secretary had written for an explanation of some of my
statements. I replied via the editor of the Tatler.
The points raised in the letter from His Grace’s secretary are
answered as follows:
‘1. The authorities whereby the descent from William The
Conqueror s time is denied. By this is meant descent from a
Companion of the Conqueror. In Vol. 1. of the Ancestor, of 1902,
edited by Oswald Barron is an article by W. H. B. Bird on The
Grosvenor Myth, pages 166—188. The modern criticism of the
Norman descent of the Grosvenors is thus some 50 years old.
See also Burke’s Peerage, current edition (i.e. 1949). The pedi¬
gree which is based on documents is dated from about 1160; the
older account which derived the family from a Norman, Gilbert
le Grosvenor was a tradition without documentary support.
2. The assertion that the Grosvenors determined to make their
fortunes by marrying. 'By a long series of fortunate marriages,
from the heiress of Pulford to the famous milkmaid of Ebury it
35
36
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
has risen in wealth and consequence.’ W. H. B. Bird says this in
the work quoted above, page 166. Under the life of Sir Thomas
Grosvenor 3rd Bt. (bom 1656) in the Dictionary of National
Biography, Vol 8 article by H. R. Tedder F. S. A. there is the
following: ‘In 1676 young Thomas Grosvenor laid the foundation
of his family’s wealth by marrying at the Ghurch of St Clement
Danes Strand, London, Mary aged 11, only daughter and heiress
of Alexander Davies, a scrivener. The rector of St. Clement
Danes, the girl’s grandfather who had Cheshire connections,
encouraged her early marriage, but husband and wife did not
live together for some years. Her marriage portion consisted of
a large sum of ready money and a considerable estate known
as Ebury farm, towards Chelsea, over which Belgrave Square
and Pimlico now extend and another large holding between
Tyburn Brook and Park Lane, on part of which Grosvenor Square
was afterwards built.'
‘Also in D.N.B. Vol 8 page 726, article on Robert Grosvenor,
2nd Earl Grosvenor and 1st Marquess of Westminster, we read
that he married Eleanor, daughter and subsequently sole heiress
of Thomas Egerton, Earl of Wilton and thus acquired the ex¬
tensive Egerton estates with the Earldom and Viscounty of Wil¬
ton entailed upon his second son.
‘3. How the particular marriage helped to make their fortunes.
Eaton was acquired by the marriage with the heiress. Eaton is
still after 500 years the seat and property of the family so I pre¬
sume it was of value.'
Thus in a heavily referenced note I was able to sum up the
case against the traditional story of the descent of the Grosvenors
from a companion of the Conqueror, who was described in a
mixture of Latin and French as a Gros Veneur or Grossovenator.
Needless to say in former times most peerage books carried the
story, but it has disappeared from responsible genealogy for at
least 60 years. In fact, the Grosvenors are the almost classic
example of the steady rise of an English family from a lowly
position as small landowners to the highest rank in the peerage.
Compared with that of Grosvenor the rise of the Howards is
swift. 216 years only separate the first mention of a Howard as
THE HOUSE OF GROSVENOR
37
a yeoman landowner from the time when the representative of
the family was made Duke of Norfolk and Earl Marshal.
On the other hand, in the family of Grosvenor. nearly 500
years intervene between the first mention of an authentic ances¬
tor and the first hereditary title held by them. A Baronetcy was
conferred on Richard Grosvenor in 1621, but his ancestor Robert
le Grosvenor who lived at Budworth in Cheshire had a grant of
land there from Hugh Kevelioc, Earl of Chester about 1160. The
family resembles a mighty oak tree, which has grown slowly but
at last after many ages has attained a huge growth and spread
out numerous branches. For several generations the Grosvenors
were content to be small landowners at Budworth and Hulme
until Robert le Grosvenor, great-great grandson of the first
Robert did homage to the Abbot of Vale Royal for the Manor
of Lostoke (now Allostock) in 1305. Both this Robert and his
father had served the office of High Sheriff of Chester. That
position had not in the Middle Ages the important social
distinction which the Sheriffship has acquired, now that it has
hardly any practical use. (A Sheriff of a county may have to
officiate at a hanging if an>thing goes wrong, e.g. if the hang¬
man’s nerve fails; there are hardly any other duties which one
can think of, but on the other hand the emblazoned banner of a
Sheriff has to be hung out during his year of office, which of
course is a matter of kudos for his family).
The Grosvenors gradually obtained the position of knights;
probably from the earliest times they had had the duty of ser¬
ving as horsemen in the Royal army. It was wth one of these
knights, Sir Robert Grosvenor. that the family first attained fame,
but not in a very satisfactory manner. In the year 1385, King
Richard II, then only a young man, invaded Scotland and led his
army as far as Aberdeen. He was attended by many of the most
distinguished knights who had served in the wars of his grand¬
father Edward III. Among these was Sir Richard Scrope, first
Lord Scrope of Bolton, who had held high office at the Court,
being at various times Chancellor of England, Treasurer, and
Steward of the Household. Such a man was among the greatest
of the barons of England; indeed the Scropes became so power-
38
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
fill under Richard II that they aroused inevitable jealousy and
fell into disgrace and danger when King Richard himself was
pushed off the throne by his cousin Henry IV. However in 1385
Scrope was a force to be reckoned vidth, as Sir Robert Grosvenor
was to discover. His arms were azure a bend or (a blue field with
a gold bend across it from right to left). As he rode through the
English camp in Scotland, Scrope was surprised, amazed and
finally indignant to observe the same coat of arms displayed
above the tent of a person with whom, as far as he knew, he had
no blood relationship whatever. A dispute immediately began
between Scrope and the owner of the second coat of arms. Sir
Robert Grosvenor who was a simple knight of the palatinate of
Chester and as we have seen, a tenant of the Abbot of Vale
Royal, had indeed considerable hardihood to stand up to Lord
Scrope. What follows is typically and amusingly English.
As neither side would give in, there was only one thing to do,
and that was to summon the Court of Chivalry, the same Court
which sat as recently as 1954 after an hibernation of 219 years.
The Court was primarily that of the Earl Marshal and was con¬
cerned with matters of army discipline. One can almost hear
mutterings about conduct to the prejudice of good order and
discipline being made in the mess by people who resented
Scrope’s position. It was necessary to take all sorts of depositions
from many witnesses. There were 200 witnesses on Grosvenor’s
side alone, and for Scrope there were many and important per¬
sons who were prepared to testify that the arms in dispute be¬
longed to him. The evidence as it has come down to us fills
two large quarto volumes edited by Sir Harris Nicolas. The
sittings of the Court cannot have been concluded while the army
was in Scotland. Indeed they must have occupied 4 years. The
findings are most interesting for students, apart from the
technicalities of heraldry. Part of Chaucer’s life is dated by the
case, for the deponents gave their ages; John of Gaunt appeared
on behalf of Scrope; Owen Glendower was one of Grosvenor s
witnesses. When the Court did reach a decision, which was
after sittings which would have equalled those of a modern
Royal Commission, it was in Scrope’s favour, but with permission
THE HOUSE OF GROSVENOR
39
for Grosvenor to bear the arms with a bordure for difference.
The decision was inevitably in favour of the great lord who had
the King's uncle as his friend; but the privilege of retaining the
arms in bulk, so to speak, was a great concession, and was pro¬
bably inspired by the fact that a few years earlier there had been
another dispute on the same subject between Scrope and a
Cornish squire, Carminow of Carminow. In this latter case, Scrope
had argued that his family was Norman, and that tlieir arms had
been borne from that time; Carminow side-tracked that claim by
the bland statement that his ancestor who first bore the arms
had been a knight of Arthur's Table. In that dispute Carminow
had come off with the arms intact.
Grosvenor refused to accept the compromise, and appealed to
the Crown. Richard II acted with promptness and appointed
commissioners to rehear the case. When they reported, the King
who was by this time (1390) beginning the arbitrary courses
which led to his deposition, at once ordered Grosvenor to give
up the arms, as the proposed difference mark was insufficient
to distinguish the arms of two persons who were not related by
blood. He also awarded the costs of the action against the
defendant, Grosvenor.
In the dispute before the Court, both sides had argued that
they were of Norman blood. Scrope seems not to have bothered
with proof of this, but Grosvenor got his landlord, the Abbot, to
produce a pedigree from the charters in his muniment chest.
All sorts of mythical Grosvenors were brought out from this
source, but the main item of interest is the proof that so long
ago in our history, the best people were convinced that theii’
ancestors had come over with the Conqueror. Scrope could not
show unbroken descent back to the Conquest period, though his
name is of Norse-Norman origin, meaning a crab; he was very
probably of Norman ancestry, but there is no assurance of the
same thing with Grosvenor. The legend of the Grand Hunter of
the Dukes of Normandy is not heard of in the case, so it was
either overlooked or came into existence later. Here with Gros¬
venor, as with Howard we come upon the possibility of a native
Engbsh origin. Learned evidence has been adduced to show that
40
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
there were foresters during the early Plantagenet period who
were named Grosvenor. This is really adding insult to injury,
for if we cannot accept the story of the Great Hunter, it is surely
significant to discover that some Grosvenors were simple
foresters (i.e. game keepers).
In truth in the case of Grosvenor we have par excellence the
example of a family rising gradually by steady degrees until it
reached the zenith of greatness. As is usual in such cases the
heads of the family in later times tend to view their ancestry
through a magnifying glass and refuse to see the humbler an¬
cestors from whom they spring.
Unmindful of future greatness for his family, Sir Robert
Grosvenor was most upset when he heard the King’s decision. It
was a costly sentence for him and so much did it unnerve him
that he lowered his dignity to beg his successful rival to intercede
for him that part of the fine (for it amounted to that) should be
remitted.
Perhaps it was the loss of revenue which made other gene¬
rations of the family so conscious of the need to obtain wealthy
alliances. Sir Robert’s son, Raulfe le Grosvenor who was living
in 1447, married a Cheshire heiress, Joan, the daughter of John
Eton, or Eaton, a place which became the principal seat of the
Grosvenors. For several generations the Grosvenors continued to
play the part of small country gentlemen who sometimes attained
the honour of knighthood. They made good marriages, including
(two generations after Raulfe’s time), one with the heiress of
Richard Cotton. In 1621 the family began the round of the
English cursus honorum, by obtaining a baronetcy from James I.
Sir Richard Grosvenor, the first baronet, must have been a man
of ample means because James I did not give honoms for no¬
thing. Any surprise which we may feel about the sale of honours
in modem times (£10,000 for a knighthood, £12,000 for a
baronetcy, according to Mr. Maundy Gregorys tariffs!) would
not have been shared by our Jacobean ancestors. There was no
disguise about the fact that the Order of Baronets, founded in
1611 was to be recruited from the wealthy. James did agree to
make baronets only of men whose pedigrees commanded respect.
THE HOUSE OF GROSVENOR
41
but such men had to be prepared to put down 1,000 to meet
the requirements of the King s coffers. Consequently while Sir
Richard Grosvenor was certainly of the type to merit a baronetcy,
we know that he would have had to meet James* scale of charges
in the matter.
By the time of the famous marriage with the so-called milk¬
maid the family had become impoverished and consequently was
on the lookout for a wealthy alliance. This was found in the
person of poor Mary Davis, who eventually went out of her
mind. Her fortune set the family up and it may have been that
her husband Sir Thomas Grosvenor foresaw what the expansion
of London would ultimately mean to his new holdings in Pim¬
lico and Mayfair. The 600 acres of the London property were
worth much more than 6000 acres of good agricultural land in
the country.
The habit of marrying witli heiresses did not desert the
Grosvenors after their first successes. The 4tli Baronet, Sir
Richard took as his second wife Diana, the only daughter (words
which hint at the possibility of fortune) of Sir George Warbur-
ton. Few men in the upper or propertied classes then married
without the likelihood of fortune in their wives.
One of Sir Richard’s sons the 6th Baronet married Jane Ware,
an heiress of Somersetshire. This persistence in business had its
reward, for the son of the 6th Baronet was created in 1761 Baron
Grosvenor of Eaton, and in 1784, Viscount Belgrave and Earl
Grosvenor. The Marquessate followed in 1831 and the Dukedom
of Westminster was created in 1874 for the 3rd Marquess. He
was a Liberal peer who had been a great admirer of Gladstone,
but who in later years removed the latter’s portrait from his
house, when he did not agree with Gladstone’s policy.
Meanwhile with the gro\vth of the family in wealth and
power, there went a determination to uphold the Grosvenor past
as something much grander than it really had been. The
Christian names of Lupus, Hugh, etc began to appear, reminis¬
cent of the claim to descend from Hugh the Great Hunter of
Norman days. Nor were the arms of the family forgotten. After
the decision of Richard II, Sir Robert Grosvenor had been
42
TALES OF THE BFUTISH ARISTOCRACY
compelled to forego the old arms, and to adopt (for himself,
\vithout benefit of the Heralds) azure a garb or. This was in
reference to the old arms of Cheshire. The arms it will be noted
were simply assumed, i.e. the Grosvenors followed a normal
custom, as appears to have been the case generally before the
Heralds Visitations in the time of the Tudors. But the arms lost
in 1390 were not forgotten. Every so often a reminder was given
of the old azure a bend or. The first Duke kept a racing stable,
and Bend Or was one of his winners, indeed a Derby winner in
1880. The second Duke who died in 1954 had a nickname. Bend
Or, which sorely puzzled those who were not in his confidence
or did not know the history of his family.
The position held by the first Duke (and his successor) in
society was splendid and opulent. It required little imagination
to suppose that a family of such grandeur should have a most
distinguished ancestry, going far back to Norman times. The
obscurity of the earlier history was forgotten in the golden glow
of greatness which distinguished the Grosvenors in our time, and
in the Victorian period. The late (2nd) Duke was usually re¬
ferred to in the press as Britain’s wealthiest peer. He owned
estates in Cheshire, Ireland, France and of course in London. It
was not so much the acreage of his possessions, for many a
Scottish laird or peer had much more extensive property. It was
the value of those golden City acres and the skill in investment
of the 2nd Duke. The latter had shares in Canadian industry as
well as in Britain; and large sums of ready money.
Yet huge possessions are not enough. They have to be taken
care of and passed on to successors. Naturally, a man in such a
quasi regal position wanted a son of his own to succeed him.
The 2nd Duke had a son, Edward George Hugh, Earl Grosvenor.
Alas, the melancholy entry reads, born 16 November, 1904; died
13 February, 1909. By his first wife, the Duke had in addition
two daughters, but no other son was ever bom to him. One can
understand how ardently he longed for one; in 1919 he had a
divorce from his first wife, who had been Miss Constance Com-
wallis-West; in 1920 he married Violet Mary, formerly wife of
George Richard Francis Rowley, and youngest daughter of Sir
THE HOUSE OF GROSVENOR
43
William Nelson. This marriage was dissolved by divorce in 1926.
In 1930 he married Loelia, only daughter of Lord Sysonby; and
in 1947, after divorce from his third wife, he married Anne
Winifred Sullivan. One of the favourite sports of tlie British
press was to put in a rumour that special apartments at Eaton
Hall, reserved for accouchements, were being prepared. There
was always an inevitable denial, for none of the Duke s last
three wives bore him any children. Owing to the peculiar nature
of the British divorce laws, there were usually at any one time
three or four Duchesses of Westminster in society. When a
marriage has been terminated by divorce, the wife retains the
right to use her former husband’s surname. This may have value
in the case of Mrs. Smith or Jones, for a married woman has a
certain prestige, she has at least gained a man in the marriage
lottery even though she has lost him aftei^vards. On remarriage
to Mr. Robinson, the lady gives up her Smith or Jones title; but
this does not always follow when the first husband has been
titled and the second is plain Mr. there is a strong tendency for
the former wife, even when she has become Mrs. Jones, to call
herself, Xenia, Duchess of Belgravia.
In consequence of the late Duke’s matrimonial adventures,
there were three or four ladies who had heen Duchesses of
Westminster and who retained the title as a sort of souvenir.
When someone spoke of a Duchess of Westminster, it was almost
necessary to consult the guide books to the aristocracy to know
which of the Duke’s former partners was meant, or perchance
was it the current one?
Whatever the position of the Duke in matters matrimonial
there could be no doubt of his vast wealth. He was often referred
to as Britain s wealthiest peer. His fortune was estimated at be¬
tween £.10,000,000 and £20,000,000; when his estate was made
public it was estimated at around £5,000,000. How surprised the
honest old Cheshire knight Sir Robert Grosvenor would have
been if he could have seen the huge wealth of his descendant,
17 or so generations after his day. The Duke stood much higher
in the peerage than the Lord Scrope of Bolton who had over¬
ridden his ancestor. The latter was but a baron, tlie lowest
44
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
degree in the peerage, the former was in the highest degree.
Moreover, Westminster was the last non-royal dukedom to be
created. Since 1874 every dukedom which has been created has
been conferred either upon royalty or upon persons who marry
into the royal family, like Fife or Edinburgh.
Sir Robert Grosvenor would have been pleased with his
wealthy descendant He might pardonably have looked around
for his old antagonist’s family, Scrope’s. He would not have
found them among the peers. Peerage had long since departed
from the house of Scrope. Today the representative of the great
house which had once seemed to hold England in fee is a
simple country squire, Mr. Scrope of Danby. It is a splendid
instance of the changes wrought by time. One family has gone
up, the other has gone back, or at least not advanced. No title
now graces the Scropes, not even a knighthood.
Yet there is no real cause for gratification on either side. The
Scropes adhered to the Roman Catholic religion in the Refor¬
mation period. They were then persecuted but they kept
their faith. They were allowed to keep their land. The Gros-
venors changed their faith in the approved manner, when the
Tudor sovereign ordered it; they went on increasing and
glorifying their greatness, but to-day one inevitable result faces
all families of eminence. To parody Job’s words, all families are
now one. One end awaits them all.
The second Duke of Westminster was one of the last, if not
the last, of the grand seigneurs. Fortunately we still have many
representatives of our ancient aristocracy who look the part but
as often as not they simply have not sufficient means to keep up
their positions. The Duke of Westminster — Bend Or — had the
means still to indulge in the gestures which the English public
have always liked to associate with their patricians. For instance
on the occasion of his third marriage he remitted a weeks rent
to all his tenants. The wiU for this sort of thing is present with
many noblemen, but they have to be content with inviting two
coach-loads of country tenants up to London for their weddings.
The Duke had his boar hounds on his Normandy estate (very
appropriate for one who claimed to descend from the court
THE HOUSE OF GROSVENOR
45
Nimrod of Norman times); in Canada his investments were
sufficient to merit attention in any survey of Canadian economic
life. At his home in Cheshire it was a commonplace that he
possessed a library of 10,000 volumes and an organ suitable for
a small church. That home, Eaton Hall, had been reconstructed
several times from its comparatively humble beginnings. In the
form in which it now is, it has tlie wall paintings and fireplace
carvings similar to those we see in Cardiff Castle. It represents
an immense sum of money but it stands in fact as one of the last
representatives of a vanished age. Today, it is a centre for
officers or would-be officers of the British Army on their training
courses; during the last war it was put to service use, and has
never reverted to private occupation. With such vast wealth it is
not likely that even the demands of modem death duties will at
one stroke entirely dismember the Grosvenor estate, but the sun
of its glory has set forever. The best that can be done is to con¬
serve what is left of the properties in the hope that tlie successors
of the Duke Nvill not die too soon. A millionaire estate pays more
than half its value to the Kxchequer; moreover the value of the
estate is assessed by the very department which requires payment.
In any event when vast quanties of shares or landed properties
are suddenly thrust upon the market with the necessity of their
sale within a short time, their value drops and much that is
worth-while is acquired for a comparatively low sum.
To have lasted 800 years a great EngUsh family must have
survived all manner of changes and hazards. It has been left
for our own time, when internally there is far less likelihood of
violence and revolution, for such a family to face a ruin far worse
than anything it braved in the Wars of the Roses, the Black
Death, or the tyranny of the Roundheads. In olden days a man
or a woman might steel himself or herself to die rather than
give up cherished lands, but an heroic death now merely means
that a larger sum \vill pass more quickly to the tax gatherer.
There are several members of the Grosvenor family still left;
the present and third Duke is William Grosvenor of whom
peerage books record that he was bom on 23 December 1894; if
he should die unmarried he will be succeeded by one of liis
46
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
cousins just as he succeeded the' second duke in 1954. There
will never again however be any Duke of Westminster to hold
the position of his predecessors in the social life of Britain. So the
glory of a great house departs merely because enormous sums of
money have to be found to pay for a welfare state and for
insanely conceived wars.
Chapter three
NELSON
THE HOUSE OF NELSON
O n the evening of 21st October 1805 the remnants of the
French and Spanish fleets were escaping from Trafalgar;
the most momentous naval battle in the history of the world had
ended with the destruction by the British navy of Napoleon’s sea
power. For another ten years the French Emperor would miirch
liis armies up and down Europe until at last he met an over¬
whelming combination on land, but he would never again be
able to bid for the mastery of the sea. England was safe from
invasion and was free to follow her traditional policy of building
up continental opposition to a would-be European conqueror.
The price — in the cockpit of tlie British flag-ship, the Victory,
there lay dying Horatio Nelson Rear-Admiral of the Blue,
Viscount Nelson of the Nile in the Peerage of Great Britain, and
Duke of Bronte by decree of the King of Naples. He died as he
had wished in action against the French and just before he died
his words were ‘Remember that I leave Lady Hamilton and my
daughter to my country, never forget Horatia'.
Every honour which could be paid to the hero, except that of
carrying out his dying wishes, was rendered to Nelson. There
was a State funeral after two lyings-in-state. one at Greenwich
Hospital and the other at the Admiralty. The body was buried
in St Paul’s Cathedral and thereafter the British government
seemed to be obsessed with the desire of rewarding financially
every member of the Nelson familiy. The widow. Lady Nelson,
had £.2,000 a year settled on her by Act of Parliament. £.10,000
47
48
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
was given to each of Nelson’s two sisters. The greatest rewards
however went to his brother the Bev. William Nelson whom the
Admiral had only been persuaded to take to sea after a great
deal of hesitation and reluctance. After all Horatio knew what
William was like. However the Naval Chaplain now had good
reason to be thankful for the accident which had made him a
brother of the Admiral. He came in for the Earldom which
would have been granted to Nelson, as the victor of Trafalgar,
had he lived. He was granted £.10,000 to buy an estate and with
this he purchased the former Trafalgar House property in
Hampshire. In order that he should not suffer any embarrass¬
ment in keeping up his estate, a pension of £.5,000 a year was
granted by Parliament to be attached to the Earldom. Even¬
tually it turned out that £90,000 came out of the consolidated
fund whereby the estate was to be purchased. It was also
ordained by tlie same Act of Parliament (46 George III, 1806)
that the name of Nelson was to be taken by every inheritor of
the title. The first Earl Nelson, (the Naval Chaplain) was un¬
lucky in his family for his only son died unmarried in the life¬
time of his father, and it was therefore arranged by special
remainder that the title should pass to the heirs male of the
body of his sister, Mrs Bolton, and failing them to the heirs
male of the body of his other sister, Mrs Matcdiam. Thus the
second Earl Nelson was Thomas Bolton, who had of course to
take the name of Nelson in accordance with the Act, and it is
from him that the sixth and present Earl Nelson descends. In
1947 under the first post-war Labour government the pension
was terminated and the estate was sold. Whatever may be
thought of the government’s action, it could be, and it was,
pointed out at the time that the State had paid £700.000 to the
Nelson family under the Act of 1806; not a bad endowment,
especially as not a penny of it ever went to man whom it was
intended to honour or to his descendants. For what happened to
Lady Hamilton? She soon had to leave Merton Place and her
lodgings in Bond Street were soon too dear for her. Her mother,
who was her best friend, died and the annuity which Nelson had
left to her secured upon his Bronte estate was very irregularly
The Duke of Norfolk
Thomas William
THE HOUSE OF NELSON
49
paid. By 1813 Lady Hamilton was living in some miserable
rooms in the region of the Temple, but illness and debt soon
removed her thence. Eventually most of her debts were paid by
friends, and she was enabled to live in France, but she was in
very great distress at the time of her death, and was reduced to
borrowing sums of £10 from Earl Nelson, a man who if he gave
any help at all gave it Nvith foul and brutal language, in such a
manner that it would have been better withheld. Fortunately,
the life of Horatia was happy. When Nelson was going away on
his last departure from Merton he had knelt down by the little
girl’s bedside when she was fast asleep and prayed that she
might be happy; she was, for she had inherited none of the
dangerous talents of her parents, nor the beauty of her mother.
She was in fact a throw-back to the Nelson forbears and with
her somewhat bovine intelligence she settled down to a happy
life with a country parson, the Rev. Philip Ward whom she
married in 1822. Horatia was known as Miss Thompson, a name
which had been adopted by Nelson and Lady Hamilton when
they wanted to correspond about the child without other people
kno\ving what was meant. Thompson was supposed to be a
young sailor on board the Victory who was going to do right by
his Fanny as soon as he got ashore; in the meantime his letters
were full of affection for his daughter. Whatever may have been
thought by members of the public of the association of Nelson
and his Emma, the news of the birth of the child was hushed up.
The baby was boarded out with an honest widow when eight days
old, and so well was the secret preserved that the child herself
never knew her parentage, though she lived to be 81. She
looked upon Lady Hamilton as her guardian, and never learned
from the latter the name of either of her parents. On her
tombstone Mrs Ward, who died in 1881, was described as the
adopted daughter of Vice Admiral Lord Nelson. Nelson himself
had unwittingly added to the mystery of the child’s parentage by
referring to her in a note as his daughter but adding that her
mother was too great to be mentioned. It was even suggested
that this was a reference to the Queen of Naples. Eventually in
1889 a number of letters of Nelson s and Lady Hamilton's were
50
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
found and any doubt on the parentage was disposed of forever.
The descendants of Lord Nelson, in the female line, are the
modem family of Nelson Ward which bears the arms of Ward
quartering Nelson. This is a family of good social position for
whom the State has done nothing whatever to honour the Nelson
connection, unless a permission from Queen Victoria for Mrs
Ward to assume by Royal Licence the name of Nelson can be
so regarded.
It is a nice point for a moralist to consider how he would
frame a Sunday sermon on the subject of Nelson's rewards
from the State. One text which could be used would soon spring
to mind — ‘The wages of sin is death'. There is no argument that
Nelson had a wife and Emma had a husband when their love
affair began, in fact Lady Nelson outlived her husband by 26
years. Sir William Hamilton always professed himself the great
friend and admirer of Nelson and the latter always spoke of Sir
William in the highest terms. Sir William died in the arms of
Emma while Nelson held his hand. None the less the affair was
going on, and Horatia was conceived on board the Foudroyant
while Nelson was conveying the Hamiltons back to England.
Nelson was so much in love that he refers to Emma in many of
his letters to her as his wife, his language being so emotional
as to be at times incoherent. The way would seem to be clear
for our sermonizer to show that the two lovers had indulged an
illicit passion and that Lady Hamilton had met her just deserts,
while the State's failure to carry out Nelson’s wishes was merely
an example of divine justice on the sinner.
On the other hand it would be equally easy and much more
sensible to make another sermon on the well-worn words Put
not thy trust in princes’, if by princes we mean the governing
power. Nelson’s services to this country were so eminent that
the brightness of his fame can never be tarnished by the mere
fact that for the first time in his life he had fallen truly in love
with a beautiful and talented woman, the vidfe of an elderly man
whose mistress she had been, and who had had several c^ual
love affairs which had left no impression on her heart. Two
brilliant people, one of them the hero of his country, met in
THE HOUSE OF NELSON
51
circumstances the most conducive to romance; a semi-tropical
setting in Southern Italy, at the brilliant Neapolitan court, with
a woman who was the confidant of the Queen of Naples and
used herself to being the centre of a salon, pouring adulation
upon the hero. Add to this that Nelson greatly desired a family,
which the widow whom he had married never gave to him. A
few years of interrupted happiness, snatched in the intervals of
duty and the hero is killed at the age of 47 in saving his country
from her greatest peril after the Spanish Armada. It would be
easy to prove that the most hateful of human vices, spite, bit¬
terness and a loathsome sanctimonious hypocrisy, had been
employed to avoid carrying out Nelson’s wishes. As it has turned
out the only result which is now left of the State’s vast
endowment of the name of Nelson is the existence of the Earl¬
dom. When one realizes the character of morals around the year
1806 among the ruling classes, hypocritical is the only adjective
which can be applied to their conduct regarding Nelson.
In the case of Norfolk and Westminster we have a steady rise
of a great familiy. In Nelson’s case there is only one man of
eminence in the history of the family and from him the modem
family do not descend. We often hear of the expression ‘Direct
descendant’ but of course there is really nothing else but a
direct descendant. Sometimes one can refer to collateral descen¬
dants, by which we mean people descended from a brother or
sister of the one whose name they share. The whole Nelson line
comes from Nelson’s brothers and sisters, and his appearance is
that of an unexplained genius. Just as no one can explain the
sudden appearance of WiUiam Shakespeare in a family of small
>eomen (the Shakespeares) and small gentry (the Ardens, his
mothers family), so no one can explain the phenomenon of the
greatest seaman of all time appearing in a family of smaU gentry
and country parsons. The Nelson family is traced back in
ItT! ® Mawdesley who was living in
1377. Attempts to prove that the name is derived from the Norse
Nedson ^e somewhat fanciful. About the end of the 16th
century the Nelsons settled in Norfolk and Admiral Nelson was
the son and grandson of clergymen both of whom bore the name
52
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
of Edmund. Through his mother, the Admiral was connected
with the Walpole family and with various other lines of gentle
blood. The family was however poor, and the Rev. Edmund
Nelson had great difficulty in launching his children in life. The
eldest boy, Maurice, was a clerk in the Navy office; one other
beside Earl Nelson became a parson. Horatio was the only one
to serve as a combatant in the Royal Navy. Two other brothers,
William and Suckling were in Holy Orders; the former was the
Naval chaplain who received the earldom. Susannah and Cathe¬
rine were the sisters, and three other sons had died young.
Nelson’s family were connected with various county families
and his mother, Catherine Suckling, was descended from the
Walpoles from whom the name Horatio was derived. Nelson’s
uncle was Captain Maurice Suckling of Woodton and it was
probably through his service in the Navy that Nelson conceived
the idea of going to sea. His father the rector was only too
anxious to place his children in suitable situations and when
Captain Maurice was appointed to commander the Raisonnable,
a sixty-four gun ship which was being recommissioned in the
winter of 1770—71 an opportunity occurred. She was originally
a French ship and was being converted for service with the
Navy. Nelson read about this and at the age of twelve begged
his father to write to Captain Suckling so that he could accom¬
pany him to sea. The reply was in the following terms ‘What
has poor Horace done, who is so weak, that he above all the
rest should be sent to rough it out at sea? but let him come;
and the first time we go into action, a cannon ball may knock off
his head, and provide for him at once.*
In this happy-go-lucky manner, at the age of 12 years and
three months, there began the sea career of the worlds greatest
admiral. When he was killed he was 47 years of age and of his
35 years in the Navy he had spent 5 years on the beach, from
1787—1793, not from choice of course but because he was unable
to secure employment. His sea career was therefore confined to
30 years, in which time he won three of the greatest naval battles
in history, and changed the course of human affairs. He was al¬
ways in action and was a glutton for fighting. He did not found
THE HOUSE OF NELSOH
53
the Royal Navy’s tradition of fighting no matter what the odds;
that was as old as the days almost of King Alfred, but Nelson is
the man who more than anyone else in the history of the Navy
has been the embodiment of the fighting spirit Not even a
Cunningham fighting against enormously superior odds in the
Mediterranean has put up a grander show than Nelson. The
terrible inshore fighting involved in rescuing our troops from
Dunkirk, Greece or Crete was a continuation of Nelson’s habit
of fighting close in to the enemy no matter what the current, the
shoals, or the rocks. ‘Engage the enemy closer was Nelson’s
favourite signal, and anyone who thrills at the sound of it could
be e.\cused for thinking of Nelson as some rugged sea-dog, a bluff
mountain of a man witli no thought or care for the finer things
in life.
What a contrast is presented when one looks at a portrait of
Lord Nelson. There is the famous and familiar painting by Lucy
'Lord Nelson in the cabin of theVicton/. Adreaming philosopher
sits before his desk. True, he has a gorgeous collection of stars
and decorations on his uniform, but if we were to overlook this
we might well think that the musing figure was that of a poet or
a thinker absorbed in reflections far removed from the harsh
realities of naval war. Again, in Abbott’s and Atkinson’s pictures
everything has been done to represent the naval hero, but the
face is even more than in Lucy’s picture that of a poet and
visionary. Nor do the facts of Nelson’s life marry to the face a
character different from what we should expect from the features.
The language of Nelson, not only in his passionate letters to his
Emma, or in his poems, or in the views which he expressed to
his wife, but also in his remarks in the very heat of action, all
bear out the impression of a mind which would have been as
much at home in the realms of art, or rather of other arts, as it
was in the art of naval warfare. No naval commander has ever
seen more quickly the weak spot in an opponent’s tactics than
Nelson. At Copenhagen he risked the existence of the British
fleet, and perhaps the future of Britain, upon the chance that he
could bring the fire of his ships to bear quickly and strongly
enough upon the Danish anchored fleet to overwhelm them and
54
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
tlieir supporting batteries before his ships could be grounded in
the dangerous channels of the Danish Sound. His daring and
skill are shown again and again in small cutting-out actions and
in events like the siege of Caivi where he lost an eye. At the
battle of the Nile when his pilot objected to the dangers of the
channel where the French ships lay. his reply was characteristic,
‘Where there is room for a French ship to lie, there is room for
a British ship beside her.’ 'Mark you, I would not be elsewhere
for thousands’, were his words when the hottest fire came on the
Elephant at Copenhagen.
The truth is that Nelson was a man of genius and of heroic
genius at that. There is no explanation for the appearance in a
family of such a personality. He could probably have succeeded
in other walks of life; we know that for a time he toyed with the
idea of entering politics and he was interested in his position as a
landlord when he became Duke of Bronte. He wanted to make
his Sicilian estate a model on the lines of those which he knew
in England. He was a lover of poetry, Shakespeare being his
favourite, and when he was under the pressure of amorous
emotion, which was not infrequently. Lady Hamilton being only
his last and greatest enchantress, he attempted to write poetry
himself.
A boyish love of adventure, coupled with the fact that his
uncle was in the Navy led Nelson to choose a naval career. He
suffered agonies from ill health throughout the whole period of
his service. The loss of an eye and the amputation of his right
arm were incidents of active service, but fever in the tropics,
indisposition after the battle of the Nile, trouble with his re¬
maining eye, sickness every time he went to sea, headaches and
vertigo were the lot of this great man. As long as his position
as a commander permitted him to do so, he was always the first
in boarding an enemy, and despite the fact of a puny physique,
he was always eager to take part in a hand to hand struggle. In
the North pole expedition when he was 13 Nelson was prepared
to fight a polar bear with a useless musket. By all the laws of
probability he should have been killed on a dozen different
occasions in his career long before he attained fame. Even more
THE HOUSE OF NELSON
55
dangerous to him than the enemy was the woodenness and
obscurantism of higher officers such as Hyde Parker or the
Admiralty. When reading of Nelson’s exploits one is reminded of
some remarks of Sir John Seeley in Ecce Homo, where he says
that conservative opposition to a great man will often give way
sufficiently for some of his ideas to be accepted. This however
is as far as the opposition will go and they then seek to bury
both the great man and his ideas; the reforms which he has
brought about are then formulated into a rigid system from
which there is no escape. To some extent this is what has hap¬
pened with regard to Nelson. The ‘Nelson touch’ has become
proverbial for daring, but should a Naval officer presume to use
it he may well think himself lucky if he escapes with a Court of
Enquiry. When the Bremen was making its way back to
Germany at the beginning of the 1939 war it was sighted by a
British submarine in the Baltic where Nelson had won his
greatest triumph over official timidity. It was impossible for this
submarine at the same time to take the Bremen captive and to
observe the ordinary rules of self-preservation, for German air¬
craft were approaching. The British commander therefore acted
according to the book and let the Bremen go. There was exal¬
tation in Germany over Brittannia’s failure to rule the waves.
Judging by what we know of Nelson he would have thought
only that the Bremen was an enemy ship and would have sunk
her. Officialdom has succeeded in canonizing Nelson as a naval
hero, but has equally succeeded in preventing others from follo¬
wing him. On Trafalgar day there is always a service and cele¬
bration below Nelson s Column in the Square. There are Nelson
relics in the United Service Museum and elsewhere; as for the
Victory it is treated like a shrine where reluctant ABs chant in a
sing-song manner a recital of the events which took place on the
quarter deck and in the cock-pit. Yet all this is of very little avail
if the spirit of the great man is not allowed to penetrate the
Service for which he lived.
Nelson’s greatest triumphs were won because he found a few
farseeing spirits who believed in him and gave him the chance
to carry out his plans. In the 18th century it took a long time
56
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
for news to reach England from the Mediterranean; two months
and a day for Nelson’s despatches to reach the Admiralty and
inform them of the victory of the Nile. There must have been
temble anxiety for Lord Minto and Lord Spencer who were
responsible for entrusting Nelson with the command. The in¬
spired statments with which we were all familiar in the news¬
papers in the last war, made their appearance in the journals of
1798. The favourite question was ‘Where is Napoleon?’ followed
by ‘Where is Nelson?’ All sorts of rumours circulated. It was
said that seven British warships had been lost. Matters were
made worse by false propaganda from France which used the
tactics of Goebbels, to tell a lie and go on telling it. The best
that the Admiralty hoped for was that Nelson would be able to
give a good reason for having missed the French fleet. This
made the truth all the more wonderful when it reached England.
The French fleet had been destroyed and Napoleon’s fine army
of 35,000 men was locked up in Egypt. His ambitious plans of
gaining control of the whole of the eastern Mediterranean and
then setting out for India to break up the British dominions
there, had now no chance of succeeding. England went wild with
joy and hardly anything was too good for Nelson. He was quickly
created a peer, and that of Great Britain, not of Ireland (a rather
inferior honour anyway); he had the thanks of Parliament,
£.2,000 a year for life and for the lives of his two immediate
successors; he got another £1,000 a year from the Irish Parlia¬
ment, which was near its end as a separate body, and £10,000
down from tlie East India Company. Officialdom was able to
prevent him from becoming a Viscount on the score that he had
not been in supreme command though no superior had accom¬
panied him. Within three years even officialdom had to give
way on this point and after the Battle of Copenhagen the
viscounty was bestowed upon him despite the fact that he was
second in command to Sir Hyde Parker. The reasons were stark
and simple; in 1801 the two Scandinavian countries, Denmark
and Sweden had agreed with Prussia and Russia to form an
alliance against Great Britain and to close the Baltic Sea to
British trade. It was imperative that a sea confederation of this
THE HOUSE OF NELSON
57
size hostile to Britain, should not be allowed to develope and
the fleet was at once ordered into the Baltic.
Had Nelson been in sole command he would have proceeded
straight to Riga in the Gulf of Finland where the Russian Fleet
lay held in the ice, and would have struck a shattering blow at
these unmanoeuvreable vessels. He very soon had Hyde Parker
much under his control but not to the extent of making him
venture so far from his base. In the result, the attack on Copen¬
hagen was sufficiently daring. It dissolved the Northern con¬
federation at one blow. The Danes capitulated and the Tsar,
who was half mad, made one of his erratic volte-faces. It was
of course on the occasion of the Battle of Copenhagen that
Nelson put his telescope to his blind eye; Sir Hyde Parker,
frantic with anxiety four miles away, was trying to get Nelson
to retreat, but with victory in his grasp he ignored the signal
and went on with his task.
Trafalgar was the culmination of an extraordinary series of
events. Napoleon knew that to establish himself permanently in
Europe he had to neutralize Great Britain. To do this he must
have command of the sea if only for a period, enough for him to
get his army across the Straits of Dover. Nelson was engaged in
1802 as were our bomber crews in 1940 in destroying flotillas
of small boats which were being prepared for the invasion of
England in the Channel ports of Northern France and the Low
Countries. At last after the short peace of Amiens, Napoleon saw
his chance. The British navy maintained a blockade of the
French Fleet especially in Toulon. The great object of Na¬
poleon was for his fleet to elude the blockade, get out of the
Mediterranean, into the English Channel and control the Straits
of Dover for a few hours while he landed 60,000 troops in Kent.
The first part of the plan succeeded and Villeneuve, the French
admiral, managed to escape from the blockade. Nelson searched
for him throughout the whole of the central and south eastern
Mediterranean and then acting on intuition rather dian
reasoning, concluded that Villeneuve had gone to the West
Indies. It was true. On the 9th of April Villeneuve had passed
the Straits of Gibraltar. Nelson followed him on the 7th May
58
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
and then began the long chase. Villeneuve may well have hoped
by crossing the Atlantic to have evaded the British Fleet al¬
together, and it would seem that he tried to make his way up
into the Channel. Nelson was speedier than he for while
Villeneuve left Antigua in the West Indies on the 8th June,
Nelson was only five days behind him. Villeneuve was turned
back off Cape Finisteire by an action with some ships com¬
manded by Rear Admiral Sir Robert Calder, and had fled down
the coast of Portugal to take shelter in Cadiz. Here he was joined
by the Spanish fleet and at length goaded by Napoleon’s orders
he sailed out to risk everything upon a battle. It is difficult to
see what else he could have done in view of the drastic nature
of Napoleon’s commands. Villeneuve survived the battle but his
fleet did not.
There has never been a national hero who has more stamped
himself upon the consciousness of his countrymen than Nelson.
From the Nile battle onwards pictures of Nelson began to appear
in prints, on mugs, on plates and many other household utensils.
His name became a proverb for daring; his blind eye to the
telescope a symbol of the courage which risks all. No signal has
ever been as famous as the immortal 'England expects that
every man will do his duty* — curious to think that Nelson with
his somewhat stilted 18th century diction should have originally
used the words ‘England confides etc.’ It was a Signal Lieute¬
nant, Mr Pasco, who suggested the substitution of ‘expects’ for
‘confides’. Seldom as the Scots admire anything English, it was
a Scottish poet and not an English one who wrote the ‘Battle of
the Baltic’ and ‘Ye Mariners of England’ which are a glorification
of Nelson, English seamen and England. But perhaps the side of
Nelson which is most truly characteristic and most forgotten is
revealed only in his private papers. It was his habit to keep a
private journal and this, with his pocketbook, was found on the
desk in his cabin after his death. The last thing which he had
written was not to his darling Emma, or even to his infant child.
but a prayer:
‘May the Great God, whom I worship, grant to my country,
and for the benefit of Europe in general, a great and glorious
THE HOUSE OF NELSON
59
Victory; and may no misconduct in anyone tarnish it; and may
humanity after Victory be the predominant feature in the British
Fleet. For myself, individually, I commit my life to Him who
made me, and may His blessing light upon my endeavours for
serving my Country faithfully. To Him I resign myself and the
just cause which is entrusted to me to defend. Amen. Amen.
Amen.’
From all this grandeur and greatness we turn to the history of
the Nelson title. Six Earls there have been, none of them
distinguished for naval or other greatness. If ever there were an
argument for the abolition of hereditary titles, a good example
could be found in the honours granted to Nelson, or rather to
his kinsfolk. At last after five title holders had hved in noble
obscurity and died without venturing into the halls of fame, the
sixth earl succeeded his father in 1951. He lived for a long time
at Ballsbridge near Dublin, and his club is still the Royal Irish
Yacht. He has now returned to England and has announced that
he intends to raise the question of the Nelson pension in Parlia¬
ment. On what grounds it would be interesting to learn. The
sixth earl ranks as an astronomer who has published two popular
books, Life and the Universe, and There is Life on Mars. The
former is a fairly ambitious subject. The greatest intellects of all
ages have recoiled baffled from the problems of life and the
universe, but to-day someone can come along confidently to
explain it aU.
However, the Earl has an array of titles after his name which
would have done honour to even so ardent a collector of letters
as the late Walter Hutchinson. According to his latest book, Earl
Nelson is F.R.S.A., F.R.G.S., F.R.A.S., F.Z.S., and from Who’s
Who we learn that he is also F.R.Hort.S. Of all which one can
only say that it must cost a great deal in annual subscriptions. In
fact of course the possession of letters of this nature in the form
of fellowships is not a sign of proficiency in any science or art.
A degree unless it is honorary cannot be obtained unless it is by
a certain amount of mental effort. On the contrary fellowships
of most societies can usually be got on the manifestation of an
interest in the subject which is the raison d’etre of the society.
60
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
One has to be proposed and seconded and is then duly elected
and can use the letters. Still a fellowship of a society does not
rank as a university degree.
It is beyond the power of the most encyclopaediac editor to-day
to keep up with all the letters that are used after the names of
writers and others who seek after distinction. The great
majority of people do not know this and consequently the letters
serve their purpose and impress. Incidentally many journalists
are taken in by the parade of abbreviations.
If the earl does bring up the matter of the Nelson pension in
the House of Lords, he may well raise more than he intends.
The whole question of hereditary honours may be called in
question and with very little to justify their retention. It is one
thing to grant an hereditary title to a man as an honour for his
work; this has been the practice in many ages and countries; it
is one thing to grant honours to a man after his death, honours
which descend to his issue. It is quite another matter to grant
honours on a lavish scale, to the tune of three quarters of a
million pounds, to people who are not his descendants and for
whom he cared little. A mere turn of the wheel of birth made
the unknown and imdistinguished Nelsons kin to a man of
genius. Not before him and not after him have Nelsons been
noted in any way for ability unless we can reckon the 6th. Earl s
astronomical writings in this connection; the title of Earl Nelson
is a wonderful advantage to any one who is writing or lecturing
and can hardly be without its uses in the business world of
directorships. But to claim the continuance of the title is to seek
to perpetuate an arrangement which should never have,been
made in the first instance.
The State was as awkward in its dealings with the Nelson
title as the College of Arms of Nelson's day was with the
Nelson coat of arms. Nelson’s career was reproduced in his coat
of arms. The original shield of the Nelsons showed simply a
single black cross on a gold field with a red bend overall. On
top of the red bend was another (of gold), charged wth three
bombs proper, to show some of Nelson's early achievments.
This was not too bad, but as the momentum of Nelson s victories
THE HOUSE OF HELSON
61
gathered force, a chief, as the upper part of the shield is called,
was granted as honourable augmentation for Nelsons victory
of the Nile. The chief is undulated, haWng upon it, 'waves of the
sea from which a palm tree issues behveen a disabled ship on
the right and a battery in ruins on the left, all proper. There
were two crests, one of which, tliat on the dexter or right, is also
an honourable augmentation. It is: 'On a naval crown or (i.e.
gold) the chelengh or plume of triumph presented to Horatio,
Viscount Nelson by the Sultan Selim III.’ The crest on the
sinister or left, described as the family crest is: 'On waves of the
sea, the stern of a Spanish man of war, all proper, theron in¬
scribed San Josef, with motto over. Faith and Works’. This type
of crest could never have been used in the mediaeval warfare
from which the usages of heraldry arose.
Chapter four
WELLINGTON
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
T he names of Nelson and Wellington are linked together,
and have been for a long time in the popular mind. In
fact, no two men could well have been more unlike, but the
superficial facts of their careers do have a certain resemblance.
Both of them were supremely successful in their work. There is a
neat memorization in the dates of Trafalgar and Waterloo, 1805
and 1815. The former destroyed the possibilty of invasion and
gave Britain control of the sea; the latter was the result of the
ability to build up a Front in Europe which could be reinforced
by our sea power. Given our ability to send in men and supplies
to Spain, and to find the necessary money to equip our allies, it
was merely a matter of time before Napoleon would exasperate
some of the European nations into taking arms against him, in
the same way as he had infuriated the Spaniards. So just as
Nelson was the hero of Trafalgar and the British navy, Welling¬
ton was the hero of Waterloo and the army. In each case the
nation endeavoured to reward its hero on a prodigal scale;
Nelson missed most of his rewards by dying at Trafalgar, but
Wellington lived nearly 40 years after Waterloo, attained the
Iiighest civilian office, was insulted and abused even more than
other Prime Ministers, and finally died in extreme old age in a
kind of apotheosis of national glory. 'The last great Englishman
is dead', thus Tennyson summed up the popular feeling.
When we come to look at the characters of Nelson and Wel¬
lington there is the greatest divergence. All generalizations are
62
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
63
apt to be misleading (including the present one) but it would
not be far wrong to say that Nelson was the truer representative
of the ordinary English man or woman who has strong emotions
and is quite uninhibited in displaying them. The idea of the
strong silent man or the cold reserved person typifying the
English character is really quite inapplicable, without the in¬
fluence of education and a particular kind of education at that,
Englishmen are just as quick to express their feelings as any
Celt. Anyone who has had a dispute with a ta.xi-driver over a
fare will know that. About the end of the 18th century however
a veneer of reserve began to appear among upper class English
men. It was not properly developed until Dr Arnold brought
about his reform of the Public School system, but Wellington was
an early example of it. As it happens we have the record of the
only interview which ever took place between Nelson and Wel¬
lington. The account was given by Wellington. Apparently
Nelson in 1805 had called at the then War Office in Downing
Street and had been shown into a small waiting room where he
was presently joined by another visitor. Nelson did not recognize
the visitor, but the latter, who was General the Hon. Sir Arthur
Wellesley (Wellington), knew Nelson ‘from his likeness to his
pictures and the loss of an arm’. Wellington was tall, with a
large nose, haughty and curt in his manner, with the bearing of
a proud aristocrat. Nelson like most sailors had only a moderate
opinion of the army and of army officers. However, conver¬
sation began between two ill-assorted companions. We have
Wellington’s description of the opening of the conversation: ‘He
entered at once into conversation with me, if I can call it con¬
versation, for it was almost all on his side, and all about himself,
and in, really, a style so vain and silly as to surprise, and almost
disgust me.’ In other words Nelson had not had the least
compunction about talking about his own affairs, which the
reserved WeUington thought not quite correct. Some remarks of
Wellington’s must have struck Nelson for he went out of the
room, presumably to enquire who the soldier was. When he
returned he was no less voluble but in a more interesting vein as
far as Wellington was concerned. Having learned that his com-
64
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
panion was the celebrated young soldier from India, Nelson lost
no time in suggesting that he should lead the troops to the in¬
vasion of Sardinia. The wait for the Secretary of State was a
long one, and before it was over Wellington had decided that
Nelson ‘Really was a very superior man.’ This account reveals
Wellington as pre-eminently a man of the world, concurring in
the usual amusements of his kind (although he had very little
interest in women, he kept a mistress, it being the thing to do).
He simply could not understand how an officer of high rank
could be romantic, egotistical and vainglorious, as a man of
Nelson’s genius was bound to be. Wellington was a man of the
highest ability in his chosen profession but not wedded to it as
Nelson was to the Navy. It is a curiosity that of his 83 years,
Wellington should have spent 28 in military affairs and 37 in
civil life after Waterloo.
Another resemblence between Nelson and Wellington is in
the obscurity of their families. Indeed the ancestry of Wellington
cannot be traced back as far as the earliest person in the Nelson
pedigree. In their origins the Wellesleys were Cowleys or
Colleys. In Burke the pedigree begins with a somewhat amusing
entry. Walter Cowley, described as an English gentleman, was
sent to Ireland in the time of Henry VII to watch the conduct
of the then Lord Deputy, the 8th Earl of Kildare. From this time
forward the Cowleys were employed in matters of state in which
they must have been very skilful and unromantic because they
acquired property steadily, generation by generation. They
served with credit in the army, the law and the Church. The
name of Wellesley came to the family from a marriage of
Elizabeth Colley with another Engish settler Garret Wesley of
Dangan in County Meath. This family had been in Ireland much
earlier than the Colleys, for the original settler was one Waleran
de Wellesley who was one of the Justices for Ireland m 1261.
His name begins the pedigree of the Wesleys in the old Ulster
Office in Dublin Castie and in the same pedigree W^eran is
stated to have been a member of the family of Wellesley of
Wellesley in Somerset. The Colleys and the Wesleys thus be-
longed to two vintages of English settlers. The es eys
Sir Winston Churchill
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
obviously belonged to the old Anglo-Norman ruling caste,
whereas the Colleys were Tudor settlers. The last of the Wesleys,
Garret’ died in 1728 and as he had no children he left his estates
to his maternal cousin Richard Colley. Following the usual
fashion the latter took the surname and arms of Wesley which
now occupy the first and fourth quarters of the shield of the
Duke of Wellington. The spelling usually employed thereafter
for the family name was Wellesley and this has been perpetuated
in one of the titles of the Duke of Wellington, Baron Douro of
Wellesley, Somerset, the first title which was granted to the
famous first Duke in 1809. Garret Wesley of Dangan had
adopted Richard Colley who was a son of his wife’s brother and
had made him his heir. Thus the name Wellesley born by the
family ever since does not denote any blood connection with
that line. It is a curious fact that Wellesley is an old spelling of
Wesley and thus as one of the first Duke of Wellington’s bio¬
graphers records The same stock which produced the illustrious
conqueror of the peace of Europe in 1815, had previously
acquired fame of no common order by giving birth to the foun¬
der of English Methodism in the year 1803’. This is a mistake
because there was as has been noted no blood connection, but
it is certainly one of the most curious freaks of nomenclature
that the family name, after 1728, of this Anglo-Irish family
should have been the same as that of the English evangelist.
The increase in the wealth of the Wellesleys which came from
the succession to the Dangan and Momington estates was soon
reflected in the raising to the peerage of Richard Wellesley
under the title of Baron Momington in the peerage of Ireland in
1746. The new peer had been for 17 years previous to his
elevation a member of the Irish House of Commons, He was
succeeded by his only son Garret in 1758, and the latter was
created Viscount Wellesley of Dangan CasUe and Earl of Mor-
nington in 1760.
This first Earl of Momington had several sons but although
they left behind them a considerable progeny there are only two
men in &e whole family of WeUesley who have achieved fame
and both of them were sons of the first Earl. The gigantic
66
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
reputation of tiie first Duke of Wellington has overshadowed
that of his elder brother Richard. The latter succeeded his father
in 1781 as second Earl of Momington but he attained for him¬
self a position in the peerage which owed little to his birth. In
1797 the second Earl was created Baron Wellesley of Wellesley,
Somerset in the peerage of Great Britain and Marquis Wellesley
in the peerage of Ireland 1799. Lord Wellesley was Governor
General of India, and during his tenure of that office he had to
deal with a grave menace to Indian security from the Muslim
Ruler of Mysore, the brilliant and dangerous Tippoo Sultan, son
of the ruthless Hyder Ali. Mysore was a Hindoo State but Hyder
Ali usurped the throne and the Muslim Kingdom ended with
Tippoo. The dominion which Clive had won for us in India 50
years earlier was in danger of collapse. The French were in¬
triguing for the restoration of their own influence in India;
Tippoo was in league with them, of course for his own advantage,
and both he and the French were determined to drive the British
out of India. Lord Wellesley decided to strike a heavy blow at
Mysore while Napoleon was still in Egypt, in case the latter
should be able to carry out any of his plans and reach India.
Should he do so, there would be no native allies for him to meet,
if Wellesley’s plan succeeded. An army was prepared which was
to march across country (this part of Mysore is as bare as the
Downs) to Seringapatam ihe capitol of Tippoo. In February 1799,
21,000 troops, of whom 5,000 were British marched into Mysore,
where they were joined by 16,000 men from Hyderabad. A third
army of 6,000 men marched from Bombay. The army of Tippoo
Sultan was the strongest and best disciplined which had yet
appeared in India. It was composed of 76,000 men organized on
European lines and officered by Frenchmen. Tippoo was able
to work on interior lines against the British, and he very new y
destroyed the army which was advancing from Bombay, but when
he was menaced by the two other armies he was forced to refrea
to his capital of Seringapatam. There he trusted to be able to hold
out behind his very strong fortifications until the Britash oops
were compelled to retreat owing to lack of food and ™-
culties of supply lines in Southern India. In this he would pr -
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
67
bably have been quite right but the British were led by generals
of iron resolution. One of them. General Baird, had been cruelly
treated in the dungeons of Tippoos father, having spent some
years in chains. He was determined to be even with the enemy.
A great bombardment was brought to bear against the fortress,
but no amount of cannon fire or rockets could bring about its
surrender. The place had to be stormed, and to do so it was
necessary to cross a river 300 yards wide and then to enter the
breaches which had been made in the walls by the artillery.
After having crossed the river it was found by the troops that
there was a further obstacle in the shape of a large ditch full of
water beyond the breaches. Despite all opposition however the
city was carried, and Tippoos body was found among a heap
of slain. He had fought with great gallantry, firing his own
musket among liis men, until at last he had opened an old wound
and could no longer carry on the struggle. When his body was
found, his eyes were open and the expression in them was so
strong that he seemed to be still alive. By nightfaU the whole
city was held by the British; there had been a great slaughter
among the defenders and no doubt a good deal of plunder was
gained by the victors. (It was the storming of Seringapatam
which gave Wilkie Collins the basis of his story of the Moon¬
stone). Before the final assault Tippoo had massacred his 12
English prisoners; this was known to the storming troops and
they took good care that the murdered men should be avenged
many times over. Two of Tippoos younger sons were saved and
were later entertained with toys and sweets by General Baird.
One of the junior officers in this great campaign, which left
the British in command of Southern India, was a young Colonel
who had arrived in India in 1796. He was Arthur WeUesley
younger brother of the Governor General, who had had some
expenence in the British army in Holland and had now come
out to India %vith his regiment. Whatever may be said about the
patronage system in the 18th century it certainly seems to have
brought about the promotion of men of ability at an age much
younger than anything we have seen since. William Pitt the
Younger, was Prime Minister at 24, Nelson commanded a’ship
68
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
of the line at 21, and the future Duke of Wellington was a lieu¬
tenant-colonel at 27. We certainly have had no one in the
political sphere to approach Pitt’s record; anyone of 45 who be¬
comes an Under-Secretary of State and does well is regarded
politically as a promising boy. In the second world war we did
of course have commanding officers in all three services who
were in their twenties; a wing-commander or squadron-leader in
the Air Force who is engaged in flying operations may well be no
more than 24, even though he is referred to as ‘the Old Man'.
But flying duties require youth and in any case in the last war
we had hundreds of thousands of officers. In the time of Nelson
and Wellington there were only a few thousand officers in either
the army or navy, and the rise of such young men is a proof that
the rule of the governing classes was very different from the
policy of ‘jobs for the boys’. Of course there were cases in the
18th century when a dull or vicious person secured an important
post, but such instances were rare and on the whole only men
of ability could find a patron. Poor men like Edmund Burke
were able to make a career in politics which would have been
impossible in the 19th and early 20th century under democracy.
Curiously enough, it was only when the great organized bodies
of Labour, the Trade Unions, exercised some patronage that able
young men like Aneurin Bevan with no money of their own
could hope to get into Parliament at a fairly early age.
Consequently although Wellington (for the sake of convenience
I use the title by which he is best known) was the brother of the
Governor-General, this did not necessarily bring him advance¬
ment. In India he won his spurs, and anyone who thinks that
influence helped him unduly, might meditate with profit on the
ordeal through which he had to pass. Wellington had a good
deal to do with planning the campaign against Tippoo and after
it was over he was given supreme command, military and
political, in Mysore. After Tippoo’s death there was the problem
of clearing up the Mahratta chiefs who were a perpetual menace,
because they existed almost entirely on plunder, and cared little
where it came from. For some years Wellington was engaged in
fighting the Mahrattas. By 1801 at the age of 32 he had become
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
69
a Major-General, and soon after he undertook the task of
restoring to power the Peshwa, the titular head of the Mahratta
confederacy, who was in alliance with the English. A huge force
of 50,000 men, the whole of the Mahratta army, faced Welling¬
ton, after some weeks of manoeuvring, at a place called Assaye.
The Mahrattas were drawn up with a river in front and had
128 pieces of cannon. Against this force Wellington had 8,000
men of whom not more than 2,000 were British, and only 17 guns.
Here was the test of the Generals capacity. If he were to retreat
the cavalry forces of the enemy would probably overwhelm his
whole army. On the other hand he could wait for the arrival of
General Stevenson who was expected within two days. To do so
might be to lose a great opportunity. Wellington had to decide
quickly on a daring plan of action. He had a wonderful eye for
a weakness in an enemy's position. In the present case he saw
that he could attack on the left across an undefended ford and
he sent part of his infantry straight to this point. His artillery, 17
to 128, was soon silenced, but his infantry pressed on in a manner
which struck the Mahrattas with astonishment. The enemy’s
artillery was reached and they abandoned their guns. Seeing
this the hostile infantry also fell back. The British troops pressed
on past the guns and folowed the retreating enemy with ardour.
At this moment a terrible thing occured which might have lost
Wellington’s whole army. Many of the Mahratta gunners had
merely pretended to be dead and had fallen beneath their guns.
As soon as the British had passed and were pursuing the infantry
these gunners got up, turned their guns round and resumed
firing. It was a critical moment. The bulk of Wellington’s tiny
force was now between two bodies of the enemy, with cannon
in their rear, the Mahratta cavalry on their flank and the
Mahratta infantry beginning to turn back in their front. Wel¬
lington himself led the charge with the remainder of his troops,
the 78th regiment of the line and the 7th native cavalry. By a
terrible charge he succeeded for the second time in capturing
the Mahratta artillery. This virtually ended the battle. Their
artillery being gone, the Mahrattas seemed to have been unable
to withstand the fierce courage of Wellington's men, but the
70
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
battle was desperate almost beyond description. After it was
over large quantities of the Mahrattas were found lying in ranks
where they had been killed; as for their artillery men they were
quite understandably slain to a man by troops whose blood was
up. Wellington himself had two horses killed under him in the
fighting. This was the most desperate battle ever fought by the
british in India, until the time of the Sikh War. After Assaye,
which Tennyson commemmorated in his verses on the Death of
the Duke of Wellington, the British went on to mop up the
remains of the Mahratta power, and the treaties with the fallen
chiefs were negotiated by Wellington who was as successful in
political as in military matters. One can imagine that after this
terrible experience where his judgement had been tested literally
under fire, Wellington would have no doubts as to his ability to
deal with any other enemy.
In 1805 he left India and after a brief experience in Hanover
he became M.P. for Rye, mainly to be able to defend his brother
the Governor General from the attacks of his enemies, and in
1806 he was actually employed as Secretary for Ireland for a few
months. His representation of Rye was not his first experience
of Parliamentary life; his family, like most wealthy families of
that period, owned a rotten borough. Trim, and he had been put
into this in 1793. He had taken up a military career probably
because a yoimger son had to be provided for, and because the
life of a soldier gave more opportunity for sport. He had had no
education to fit him for a position of command. He had been to
Eton and then to a Military College in France. His commission
in the Army like all commissions in those days was bought, and
his brother, the Earl, lent him enough money to purchase his
promotion through the commissioned ranks up to colonel, no
doubt the Earls idea being that Wellington would repay the
money from his perquisites as a commanding officer. Despite this
rapid advance Wellington saw very little military duty, as he
was aide-de-camp to the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland during most
of the early years in the army. It was in the expedition to Hol¬
land in 1794 that he had his first experience of active service
and also learned about the army. It was a curious situation, for
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
71
a lieutenant-colonel to be learning his regimental duty at the
same time tliat he was leading his regiment into action, but tliat
was how things were done in those days. Wellington was
interested and learnt the work thoroughly, so that when he
went to India he was fully trained, by himself. It was in India
that he was able to practice his profession on a much wider
stage and with no hindrance. He even gave up playing cards and
the violin to study military tactics. Thus we have him when he
is nearly 40 an experienced soldier, trained by methods wliich
would have made Wavell, Alexander or Montgomery shudder,
but which were in the tradition of training of geniuses like
Cromwell and Clive. At the same time Wellington is not purely
and simply a soldier, but a man of the world, a politician, and a
man of varied talent. Moreover he has ambitions outside the
army, and his taking a seat in the House of Commons fore¬
shadows the Premiership of his later life. In other words, while
the majority of people think of Wellington in the light of the
well known statue outside Apsley House, as a general par
excellence, he regarded his generalship as an adjunct to himself,
and would have been surprised at finding his name down
in history as that of a successful general alone. Even when in
1808 he was promoted Lieut. General and sent out to campaign
in the Peninsula against the French, he seemed to have regarded
the affair as only a matter of tlie moment. On his being superseded
by another general, he returned to England, resumed his
Parliamentary duties and his tenure of the office of Secretary for
Ireland. However, he was destined to something more than the
glory of an occasional campaign; the generals who had taken Iris
place were no good; even when they won victories they let the
enemy go, and signed agreements with the French which were
detested by the public in England. Wellington was called to the
scene of action and began the career of victories which was to
place him with Marlborough as the most successful British
soldier before the generals of 1939-45.
We constantly come upon misunderstandings in the career of
Wellington. To the outside observer it seems that his career in
Spain is one long series of triumphs in which his grateful coun-
72
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
trymen applaud and support him the whole way. In fact, he was
the subject of the most lively controversy in the House of
Commons. Bold tactician as he was, Wellington decided to
strike right against the centre of French authority at Madrid,
and on the way he defeated the army of King Joseph, Napoleon s
brother whom the latter had set on the throne of Spain. The
Spanish allies of Wellington however let him down and he was
forced to retreat before the overwhelming forces of the French
Marshal Soult. He was given a peerage for his victory and an
award of £2,000 pension per year, but this was criticised in the
Commons as just a Tory job, because it was said that Welling¬
tons victory was costly and barren. His critics were silenced in
the next year or two when Wellington constructed impregnable
fortifications on the Portuguese border, the lines of Torres Vedras,
against which the French advanced in vain. When famine com¬
pelled them to retreat Wellington took the initiative in 1811, and
the following year when the best French troops were out of
Spain and had taken part in Napoleons advance against Moscow,
Wellington was able to advance right through Spain, win the
battle of Salamanca, and force the Pyrenees; the war was carried
into France, the battle of ToiJouse was won, and by 1814
Napoleon was nearly beaten. Wellington then took farewell of
his army and went to England. In 1814 he was created Duke of
Wellington. The war of 1812 was still raging with the United
States, and there was some talk of sending Wellington over to
America with some of his veterans to bring the struggle to
a conclusion. This was one of the occasions when Britain had a
chance of finishing off the United States, as she had again in the
war of 1865—69 between North and South and which she
missed. At any rate Wellington was not sent and in 1815 he was
recalled to take the supreme command against Napoleon for the
Hundred Days when the latter had escaped from Elba to France.
Wellington was a soldier of iron discipline. In India he had
praised his troops unreservedly, especially after Assaye; but in
the Peninsula he looked on them as the lowest vermin. After the
retreat into Portugal he had described his troops as the most
demoralized and misconducted army he had ever seen. He is
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
73
supposed to have said of his men that he wondered what effect
they would have upon the enemy since they terrified him. He
had none of the camaraderie which distinguished Marlborough
or Cromwell, not even the showmanship of a Montgomery
which at least stimulates the rank and file. He was cold,
reserved and distant. Not only the men but the officers also came
under his criticism. He had few personal friends or admirers
in the armies which he commanded, e.\cept on his staff. He
could control and discipline his troops and lead them to victory
but he never won their affection. The Little Corporal whom he
fought was probably more unsparing of his men than Wellington,
but he had ways of winning the devotion of his soldiers which the
cold correct Wellington would not have understood. ‘Soldiers, 40
centuries are looking down on you' (Napoleon’s remark before
the Battle of the Pyramids) would have seemed theatrical to
Wellington.
It seems strange to find that Wellington married, yet he did,
though the account of the marriage in one of his less biassed
biographers seems peculiar. The Hon. Catherine Pakenham,
third daughter of Edward Michael, Lord Longford was one of
the reigning beauties in the circle of the viceregal court. ‘She won
the affections of Mr. Wellesley and gave him her own in return;
but the worldly means of both were slender and the Lady’s
father refused on that account to sanction the marriage. It was
a severe blow to the yoimg Colonel but he bore up under it wth
characteristic fortitude and as he received from Catherine the
assurance that she would always look upon herself in the light of
being betrothed to him he resolved to wait for better times and
to accompany his regiment to the Continent. Though rejected by
the father he still retained the affections of the daughter and by
and by proceeded to India a betrothed man. But he had not been
gone many months ere a violent attack of small pox deprived
Lady Catherine of all her beauty and in a noble spirit of disinte¬
restedness she wrote to Wellesley informing him of the circum¬
stance, and releasing him from his engagement. Sir Arthur
* Urd Longford never succeeded to the Earldom of Longford so his daughter
could not be ‘Lady Catherine’, despite the passage quoted.
74
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
declined like a true knight, to avail himself of her generosity,
and in due time Lady Catherine Pakenham became Lady Cathe¬
rine Wellesley/ It is hard to reconcile the romantic tone of the
above account with Sir Arthur Bryants reference to Welling¬
tons mistress, an incident which must have taken place a few
years after his marriage. The affair of the mistress may have
been, as I have suggested already, a gesture like vidne drinking
or fox-hunting, to be in the fashion at the time. There is a story
that Wellington in much later life after the death of the Duchess
fell violently in love with a young lady who had professed her¬
self to be interested in his eternal welfare, but who possessed the
gift, very dangerous for an evangelist, of beauty; however it is
not clear whether Wellington became interested in the ladys
scheme of conversion or if she felt the call of another emotion
which often accompanies revivalism.
There was inevitably a decided tinge of coldness in the Duke s
character, perhaps the overdevelopement of his magnificent
qualities as a leader. His nickname was 'The Iron Duke’ and
amid the poetical types like Pitt and Napoleon, Nelson and Fox,
Wellington moved with an apparently Olympian attitude
towards life and death. At Waterloo he was never far from the
front line and as he rode calmly among the British squares, he
remarked ‘hard pounding, gentleman, but we shall see who
can stand it the longer'; when one of his generals had his leg
shot off and not unnaturally remarked on the loss, Wellington
looked coolly around and having ascertained that the leg was
really missing remarked ‘Yes, you have lost it*. Napoleon, on the
other hand on vidtnessing the removal of the head of one of his
officers by a cannon ball, was unable to control his laughter, a
circumstance which Stendhal ascribes to the nervousness of the
Italian temperament. Wellington would never have laughed at
such an occurrence but equally he would never have used the
tears, albeit of rage, which came to Napoleon. When Wellington
had conquered the whole of Spain and crossed the mighty
* Uxbridge: — I have lost my leg, by God.
WellingtoD: — By God, and have you*
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
75
barrier of the Pyrenees, it never occured to him to tell his
veterans that they were about to take an historic step and to be
the first British army to invade France from the south, while the
ghosts of Roland and his Paladins were watching them. If any¬
thing could have made the Duke blush it would have been the
thought of such far-fetched and high-faluting language.
It was this very coolness coupled with his organizing ability
which made the Duke as successful in peace as he was in war.
There was no office, it seemed, with which his countrymen were
not prepared to entrust him. In 1814 when Napoleon was
banished to Elba, the Duke was appointed Ambassador to
France; he had slain thousands of Frenchman, but presumably
they were regarded as rebels to their la^vful king, Louis XVIII,
and so the Duke would be persona grata to the restored French
Government. He appears not to have occupied this ambassadorial
post for long, for he was soon off to Vienna to take the place
of the British Foreign Secretary at the Peace Conference. From
this Wellington was recalled to take up his military duties as
Commander-in-Chief in the West by Napoleon’s escape from
Elba. After Waterloo the Duke commanded the occupation
armies in France, but this did not prevent him in a semi-civilian
capacity from taking a leading part in the peace negotiations.
As soon as the occupation armies were withdrawn from France
in 1818 Wellington went back into politics, whichheseemstohave
preferred over military duties. Apart from such liigh posts of
honour as that of Lord High Constable at three coronations,
Wellington in the ten years, 1818—1828, held a seat in the
Cabinet in various offices, at the same time being Commander-
in-Chief of the army. In 1828 he became Prime Minister,
whereupon he resigned his military command.
He had no real desire to be Prime Minister, despite his love
of political life, perhaps because he saw some of tlie storms which
were ahead. As always happens in the time of a great war many
reforms and changes had become necessary or were desired in
the country. While the Duke was Prime Minister it fell to his lot
to put through Parliament the Catholic Emancipation Bill, a
statesmanlike measure which went dead against the prejudices
76
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
of Protestant England. For three centuries Papists had been
excluded from every profession and almost from every walk of
life where it was possible to impose a test, namely the willingness
to receive Holy Communion according to the forms of the
Church of England. Wellington as a member of the English
garrison of Ireland could have had no sympathy with Popery, but
he saw the injustice of keeping in a state of mental solitude, a
body of men and women whose sole fault was the holding of
certain religious views. He therefore ensured the passage through
Parliament of the Catholic Emancipation Bill. His government
however fell in 1830 mainly because the Duke was quite unable
to appreciate the need of reform in the electoral scheme of the
country. In fact, in 1830 he declared that the British Constitution
could not be improved; and this on the eve of the great Reform
Bill. Earl Grey headed the Whigs and secured the passing of the
Reform Bill even invoking the aid of William IV, who promised
to make enough peers to enable the Bill to pass the Upper
House. The Duke opposed the Bill. It could hardly be expected
tliat he would be enthusiastic about increasing the electorate by
half a million persons; as he had described the men of his own
victorious army as blackguards, scallywags and the scum of the
earth, he was not likely to be keen to give the vote to some of
their relations. As soon as his attitude was known he became the
centre of fierce hostility from the mob. One of the curiosities of
English political life before the rise of universal suffrage was the
interest taken in politics by people who had no votes. It did not
need an election for a mob to start parading the town with
banners and effigies, shouting out filthy songs and taking every
opportunity of theft and outrage which could be found. Sober
politicians applauded the practice because they felt that it
diverted the minds of the people from their real troubles; but
although it is highly amusing to read of these things in
retrospect, it must have been very unpleasant and at times very
dangerous to be in the way of a mob. This the Duke soon found.
He had acquired Apsley House in 1817 from his brother who had
bought it from the family of Earl Bathurst. Diulng the height of
the Duke’s unpopularity with the mob, the windows of Apsley
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
77
House were broken. Iron shutters were then fitted to the windows
at the Duke’s orders, and there remained for the next 21 years
until his death. His popularity soon returned and on one occasion
as he drove up Constitution Hill he received as many cheers as
he had formerly had boos and curses. He remained impassive in
his carriage until he reached the courtyard before his own door
when he rose gravely to his feet, took off his hat and motioned
the eyes of the crowd towards tlie iron shutters. This done, he
withdrew into his house, being in all probability of the same
opinion as Cromwell who once remarked of an immense crowd
which cheered him. ‘There would be as many to see me hanged’.
The Duke’s poUtical career did not cease until 1846 up to which
time he held a political appointment. Thus for 30 years after
Waterloo he was a politician. For the next six years (he died at
the age of 83) he still continued to take a keen interest in national
and foreign affairs. In 1848 he was called upon to organise the
defence of London against the Chartists. At the Great Exhibition
of 1851 he was almost mobbed by the crowd, a fact which he
regarded rather as an embarrassing nuisance than a tribute. Even
to the last he was useful, and the young Queen who was annoyed
by bird droppings from the inhabitants of the trees enclosed
in the Crystal Palace turned to him naturally for advice on the
problem. ‘Get sparrowhawks Ma’am’, was the immediate reply.
When the Duke died (at Walmer Castle in Kent in 1852,
where he was Warden of the Cinque Ports, like another great
Englishman of our time), his fimeral exceeded anything in State
ceremonies which had ever been seen in England. Twice the
body lay in state, as Nelson’s had done, once at Walmer and the
second time in Chelsea Hospital; one and a half million people
lined the route up to St Paul’s Cathedral where he was to be
buried by the side of Nelson. This fresh burial in St. Paul’s must
have been another severe blow to the Dean and Chapter of West¬
minster Abbey. After failing to get Nelson buried in the Abbey
they had lost money in admission fees, and had had to set up a
waxworks show on the lines of Madame Tussaud’s to attract
xisitors into the Abbey.
In the Duke’s funeral every unit of the British army took part;
78
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
nine privates with an appropriate number of the higher ranks
were present from ever>' regiment. One has only to look at the
catafalque in the Crypt at St Paul’s to realize how great a
tribute the nation paid to the Duke. It was fitting that he should
lie near his fellow victor; the two men who had saved the British
Empire, Nelson and Wellington though unlike in nearly every
characteristic, were alike as regards the relative obscurity of
their families, the huge rewards bestowed upon them (though
poor Nelson had to receive his by proxy), and in the fate which
their honours have received in their descendants. The Duke had
a barony and a viscounty in 1809, was created Earl of Welling¬
ton in 1812, Marquess of Wellington at the end of the same year,
and became Marquess Douro and Duke of Wellington in 1814.
He received a Dukedom in Spain, with a Grandeeship of the
First Class; he was a Duke in Portugal and Prince of Waterloo
in the Netherlands. In 1814 he received a grant of £.400,000
from Parliament and after Waterloo the estate of Stratfield Saye
near Reading in Berkshire was bought for him and his heirs by
Parliament. After Waterloo he received a further £200,000. In
1830 the freehold of Apsley House was also bought by Parlia¬
ment at a cost of nearly £10,000. The ceremonial honours con¬
ferred upon him were of the highest quality and of enormous
range. At Apsley House can be seen 11 batons representing those
of the High Constable of England, three as Field Marshal in the
British army, and the rest for a similar office in the armies of
Portugal, Hanover, the Netherlands, Spain, Russia, Austria and
Prussia. Apart from the Orders of the Garter, the Bath, and the
Guelphic Order of Hanover he had the chief orders of Chivalry
of Russia, Prussia, Saxony, Sicily, Spain, Baden, France, Sweden,
Denmark, Austria, Portugal, Savoy, and the Netherlands, a
magnificent collection which included orders which have now
become extinct, such as the St. Esprit of France, and many of the
German orders. The Golden Fleece of Spain is not extinct but
has not been bestowed since the fall of the Spanish monarchy.
The Order of Alexander Nevsky of Russia has had a chequered
history; some years ago it was revived under the Soviet regime
without the prefix of St. The Order of the Elephant of Denmark
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
79
has lately received some prominence owing to its having been
bestowed upon Sir Winston Churchill; but it is one of the
greatest Orders now in existence.
Apsley House, which was once known as No. 1, London, is
now a museum and contains within its walls the most over¬
whelming testimony to the impression made upon his contem-
pories by the first Duke. Not only did he impress Europe and
the world, but he also exhausted the capacity for greatness in
his family. Unlike Nelson, Wellington was succeeded in his
titles and his fortune by his elder son; but like Nelson he has
left no one behind him in his family who has ever approached
his own eminence. The first Duke’s elder brother, the Marquess
Wellesley, would have achieved sufficient by his Indian career to
have been the great man of most peerage families, but he has been
completely overshadowed by his famous younger brother, so that
among the majority of people his name is hardly known. As it
so happened the Marquess though twice married, left no chil¬
dren, so the Marquessate became extinct, but the Earldom of
Momington and the subsidiary titles were inherited by the
Marquess’s next brother William. Owing to the failure of
Wilham s issue the title of the Earl of Momington devolved on
the second Duke of Wellington. The Earl of Momington, apart
from the second Earl who was the Marquess and Governor
General of India, like the Dukes of Wellington after the time of
the first Duke, went through the usual occupations of the greater
nobility; that is to say, they held office in their counties, were
officers in the army, members of Parliament, and sometimes
Knights of the Garter etc. No breath of undue greatness has
visited the family since the time of the Iron Duke.
In another respect the resemblance between Nelson’s and
Wellington’s fates holds good to some extent. The Nelson en¬
dowment has been dissipated by the same hand which gave it,
that of the State; Wellington’s merits were rewarded rather with
a capital endowment than with the uncertain promise of an
^ual contribution. Even so, the whole range of taxation has
been so greatiy increased since Wellington’s day that hardly any
capital sum decreed in the past by the State would be sufficient
80
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
to keep its present owners free from financial difficulties.
Stratfield Saye is still the country seat of the Dukes of Welling¬
ton, but in 1947 the seventh and present Duke of Wellington
offered to the nation Apsley House with part of its contents and
other objects connected with the first Duke. The offer was
accepted by the Government and under the Wellington Museum
Act of 1947, Apsley House became a national property. The
Duke and his family retain a flat in the house but the splendid
building with its superb rooms and about 1,650 objects of art,
have passed from the Wellingtons to the ownership of the State.
What a curious coincidence that the same government which
did away with the Nelson pension, should also indirectly have
been responsible for the recouping of its expenditure in Wel¬
lington’s case. For it is clear that the tremendous pressure of
taxation has made the upkeep of a town as well as a country
house virtually impossible. The Duke’s Statue stands opposite
Apsley House, and from its rooms we are able to see splendid
vistas in Hyde Park, and to look out on the busy scene of Lon¬
don; in the wonderful Waterloo Gallery we can imagine some¬
thing of what a banquet must have been like there in the
heyday of Britain’s greatness. Now we are left with a museum,
interesting, instructive but very sad. The idea of Parliament when
it purchased the freehold of Apsley House for the Wellingtons,
was that it should belong to them for ever. Of course there
have been great wars and economic disasters but these alone
would not have sufficed to reduce our aristocracy to a humbler
position. In former days everyone in the country was proud of
the nobility, but now it has been left to the last 40 years for a
spirit of bitterness to manifest itself in the sphere of taxation.
The Nelson benefaction can be objected against on the ^ound
that Nelson and his heirs received nothing, but the Wellington
awards were made on the basis that a son has the ”2^*:
succeed his father in property and possessions, of all kinds.
Objection is frequently taken to-day to hereditary titles but tew
of those who grumble about them could give any clear reason
why. One complaint is that if we grant a place in the House of
Lords to a celebrated man, why should we grant one to
THE HOUSE OF WELLESLEY
81
lesser son? The answer to this is to be found in the attendance
list of the House of Lords where the majority of hereditary peers
are ‘backswoodsmen’, or persons who never attend. The real
objection to hereditary titles comes from Socialists who want to
stop the inheritance of a title. Why should not the Wellington
name be honoured by the continuance of the great name among
us, borne by men of the Duke s own blood? Perhaps the real
reason that some persons do not want to retain the memory of
Wellington is because he fought for the British Empire. If he had
helped to give it away, the attitude would have been different.
Chapter five
KINGSALE
THE HOUSE OF DE COURCY
I f in the Nelson family there was only one person of any real
note, this record is easily surpassed in that of the Lords
Kingsale, where it is very difficult if not impossible to find
anyone from first to last who could be described as great. In
fact, as the Duke of Wellington once remarked of another matter,
it can be said of the Kingsale ancestory 'that there is no damn
merit about it*. Whenever the name of Kingsale or de Courcy
(the family surname) is mentioned, one can be sure that the 'hat
story* will be brought up. Apart from the eccentricity of the
action which is denoted by the hat story, one of the reasons for
mentioning this tale is that the unhappy journalist who has to
write the paragraphs cannot find anything else to say about the
de Courcys, except that they claim to have the right to remain
covered in the Sovereign’s presence.
Like everyone else I had been vaguely acquainted with the
story of the hat when I was dealing with Burke's Peerage before
the last war, but I had never made a close study of the family
pedigree until I was engaged in revising the whole of the
Peerage for the first post war edition which was published in
1949. I was busy with this work from the end of 1946 and as
nothing had been done during the war. it may be imagined that
a vast amount of detailed work was necessary. At such a time a
huge mass of papers which arrives from a new source is far
from welcome to any editor; it was with considerable reluctance
that I turned to examine a very large envelope full of documents
82-
83
THE HOUSE OF DE COURCY
on the de Courcy family which had reached me from Mr Ken¬
neth de Courcy. the well known proprietor of the Intelligence
Digest. This led me to make a close study of the subject and here
I would advise all those who wish to have their pedigrees
accepted without argument, not to overload them with referen¬
ces. 'Methinks the lady doth protest too much' and ten or twelve
pages of references which are meant to support a pedigree,
usually suggest to a genealogist that the case is so bad that it
has been felt best to muffle it up with a cloud of witnesses.
At any rate, no one can dispute the vast age of the Kingsale
barony. The present peer who was bom in 1882 is reckoned as the
34th baron. No one has been able to find the date when the
peerage originated. Even the title has been changed in the course
of centuries. From the time of Charles I the title used has been
that of Kingsale, but apparently until 1613 at least these peers
sat in Parliament as Lord Courcy. In 1599 John de Courcy who
succeeded at that date was styled the 17th or 18th Lord Baron
of Kingsale. The earhest person from whom a lineal descent can
be proved is Patrick de Courcy who is mentioned on the 17th
July 1221 as one of the nobles of Ireland. It is quite impossible
to find out who was his father and here there develops one of
tlie most intriguing problems in genealogy, a little mystery in
fact which was solved very brilliantly by the late Sir Henry
Maxwell-Lyte. According to the legend of the de Courcys they
descended from John de Courcy, the Norman knight who in a
hghtnlng campaign in the reign of Henry II subdued the whole
of Ulster. He was imdoubtedly a famous man, the only one in
the family until the time of Mr Kenneth de Courcy, a gap of
eight centuries. Unfortunately for pedigree purposes, the con¬
queror of Ulster left, as far as can be traced, only bastard chil¬
dren. Even if we were prepared to accept the descent of the
Lords Kingsale from one of these latter, we should still be unable
to construct the pedigree because there is no trace of descent
from John de Courcy to Patrick de Courcy of 1221. For a long
time indeed John de Courcy was looked upon as a person who
could not be connected with any of the de Courcy pedigrees
before or after his time, but Sir Henry Maxwell-Lyte was able
84
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
to show that John de Courcy was a cadet of the great Norman
family which had settled after the Conquest at Stoke in Somerset,
whence the name Stoggursey or Stoke Courcy. But no amount
of research or learning has so far traced the origin of the de
Courcys in Ireland. All that can be said is that as far as the
record of the family can be traced the members of it have always
been reckoned among the magnates of Ireland. That is a con¬
siderable claim, for if one cannot be outstanding it is at least some¬
thing to have been able to have maintained ones place. So this
peerage has gone on for something like 800 years (for the Patrick
of 1221 is usually reckoned as the third or fourth of the line) and
considering the troubled history of Ireland it is an amazing thing
that these peers should have been able to retain their peerages.
Once or twice in the record the dullness of a string of successions
is enlivened by a piece of imprudence on the part of one of the
Lords Kingsale. James the 13th Lord was seduced into taking
part in the conspiracy of Lambert Simnel. James was pardoned
for this, and the same thing happened to the 23rd Baron,
/Vlmericus, who was outlawed in 1691 for adhering to James 11.
The outlawry was soon reversed for Almericus sat in the Parlia¬
ment of Ireland the next year. Except for incidents like these
there would be nothing to record in the Kingsale story. Are we
forgetting the famous hat? What is the truth about this story?
King John, whose record has been spring-cleaned by historians
of recent years, is supposed to have been responsible for the hat-
trick. According to the story, stiU gravely produced in Debrett’s
Peerage (Apparently on Merlin's authority, with a white horse
and three eagles thrown in), a French Knight appeared at the
Court of King John and challenged any English knight to
fight with him. Thereupon, de Courcy took up the challenge
whereupon the Frenchman fled in terror. King John was suitably
grateful and conferred upon the champion and his descendants
the right ever after to remain covered in the royal presence. In
order to clear up any difficulties which may be felt about this
story, it can be said straight away that no authority h^ ever
been produced for the grant from King John, or indeed for any
instance of the exercise of the alleged privilege. There are mdeed
THE HOUSE OF DE COURCY
85
only five instances in which the privilege has been exercised.
The first recorded case is that of the daring Almericus, the 23rd
Lord who in 1692 was allowed to keep his hat on when in the
presence of William III. As William was a Dutchman who did
not like the British, was imperfectly acquainted with their habits
and had no desire for further knowledge, we may be able to
explain how Almericus got away with this very loutish practice.
Perhaps Almericus had thought there was more likelihood of
wearing his hat before William rather than James, had given up
the latter’s cause as being not likely to afford a suitable oppor¬
tunity, and so had petitioned to be taken back into William’s
good graces. The next of the Kingsales, the 24th Baron, was able
to hold his bonnet parade before George I — he spoke no English
and hated the country — and before George II whose command
of English was very imperfect. There are thus three cases of
hat wearing in front of three different kings, not one of whom
was bom in England or really imderstood what was going on.
Probably being foreigners these three kings looked upon the
British as mad in any case, and so the sight of a nobleman
ostentatiously walking up and down before them wearing his
hat, while everyone else was uncovered, was probably looked
upon as just another example of British lunacy. The fourth in¬
stance occurs with the 25th Baron Kingsale who wore his hat in
1762 in the presence of George III. The then Lord Kingsale
could at least plead that there had been precedents before his
time. What is almost inconceivable however is that the 29th
Baron Kingsale should have succeeded in remaining covered in
1859 before Queen Victoria and the Prince Consort. The practice
was never carried out again in the reign of Victoria, nor has it
been heard of since outside the pages of popular newspapers.
Has there ever been such a thing as the right to keep one’s
hat on in the presence of the Sovereign? In the writings of
historical novelists the practice is about on a par with the so-
called bar sinister which is supposed to be used as a mark of
bastardy. In other words it has no reality but it is quite a good
stage effect for anyone who is writing a pseudo-historical
romance. There were however actual cases when permission was
86
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
given by a King or Queen for the hat to be kept on. Dr Horace
Round collected some of these cases from the Tudor and Stuart
periods. If a courtier had lice in his hair, (a misfortune which
could easily occur when hair was worn very long, and cleaning
materials were very scarce); if a poor old man was troubled with
the draughts which were very frequent and unpleasant in Royal
Palaces; if skin diseases had made their appearance on the scalp
and if the hair had been shaved off and the head treated with
some kind of ointment — then the royal eye did not want to light
upon the bare head and so permission was given for the hat to
be worn. These were however usually people of secondary im¬
portance, though there is one example of the great Lord Burgh-
ley being allowed both to sit and to remain covered in front of
Queen Elizabeth I because of the greatness of his services. It is
rather funny to think that the real story behind the hat trick is
probably that one of the de Courcys had ring-worm instead of
being a doughty champion in the lists. In any event the practice
seems decidedly ill-mannered.
Without the age of the Kingsale peerage and the hat legend
what is there in the Kingsale story which deserves a place in the
annals of the aristocracy? We have the record of the dates of
birth, marriage and death of the more modem ones among these
lords, though even these details fail for the earlier peers. From
the time of the 6th Lord (1286—1344) to that of the 24th Baron
(circa 1720), we have apart from the hat stories, only about three
or four items which can be mentioned in a peerage history. The
6th Lord was Sheriff of Cork, was summoned to serve against the
Scots; the 9th Lord Kingsale had a grant of £100 from Richard
II; the 13th Lord had a pardon as we have seen for upholding
Lambert Simnel; the 17th Lord led an Irish regiment at the siege
of Boulogne; the 18th Lord fought against the Spaniards at
Kinsale; the 19th Lord was a gentleman of the Bedchamber to
Charles I; the 23rd Lord was the rebel pardoned by William III.
What a record, especially if set against that of other noble
families.
Still, if the greatness of the family in the past has depended on
the luck of the draw in obtaining a peerage in very early times
THE HOUSE OF DE COURCY
87
and in having a legend which is good copy for the popular press,
no one can deny that today the name of de Courcy is known all
over the world. ‘Kenneth de Courcy — the man who has his ear
to the Keyhole of the World. His agents are ever>^vhere, he
knows everything. Nothing escapes his eagle eye, and ferreting
nose. His brain bulges with grave and terrible secrets that even
M.I. 5 cannot discover.’ Thus Peter Forbes in The People (25
February 1951). From his home at Alderboume Manor in
Buckinghamshire, or from his stately house in Eaton Place in
London. Mr De Courcy has sent out to the ends of the earth Iiis
Intelligence Digest: A Review of World Affairs. For 32/- a
year this Digest can be supplied to subscribers and as there are
44.000 of these, £70,000 comes in from the Digest. The Digest is
quoted far and wide and Mr de Courcy finds friends and
enemies in curious quarters. For instance, the National Message,
the organ of the British Israelites, (16 April 1955) takes him to
task for having published abroad the idea that there cannot be
religious revival in this country any more, because according to
him prophecy says the exact opposite, Christ having stated that
He was not likely to find faith on earth at His return. This was
only one occasion however, and usually British Israel finds much
to approve in the de Courcy Digest. Certainly Mr de Courcy is a
very religious man. During the Coronation year he announced
that he would convert the dining room of his London home into
a chapel where during Coronation week he would hold meetings
and lead the prayers at 11 o’clock each morning for one hour
for the future of Britain. Mr de Courcy is chairman for Great
Britain of the Christian Statesmen Committee of the International
Council for Christian Leadership. He writes persuasively in tlie
Digest of the need for Christian people to realize the implications
of Communism and to take measures to prevent the spread of
that godless movement. He might be said to have inherited
religion for when he was bom at Oldham in 1909 his father
Stephen de Courcy described himself as an Independant
Minister; when his father was married at the Abbey Road Chapel
in Marylebone in 1899 he stated that he was an Evangelist. Mr
de Courcy stated that his father founded a religious organization
88
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
known as the HoUinwood Mission and was killed while giving
a magic lantern show in aid thereof (Daily Sketch 29 April 1953).
For many years during and after the war period I had heard
the name of Mr Kenneth Hugh de Courcy, Lord of the Manors
of Stow-on-the-Wold and Maugersbury in Gloucestershire,
Lieutenant late the Coldstream Guards (Special reserve). Na¬
turally one assumed that he was a member of the famous family
of the covered head, especially in view of his obvious acquain¬
tance with the great and the importance and splendour of all his
affairs. When he married, a few years ago, the Dean of Windsor
was the celebrant at his wedding which was solemnized in his
private chapel at Alderboume Manor. Inevitably, when an
unusual surname continually flashes before the public, people
are curious to know the connection of the bearer of the name
with its other associations. I was interested to learn of the line of
descent of Mr de Courcy, which he gives as follows
The fifteenth Lord Kingsale had been unusually prolific for a De
Courcy, or at least he had had the good luck to have his off¬
spring recorded in peerage books. His third son (1) James married
a woman called Catherine Callan and they had with other issue
a son (2) James de Courcy of whom nothing else is recorded
except the bare fact of his name. James in turn had three sons,
Maurice (3), David and James. There is an equal reticence about
tlie eldest and the youngest of these, but of (3) David the second
son it is stated that he was bom in 1612 and was exiled from
Cork in 1641. He married Abigail Holl in 1638 and died in
Galway in 1677. He had a son (4) Patrick bom at Cleggan in
Galway in 1644, who died there in 1628 at the age of 84, having
been careful however to beget a son (5), Michael at the age of
78 (mother's name not mentioned) who in turn lived to a ripe old
age of 75 when he died in 1797. Both Michael and his father
were buried on Omey Island. Michael had a son, (6) Patrick of
whom nothing is known except the few details given in the
marriage certificate of (7) Stephen Coursey (21 Febmary 1861)
who married Margaret Clogherty at SeUeraa in the parish of
> The generations are numbered in brackets from the 3rd son of the 15th
Lord to Mr. K. de Courcy’s grandfather.
THE HOUSE OF DE COURCY
89
Omey in the county of Galway. This Stephen Coursey was the
grandfather of Kenneth de Courcy. On his marriage certificate
he stated that he was a S.C.M. Agent, some kind of a missionary,
and that his father was Patrick Coursey, a farmer. Apparemtly
the air of wild Galway agreed witli this branch of tlie family for
Patrick Coursey who is identified with Patrick tlie son of Michael
De Courcy (died 1797) must have been bom in his fatlier’s old
age just as his father had been bom in the old age of his
(Patricks) grandfather. Four generations of Coursey (De Courcy)
cover more than 200 years. In the next generation when the child
of Stephen and Margaret is bom on 3 December 1869 we get
back to the aristocratic ‘de’ before the name. A strong religious
strain has entered the family and Stephen Coursey or de Coursey
describes himself as a Scripture Reader on his son’s birth
certificate.
I have given this pedigree in some detail because of the great
interest it must have for readers of the British Press. A consid¬
erable amoimt of work was done on the de Courcy genealogy by
the authorities at Dublin Castle. There, by the way, is the
Genealogical Office or Office of Arms which was set up by Mr
de Valera to take the place of the old Ulster Office where for
400 years the Ulster Kings of Arms had presided over the
Heraldry and Genealogy of Ireland. Sir Bernard Burke himself
had been Ulster King of Arms and had turned out many of his
famous works in his office in the Castle, but when Sir Neville
Wilkinson died in 1941, de Valera did not want to continue the
link with Britain. The British Government agreed to unite Ulster
Office with that of Norroy at the College of Arms in London,
while de Valera was left free to set up his own heraldic organi¬
zation. This is a good thing because continuity of record is thus
maintained and much useful research work is done as in the
case of the de Courcy pedigree which is recorded in Registered
Pedigrees Volume 29 (G.O. ms. 182a) page 26 et seq.. at Dublin
Castle. A note in the pedigree speaks of affidavits made by
members of the de Courcy family of Ballinaboy House, County
Galway to show the identity between the David who is the
patriarch of their own line and David outlawed in 1641. Ac-
90
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
cording to this note ‘Four individual affidavits testify to the
existence at Ballinaboy House of a family Bible, now presumed
to be destroyed. In this were inscribed genealogical particulars
relating to David de Courcy and his descendants, which supply
the generation immediately succeeding David. The makers of the
affidavits testify to having seen, and to having been required
to study this written record.’ The pedigree was registered at
Dubhn Castle on the basis of circumstantial evidence from
these affidavits and isolated references. They were not regar¬
ded as proof but the Irish authorities who knew the state of
their own national records were not surprised at this and did
not expect to find forthright proof such as would be regarded as
normal in England. Perhaps it was because of this circumstantial
evidence that Mr. de Courcy’s pedigree, registered in Ireland
with the Dublin Castle authorities is not registered in England
at the College of Heralds. Of course one heraldic authority is not
bound to accept something because another similar authority has
accepted it. There are such things as jealousies between pro¬
vinces, apart from the greater stringency required in the English
College, with its wealth of records undisturbed by wars and
rebellions. Whatever the cause, the fact remains that Mr. de
Courcy could not secure from the Enghsh authorities that
registration of his affiliation to the old de Courcy line which he
had obtained in Ireland. In Queen Victoria Street the most he
could get was a recording of some four or five generations
backwards from himself. The College of Arms always states that
registration of a pedigree with it is the highest test of authen¬
ticity which can be obtained; the measures used for testing
pedigrees bear this out. A pedigree before it can be recorded
must pass the whole Chapter of the College. Two independent
examiners, heralds who have not had the petitioner as their
client, are appointed to scrutinize the pedigree, and to pass it
As they have to assure the Chapter that they are satisfied ■with
the pedigree, they are obviously very rigorous in judging it, or
the registration of a mistake would be a serious matter. ®
they probably made many allowances for the paucity of Ins
records, owing to war and other commotions, the examiners o
THE HOUSE OF DE COURCY
91
the College were very strict with the de Courcy pedigree. It
did not reach their standards, and so only the modern portion
ot it, to about 1800 was recorded officially. At the same time, the
College has several systems of record and in one series of books
the authorities are prepared to enter matter which is supplied
by the clients of the heralds, but no comment on such matter is
made officially by the College, so that tliey cannot be accused
of having recorded something of which they disapprove or about
which they feel doubtful.
Perhaps the College examiners were distmbed by an entry in
Burkes Landed Gentry of Ireland, of 1912, which makes it ap¬
pear that from about the beginning of the 19th century until the
first world war Ballinaboy belonged to a family of gentry named
Morris, and not to any of the Galway de Courcys. In this account,
James Anthony Morris of Ballinaboy near Clifden in Galway is
said to have died in 1840, being succeeded by his son, who died
in 1898. Ballinaboy is a small place; there was at one time a
Ballinaboy School House and Church combined which was
apparently occupied by Stephen Courcy, who was a worker on
the religious missions, as shown by the various certificates quo¬
ted above. Ballinaboy House seems to have been destroyed at
some unspecified period, but then the Irish were always an in¬
considerate race especially where the property of the Anglo-
Irish lords of the soil was concerned.
Registered in Heralds Office in Ireland, but not in Herald’s
College in England, as a representative of a long lost branch of
the Kingsale tribe, can it be wondered at that a claimant should
feel annoyed? In the Daily Telegraph for 29 March, 1951, there
appeared the following notice:
The Solicitors to Mr. Kenneth Hugh de Courcy, of Alder-
boume Manor, Gerrards Cross, Bucks, the Editor of Intelligence
Digest, are instructed to make the following statement on his
behalf. A rumour is in circulation to the effect that Mr. de Courcy
has falsely represented himself to be entitled to the siurname by
which he is now known and to describe himself as of Irish
lineage. The facts are that Mr. de Courcy’s father was Stephen
de Courcy of the HoUinwood Evangelistic, a Medical Mission,
92
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
who was born in Co. Galway in 1869 and was killed in an
accident on December 26th 1911. His grandfather was Stephen
de Courcy of the Irish Church Mission, who was bom in County
Galway in 1823, and died 1919 at Ballinaboy House, Galway.
His great-grandfather was Patrick de Courcy, a farmer, who
was bom in Count>’ Galway in 1788 and died there in 1835. His
great-great-grandfather, Michael de Courcy, bom in County
Galway in 1722, where he died in 1797. The proofs of these facts
and of the fact that his family’s name has been de Gourcy and
is of Irish descent for many centuries is lodged in the office of
Iiis solicitors.’
One can sympathize with Mr. Kenneth de Gourcy. For many
centuries the Kingsale family have persisted, holding on to the
peerage which came their way so early, but producing no one
of eminence. Then at last from an obscure line, so obscure that
as can be seen genealogists even dispute the exact nature of its
connection with the parent stock, there emerges a man whose
name rings round the world. 'Hon. Sec. to Sir Reginald Mitchell
Banks’ so runs the Who’s Who account ‘unofficial committee on
Conservative policy, 1933; 1934, formed with Earl of Mansfield,
Viscount Clive, Lord Phillimore, and Victor Raikes, M.P. Im¬
perial Policy Group and was Hon. Sec. 1934—39; travelled as
Group’s chief observer of foreign affairs in Europe and America,
1935—39; special visit of inquiry to Mussolini, Dr. Benes, Dr.
Schuschnigg, 1936; to King Boris of Bulgaria etc. 1938; to Italy
and King Boris, 1939—^0; adviser on War Intelligence to United
Steel Companies Ltd., 1944—45; commenced publishing monthly
serial memoranda on Foreign Affairs and Strategy, 1938. When
Mrs de Courcy receives at Eaton Place, there is a full house of
the Diplomatic Corps. When she and her husband travel, the
matter is one for mention in the social columns, under the
Circular. Moreover, Kenneth de Courcy has the support of the
far distant cousins of the titled branch of the family. The present
Lord Kingsale deputed many matters to Kenneth de
such as the handling of proofs of the Kingsale article for Burkes
Peerage. More. Kenneth de Courcy became the guarian of
Michael de Courcy who was the heir to the title. The a er
THE HOUSE OF DE COURCY
93
kiUed in an air crash in January 1953 as an Acting Pilot Officer.
He was only 22 but his life had not been all smooth. In 1950
he had proposed marriage to a typist who worked in the office
of his guardian but as he was then under 21 Kennetli de Courcy
made Michael ward in Chancery. The marriage took place, how¬
ever, and Miss Anne Barrett became Mrs. Michael de Courcy
at a registry office in Dumfrieshire.
There are few males in the Kingsale family. Beside the present
heir, a half brother of Michael de Courcy, and three other men
who descend from the 25th Baron and of whom little is kmown,
there is only the long lost Galway branch. Now Irish titles are
funny things. English titles are held under the searclilight of
publicity and the necessit>' of having to prove them for the
satisfaction of the House of Lords. Such claims come up regu¬
larly as father is succeeded by son, or cousin by cousin; but not
all the Irish peers have seats in the House of Lords, in fact only
five of them now have, these being the last relics of those who
were elected to the House before 1922. The only way in which
the holder of an Irish peerage can establish his right to that
peerage is by proving his right to vote at elections of Irish Re¬
presentative Peers. The matter goes before the Attorney General
who, if satisfied as to the prima facie case, gives permission for
the petitioner to proceed before the Committee of Privileges. But
who is deliberatly going to seek the privilege of voting at an
election which now never takes place? This is especially the case
as Irish peers as such may not again be summoned to a Coro¬
nation. What then will be the position with regard to a claimant
to an Irish peerage? If no constitutional importance attaches to
ms title, and if no responsible body has any interest in deciding
his claim, there seems to be no reason to prevent a person from
merely assuming an Irish peerage. In these circumstances tlie
question of a diKerence between the views of Dublin Castle and
o the College of Arms would be purely academic, a matter of
interest for a minority of genealogists. In this case if the line of
de Courcy which is generaUy known and acknowledged were to
die out it would probably be possible for Mr Kenneth de
94
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Courcy or his heir to advance a claim to this ancient barony. It
is at least a curiosity that in 800 years we have had only two
de Courcys who have been famous; John, conqueror of Ulster
whose connection with the family is not proven, and Kenneth the
proprietor of the Digest, whose Dublin recorded pedigree the
College of Arms according to its own statement does not feel
justified in accepting.
Chapter six
WAVELL
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
W hen in December 1953 the weapon of a Mau Man assassin
cut short the life of the second Earl Wavell, it ended
also a distinguished line of men who for generations had served
England with a single-hearted devotion, and whose family history
stretched back into the remoter portions of her history. The death
of Archibald John Arthur Wavell, the second Earl was rendered
all the more tragic by the fact that he was such a keen and alert
personality. Only a few months before his death I had met him
and had tea with him.
It was my first meeting, though I had met his father and
several other members of his family, and I was interested to note
the second Earl’s awakening curiosity in some of the problems of
the long history of the Wavells. He had collected a number of
references to Wavells who in the Middle Ages had been associa¬
ted with the City and College of Winchester. It was not always
easy to fit some of these people on to die existing pedigree and
Lord Wavell discussed with me how this might be done. He
decided that as he was going out to serve in East Africa, the
matter should be deferred imtil his return; he wished to be able
to undertake at least some of the research work himself. It was
a delightful surprise to find an interest in old things in a young
peer. I noticed that one of his hands was half concealed by his
sleeve and I recollected that in his war record it was stated that
he had been wounded and had been awarded the Military Cross.
Lord Wavell was a Major in the Black Watch and when he was
95
96
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
20 had seen service in Palestine from 1936—39, being wounded
He served throughout the whole of the second world war when
his more serious wound was inflicted.
The Black Watch and Winchester. In the arms of Lord Wavell
tlie two supporters indicated some of the most abiding of the
family's interests and connections. On the right of the shield was
a soldier of the Black Watch in field service uniform holding his
rifle at his side; on the left was a scholar of Winchester College
wearing his gown and carrying in his left hand a closed book.
Lord WaveU like his father the first Earl, and his grandfather
Major-General Archibald Graham Wavell, had served in the
Black Watch. This connection with the Black Watch was the
origin of the newspaper legend, mentioned so much in accounts
of the first Earl Wavell’s African campaigns, that he was a hardy
Scotsman. In fact there was no Scottish blood in the family
except for the contiibution made by Anne Paxton, the youngest
daughter of Sir William Paxton, who in 1825 had married Arthur
Goodall Wavell, the grandfather of the first Earl.
The association with Winchester went back nearly 500 years
and there were Wavells at that place before William of Wyke-
ham established the College there.
The remote ancestry of the Wavell family can be traced to the
village of Vauville which stands on the bay of the same name in
the western portion of the Cherbourg peninsula, right opposite
the island of Alderney. The name of Wavell is derived from
Vauville where the founders of the family were seigneurs before
the Norman Conquest. A chateau dating from the 15th or 16th
century stands near the village, and there was formerly a castle.
The seigneurs of Vauville were a younger branch of the Barons
of Briquebec, who like so many others of the ruling caste m
Normandy were descended from the old Norsemen who had
wrung Normandy from Charles the Simple and had given it ite
name. These fierce Norse pagans settled down in Normandy and
became, according to their own viewpoint, Christian gentlemen.
They soon forget their old language and acquired a French cul¬
ture which was only a veneer. The old Norse energy ^ ‘ re¬
mained with them and they could be savagely cruel especially
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
97
when they had secured the Church’s blessing on their work.
From among them William the Conqueror recruited the bulk
of his army to conquer England in 1066. One of those who
accompanied the Conqueror to England was Sir Richard De
Vauville. His name and that of a William de Vauville or Wav-
villa occur in charters and deeds both in Normandy and in Eng¬
land. BeUveen the years 1066 and 1200 there are numerous
mentions of the name WaveU or Vauville in the annals of Nor¬
mandy, but there is no definite proof of a permanent settlement
in England before 1200. Perhaps their final settlement in Eng¬
land had some connection with King John s loss of Normandy.
Horace said that Vixere fortes ante Agamemnona but that they
were not known Quia carent vote sacro. It is to the tireless
labours over 20 years of one man that the Wavells themselves
and hence the world know so much of the illustrious earlier
history of the family. Mr Edward Wavell, a scion of this great
house, has collected with a diligence that cannot be too highly
praised, every detail of Wavelliana upon which he can lay his
hands. Not the least valuable of his achievements has been a
correspondence with a former Abb6 of Vauville whereby much
information became available about the benefactions of the
mediaeval Wavells. The Abb6, Noel Langlois, said that the
Priory of Vauville was almost over\vhelmed with benefits from
generation to generation by the De Vauvilles. It was by the
efforts of the Abbe that )ust before the war an ancient Sanctuary
consecrated to the Archangel St. Michael in the Priory of Vau¬
ville was restored. When the Germans occupied the district they
destroyed this sanctuary. The Abb6 Langlois was sure that St.
Michael would give victory to the English against these desecra-
tors, especially as a descendant of the de Vauvilles was amongst
the British leaders.
It was a Sir Richard Vauville who settled in Sussex in King
Johns time. Between 1200 and 1400 the Wavells were found in
Sussex, Bedfordshire and Somerset, for the most part holding
lands in the form of knights’ fees. Sometimes the estates amoun¬
ted to nearly 1000 acres in Sussex and Richard Weyvill was M.P.
for Sussex in 1413, also being engaged in the king’s business, to
9S
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
collect troops to protect Sussex from invasion.
About the close of the Middle Ages we find the Wavells
settled in the Isle of Wight and here John Wavell bought the
Manor of Atherfield and died before 1592. He had a younger
son, David, from whose son Thomas, Earl Wavell was descended.
It is from about this time that the Wavell connection with Win¬
chester becomes very important. One of the cousins of the hne
which we shall be presently tracing, Thomas Wavell, was Mayor
of Winchester three times. It was during his last term of office
in 1687—88 that he refused to surrender the Charter of Win¬
chester to King James II when the latter as part of his scheme
to govern England despotically, was seeking to revoke charters
granted to various cities by his predecessors. When the demand
was made for the return of the charter Thomas Wavell replied
that ‘as the citizens of Winchester had not committed any of¬
fence against the Crown to subject them to the loss of their
charter he did not conceive that a power was legally vested in
the King to make such a demand; that it was therefore the
resolution of his fellow citizens in general not to comply with
the direction of the writ, tiU His Majesty had shown a legal
cause and authority for the same.’ It was not until the mayoralty
of this public spirited citizen had expired that Winchester sur¬
rendered its charter, and even then the King, as though respec¬
ting such civic tenacity, immediately restored it. Thomas Wavell
had two sons who between them served six terms of office in the
Mayoralty. These Wavells were of course cousins of Lord Wavell
and the City of Winchester had therefore good reason to bestow
upon him in September 1943, when he was Viceroy-Designate of
India the Freedom of the City which his kinsmen had served so
well. As the Recorder of Winchester said in handing the scroll of
Freedom to the Mayor, Winchester was not only honourmg Lord
Wavell but also his family,' whose name has appeared mne times
on the Roll of Winchester s Mayors and which has wo^^
served the Church and Cathedral, the Civic life and the College.
It is from David Wavell a freeholder in 1606 that Ae hne
of descent is traced. He had a younger son Thomas Wavell a
soldier in the great Civil War between Charles I and his Parha-
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
99
ment. Thomas was a Major and a strong Cavalier, but his
younger son the Rev. Richard VVavell evidently took the other
side in politics for he was one of the ministers of the Church who
were deprived of their livelihood by the Act of Uniformity in
1662. Pastor Wavell, for so it seems best to term him, was born
in 1633 at Limerston in the Isle of Wight. He took his B.A. degree
at Oxford in 1657 and in 1658 was ministering at Egham in Sur¬
rey where he married Anna Bale. His ministry was soon distur¬
bed, for by the Act of Uniformity the Book of Common Prayer
was restored to its proper use in the Church of England. 2000 of
the clergy who were then officiating in the Church and who
could not give their unfeigned assent to everything in the Book
were turned out of their livings without any financial provision
whatever. The earlier Parliaments of Charles II were only too
anxious to demonstrate their loyalty by passing harsh laws
against the Dissenters and in 1664 the Conventicle Act made
prison and transportation the penalty for those who were caught
in the act of dissenting worship. Richard Wavell could have had
a living of £200 a year if he would have conformed, but he
was resolute to follow the biddings of his conscience and was
confident that God would provide for him. He told the people
of Pinner s Hall, Old Broad Street, London, where he was Pastor
that he would venture his person if they would venture their
purses, and we learn from the records that they did, and were
thereby put to no small expense. On one occasion Wavell was
obliged to give bail for his appearance at the Sessions, and had
to appear at the bar before the magistrates. The then Lord Mayor,
Sir Henry Tulse, was his kinsman and through this chance Wavell
escaped the full rigour of the law.
Richard Wavell exhibited some of the best qualities of the
Christian character. Although steadfast in his own beliefs, he
was not bitter against his persecutors. His preaching was to
exalt Christ and the Grace of God through Him, but it was his
humility which made him declare that his successor as Pastor
should preach Christ more than he had done. He died in great
peace as he was going to bed on 19 December 1705 and left a
name honoured in the annals of Nonconformity. He lies buried in
100
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
B unhill Fields, London, the burial place of John Bunyan. His
children seem to have thriven, for one of them lived at Clapham,
then a good residential neighbourhood and had an estate at
Richmond in Surrey. It was this son who was the first of the
family, at least in modern times to use arms, which are en¬
graved on his tomb at Holy Trinity Church, Clapham. It was
from another son of the Rev. Richard Wavell that Earl Wavell
descended. The grandson of the Pastor, John Wavell, lived at
Newchurch, Isle of Wight, and his fourth son left a name well
knovvm in the field of science where the mineral Wavellite com¬
memorates him.
This fourth son was William Wavell M.D., F.R.S., of Barn¬
staple, Devon, surgeon, geologist and botanist. He made many
botanical researches and Sir Humphry Davy read a paper in
1805 before the Royal Society on Wavell’s discovery of Wavellite.
This is described for the benefit of the curious as ‘a mineral
consisting of hydrated aluminium phosphate, crystallizing in the
orthorhombic system. Distinct crystals are a rare occurence, the
mineral usually taking the form of hemispherical or globular
aggregates with an internal radiated structure. It is translucent
and varies in colour from grey or white to greenish, yellowish
etc.’
Dr Wavell was the great grandfather of the first Earl. His
second son was Major General Arthur Goodall Wavell who lived
near Stockbridge, Hampshire after he had retired from the army.
His career in military spheres is so remarkable that it deserves a
special mention.
Arthur Goodall Wavell, who was bom in 1785 and who died
in 1860, was educated at Winchester and after leaving school
became a cadet and then a lieutenant in the service of the East
India Company. ApparenUy India did not suit his health and he
applied for leave on grounds of sickness, but his idea of furloug
was to enlist as a volunteer in the Spanish army in the Femnsular
War, which was then raging in Spain. In that service he reached
the rank of Lieutenant Colonel and was employed as a Clnef
Engineer. He became so interested in the Spamsh ™ Aat
he completely forgot his commission with the East Indi
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
JOl
pany and was struck off their list in 1816 for having overstayed
his leave. He received several distinctions from the Spanish
government, the Cross of the Royal and Military Order of San
Fernando, and the supernumerary cross of the Royal and Military
Order of Charles III. Permission to accept and wear these deco¬
rations was granted by the Prince Regent, afterwards George IV,
and this royal concession was duly registered in the College of
.\rms. Wavell was highly recommended to the notice of the
British Government but the usual hide-bound formalism prevailed
and he could not be knighted because he was not a general
officer. He could not obtain employment either, but he did get
the thanks of the Duke of York, then Commander-in-Chief of the
British army, for some of his work. What he could not obtain
in England, Wavell sought in Spanish America where a revo¬
lution was going on for independence from Spain. Simon Bolivar
was responsible for the liberation from Spanish rule of several
provinces of South America; Bernardo O’ Higgins was the leader
in Chile. Both received much help from British volunteers and
among those who went to Chile was Colonel Wavell. There his
work was equally successful and he proceeded to Mexico. Both
in Chile and in Me.xico he held the rank of Major-General in the
army. In Mexico however his main employment was in diplo¬
matic work to secure the recognition of Mexican independence
from the British Government. He was also the first person to
suggest a scheme whereby millions of British capital could be
employed in working the mines of Mexico. For this he never
received any solid recognition from the British government or
anything at all beyond thanks from highly placed persons and
flattering references to his abilities and gallant conduct. From
the Mexican government however, he had what appeared at
first to be a most substantial mark of its favour, nothing less
than the grant of 5 million acres of land in Texas which was then
reckoned by the Mexicans as part of their territory, but which
stood in the way of the great westward march of the United
States. Americans who were already settled in the area of Texas
under Mexican control found it very difficult to secure confir¬
mation of their grants or possessions. Some of them were assisted
102
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
by WaveU when they came to Mexico City to press their claims.
Some were grateful, but one of the most able of them
showed a monumental ingratitude towards Wavell. This was
Stephen Fuller Austin, after whom the State Capital of Texas,
Austin, is named. Austin received help in various ways from
Wavell, in consideration of which Austin was to give Wavell a
share of his lands on the river Colorado. Wavell advanced some
money to Austin which was never repaid, nor did Wavell get
any land in Texas after it had become an American state. To make
matters worse Wavell’s friendliness with the Americans rendered
him suspect to the Mexican Government, with the result that he
could not get his Mexican pay or compensation for any of his
losses. In disgust he returned home and applied to the British
Government for help in securing the recognition of his rights in
Texas, but as often happens in cases of British subjects and their
sufferings abroad, nothing was done. Lord Aberdeen, then
Foreign Secretary, sent one of the unoBicial notes which come
so readily to people in high positions. ‘Do not trouble more about
the matter — it was only after all an estate of 5 million acres —
‘But catch your trout and sip your port, not disdaining an inter¬
mixture of sherry, especially after soup.’
Wavell seems to have been generally unlucky in money mat¬
ters, probably because his honourable principles as an English
gentleman got in the way of his taking all the advantages he
could in a given situation. He was one of that band of English¬
men who being devoted to the cause of freedom have sacrificed
much to help others in foreign lands to gain their liberty. Like
many others of this devoted band. General Wavell was honoured
after his death. During the last war when the B.B.C. was making
so great an effort to render the cause of freedom articulate
throughout the world, an account of General Wavell’s career
was given in the Spanish service 'La Voz de Londres. This was
in March 1943 when a dramatic programme was broadcast on the
life of WaveU, with both the Chilean and Mexican Ambassadors
present. Much point was given to this broadcast by the fact that
the General was the grandfather of Field Marshal Earl Wavell,
and there were several recordings of it. Interest was also
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
103
awakened in the United States during the last war when the
first Earl’s name was one to conjure with. With the enthusi¬
asm which marks all undertakings on which Americans once
embark, the story of Wavell’s land was brought forward by
State Archivists and research scholars. In the Dallas Morning
News of Texas, there appeared an article on the 2nd March,
1941, on the efforts Wavell had made to settle tlie grant of land
he had received. Tf Wavell’s ancestor hadn’t loaned money to
Austin there might have been no State.’ In 1942 Lord Halifax,
the British Ambassador to the U.S.A., while visiting the State
Library at the State Capital, Austin, was shown a collection of
Wavell’s letters and wrote to Lord Wavell to ask the relation¬
ship of the writer of the letters to Lord Wavell. Thus England
lived up to her reputation of honouring her sons after they have
passed beyond earthly reward.
The great though unprofitable career of Arthur Goodall
Wavell started his family on the lines of a military career, from
which they had desisted for some generations, though in the
Middle Ages there had been Wavell knights in every generation.
It was his fourth son, Archibald Graham Wavell, who was the
father of the first Earl but it is impossible to refrain from
mentioning other members of this fine family with its long
record of service. One of Arthur Goodall Wavell’s grandsons was
Major Arthur John Byng Wavell who made his name as a tra¬
veller to Mecca. He spoke fluent French, Italian, Arabic and
Swahili and an account of his work is given in the late Lord
Tweedsmuir's (John Buchan’s) book. The Last Secrets, and also in
Major Wavell’s own book, A Modern Pilgrim in Mecca. Previous
to his Arabian journey Major Wavell made many journeys in
Africa and his knowledge was of great service in the 1914 war
against the German colonies. It was in 1908 that he went to
Mecca and Medina, where few travellers who did not profess
Islam had penetrated and Uved to tell the story. Some had gone
there in disguise or as professed Moslems, and Major Wavell’s
experiences were among the most fascinating and curious. He
fell fighting against the Germans in 1916 at Mwele, British East
Africa.
104
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Another son of Arthur Goodall Wavell, Llewellyn Wavell,
served in the Indian Army and at the siege of Delhi in the Indian
Mutiny was one of the first officers through the city gate (called
the Cawnpore Gate and still preserved with the marks of cannon
balls upon it) when it was blown in. He was described as ‘that
brave boy Wavell’ and well deserved the description for, at the
risk of his life he bore Woodcock, one of his comrades who had
been wounded, on his back through the storm of grape shot and
bullets to a place of safety. This glorious action took place in a
lane leading from the captured gate, at the head of which the
rebels had planted a battery of artillery. In addition, Llewellyn
Wavell, who became a Golonel, was keenly interested in all
that concerned the welfare of the soldier and was for 20 years
Honorary Secretary of the Aldershot and Pirbright Church of
England Soldiers’ Institute.
We have here the by now familiar pattern of Wavell life, the
devotion to duty and service of a grand race of men, shown in
private and public as well in peace as in war. With Archibald
Graham Wavell, father of the first Earl, we have again a military
career, but this time in the British Army, where he became a
Major-General and a C.B. He served in the Zulu and Basuto
Wars and in the South African War. With such a parentage and
ancestry it is not surprising that Archibald Wavell should have
become a soldier too.
He was educated at Winchester like so many of his forbears
and then went on to Sandhurst; on passing out from there he was
commissioned in the Black Watch, being just 18. This was in
January 1901 and in the autumn of that year he went out -with
the second battalion of the regiment to South Africa where the
final stages of the South Africaner Boer Warwere in progress. Some
of the most determined of the Boer leaders were operating the
Commando tactics which were to have such influence on Bntish
warfare against Nazi occupied Europe 40 years later. In many
respects our troops had their hardest task in the whole of Ae Boer
War in these last few months for the Boers were elusive to a
degree, and combined the quaUty of hard hitting with that of
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
105
disappearing swiftly. It was against such enemies that Archibald
Waved gained his first e.xperience of war. He came through
without wounds but in a football match he had a fall which
broke his left shoulder blade and collar bone, with the result
that he was never able afterwards to raise his left arm straight
above his head. When he recovered, Waved rejoined his regiment
on the North West Frontier of India where British regiments
used to acquire practical experience of war while Continental
Armies went on manoeuvres. Sport also was to be had in great
quantity and Waved, a keen sportsman, found plenty of oppor¬
tunity for his tastes in polo and big game shooting. He also added
to his knowledge of war, for being appointed Transport Officer
to an Indian mounted battery, he managed to get himself made
C.O. of an ammunition column in the force which was being
sent against the Zakka Khel, one of the tribes of the Afridi group
who inhabit the no-man’s land betxveen Afghanistan and India.
This was his first independent command, which was rapid ad¬
vancement for a subaltern only a few months out of Sandhurst.
The warfare was of the usual nature between British troops and
the frontier tribesmen, but in Waved’s case it gave him an in¬
sight into the form branch of modem warfare, for he had much
explaining to do to clear up his failure in completing the right
forms when making up his ammunition column.
In 1908 Waved was on leave in England and passed into the
Staff Codege at Camberley where he was considered by the then
Commandant as the ablest officer he had met. He was always
quick to seize opportunities to improve his knowledge of his
profession and having the chance to visit Russia on leave, he
took it and also went there in 1912 and 1913. He was able to
satisfy the War Office standards in the Russian language from
which he was later to translate a book. When war came in 1914
Waved was sent to France in the September and some weeks
later was made Brigade Major to the 9th Infantry Brigade. He
was continuady in the front line positions and went through the
first battle of Ypres and the action of Bedewaarde. It was in the
latter that he was struck in the left eye by a splinter from a 5.9
shed or by a machine gun budet which caused blindness in the
106
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
eye. He was sent in 1916 to Russia where he served on the front
against the Turks in the Caucasus. He had married in 1915
Eugenie Marie, only daughter of Col. John Owen Quirk, and
Mrs. Wavell had managed to follow him to Russia. When the
Soviet Revolution came, the Wavells were able to get back to
England through Finland and Scandinavia. On his return Wavell
was ordered to carry out liaison work between the War Office
and General AUenby who was then about to begin his victorious
campaign against the Turks. In Palestine the war was not con¬
fined as it was in the West by the trench system and Wavell
must have learnt a great deal which was to prove of inestimable
value to him in his own warfare in the Libyan desert. He was
deeply interested and his book on AUenby showed how closely
he had studied the eastern warfare, including the use of air
power. Apart from a brief speU at VersaiUes, Wavell spent his
time until 1920 at AUenby’s H.Q. In 1920 he rejoined his regiment
in the Army of Occupation in Germany and in 1921 he was
appointed Colonel. He had gained the M.C. in the war and had
been mentioned several times in despatches. Wavells progress
went on in the 20 year period between World War I and II. He
was promoted Major-General in 1933 and in 1937 was appointed
Commander in Palestine where he was successful in restoring
order in the Jewish-Arab disturbances. During this period he
came into contact with Orde Wingate, that weird creature whose
spectacular exploits with the Chindits in Burma ended, perhaps
fortunately, with his death, for had he lived his pro-Israeli
sentiments would probably have made him take arms against his
country. Wavell was G.O.C. the Southern Command 1938 9
and in 1939 he was knighted. In the years between the two
world wars Wavell wrote on various aspects of warfare and gave
lectures on military tactics at Cambridge University and at the
Royal United Service Institution.
During the last war Wavells lectures were frequently quoted
for the benefit of those who were training to be officers; in
particular, one of his dicta was impressed upon us, namely that
in an emergency it was essential to do something rather than just
wait for the course of events. Wavells name was far better kno\vn
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
107
outside Britain than in it, for it was his misfortune to belong
to a profession which powerful and vociferous elements in the
country affected to despise. The soldier was only wanted when
some pious minded crank wished to interfere with Manchuria or
Ethiopia. But abroad, Wavell, like General de Gaulle, was already
noted by his future antagonists, and it was the German General
Keitel, who before the war declared that Wavell was an in¬
comparably good general.
In 1939 at the outbreak of war Sir Archibald Wavell was
appointed C-in-C of the Middle East, a vast area which stretched
from the borders of Syria to the Gulf of Aden, which was sparsely
occupied by our troops and where we relied on the French to
supply most of the man power. The collapse of our Latin ally
meant that we could no longer rely on large French armies in
North Africa and Syria, and when the might of the warlike
Italians (who have hardly ever won a war in the whole of history)
was brought against us, Wavell was outnumbered by ten to one.
He had not more than 60,000 all told under his command,
whereas the Italians had between 250,000 and 300,000 men in
Libya and the same number in Italian East Africa. At first every¬
thing seemed to be going in the Italians’ favour and they exulted
when they were able to overrun British Somaliland, driving out
the police force which was their only opposition. In Libya the
Italian General was Marshal Graziani who had won great fame
by suppressing the Senussi tribesmen. However it was one thing
to beat these natives by methods even more fantastically cruel
than their own, such as throwing them alive from aeroplanes in
full flight, and another to contend with a properly trained com¬
mander. Judging by the Italian descriptions, one might have
thought that Graziani was a CUve and a Marlborough rolled into
one, but in fact his powers of generalship had never been
properly tested. He tried to invade Egypt but did not get beyond
Sidi Barram where he halted, apparently not quite sure what to
do. His troops were then subjected to constant harrassing by
Wavell s army, in commando raids across the desert; by these
the British troops were trained in desert warfare while the
Italians became nervous and restless. Meanwhile reinforcements
108
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
arrived in Egypt for Waved and in December 1940 when our
affairs seemed to be at their lowest ebb, he struck. In less than
three months Grazianis army had disappeared. Apart from
killed and wounded, 133,000 prisoners were taken, and the whole
of Libya as far as Benghazi was cleared of the Italians. Graziani’s
reputation was deflated and it never recovered. The Italians
were plunged into despair from which they were rescued by the
German intervention in North Africa. This came at a time when
many of Wavell’s troops had had to be sent to assist the Greeks
in their struggle against the Germans. The British army was
unable to keep the Germans from over-running Greece, nor could
it hold Crete against airborne attack, but the withdrawal of these
troops weakened the army in North Africa so that Waved was
forced to retreat. It was WaveU’s constant misfortune to have
to work with inadequate forces, to show the way to victory, and
then to have the triumph taken from his hands and for someone
else to achieve what he, through no fault of his own had been
prevented from doing. None the less, WaveU’s achievement in
the dark days of 1940—41 cannot be over estimated. He had
given the British people hope. The greatest gain was in morale.
The British people had experienced nothing but retreats on the
part of their troops, foUowed by the fall of France and the
horrible ordeal of the nightly bombing of London and other
great cities. A British General came forward in the midst of aU
this gloom and misery, who was more than equal to the enemy’s
best, and who for a few months had a series of brilliant victories
to his credit. Compared with other commanders in the war.
Waved was or appeared to be reserved; he did not go around
making speeches or purporting to take the troops into his con¬
fidence but he did have the confidence of his men in fuU mea¬
sure. Enough that Australian troops believed in him and his
leadership. Although he had always to act with inferior numbers
and although tlie Germans had won back much of Libya, Waved
was able to reoccupy British Somaliland and to destroy Ae
Italian armies in East Africa and Abyssinia. The Iraqi rebellion
was crushed and in 1941 Syria was taken over despite French
resistance. It was to be two years however before the road to
THE HOUSE OF WAVELL
109
Tunis was occupied by British troops.
In July 1941 Wavell exchanged commands with Auchinleck
and became C-in-C India. Here his tasks were formidable, for
he had to build up an Indian army from 200,000 to over 214
million men, while at the same time arranging for important
tasks such as the occupation of Persia in conjunction with the
Russians. Once more after the Japanese invasion of the South¬
west Pacific area Wavell had the task of fighting against greatly
superior numbers and equipment. It was not possible to do more
than hold on doggedly.
In 1943 a momentous change took place, for Wavell was asked
to leave his military career and become Viceroy of India. In the
words of Mr Kieman, his biographer, the governments view
'In offering this highest appointment in the East, may be easily
conjectured. In Wavell it had a man witli no political past, one
above intrigue and faction, courageous, accustomed to clear
tliinking as to the desirable objectives and determined to reach
them, and ^vith immense prestige throughout the world as a sol¬
dier and a man of honour’. WaveU remained Viceroy until 1947
when he was succeeded by the last of the Viceroys, Earl Mount-
batten of Burma. In all his career Wavell could not have under¬
taken a more thankless task than that of holding supreme power
in India during the last stages of the British surrender. Only
those who have actual experience of politically minded Indians
in India itself, can have any conception of the gruelling nature of
Wavell’s position as Viceroy. For him work could almost be said
to have begun on that Sunday in 1945 when he read the Song of
Deborah at the great Thanksgiving Service for the collapse of
Japan which was held at the Church of the Redemption in New
Delhi (this beautiful Church which was built by Lord Halifax
when he was Viceroy, is now the Cathedral of the Diocese of
New Delhi). Thereafter the clamour for independence grew on
the part of the Indian politicians and was increased by the
arrival in power of a British government, Mr Attlee’s first ad¬
ministration, fully pledged to renounce the British Raj. Wavell
believed in cautious methods which were not suitable for the
ignorant in England who could hardly wait for democracy to
110
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
function in Indici; in 1947 after four of the inost frustrating
years in his career, Wavell was summoned home, he received an
Earldom and was succeeded by Lord Mountbatten whose destiny
it was to preside over the liquidation of our great Indian Empire.
For Wavell the end of his period as Viceroy must have been a
matter of relief, to be relieved of a distasteful task. Honours
flowed in upon him; he was made Constable of the Tower,
Chancellor of Aberdeen University, High Steward of Colchester;
he received the freedom of Winchester and of Perth; he had
twelve foreign orders of Chivalry as well as those of his own
country. He was not a wealthy man, for he had never had the
inclination or the opportunity to seek wealth; like his grand¬
father who had been cheated of his dues in Texas, Wavell was
not a man in the tradition of the sordid commercialism of big
business and cartels, mergers and the like. He found one of his
great interests in poetry and in writing. Modestly he brought out
an anthology. Others Meris Flowers which contained the poems
he had loved the best and which had been a solace and in¬
spiration to him. He was much in demand at public functions
and when he was induced to speak he acted always with the
easy good manners which had marked him through life. When
he died Britain and the world lost a character of sterling value.
Fortunately he did not live to see the death of his only son;
tragedy had already visited his family, however, for while he
was Viceroy, his youngest daughter had lost her husband, Major
the Hon. Simon Astley, Lord Hastings son. The death occurred
in a car accident in Quetta and I well recall among my memories
of the Wavell family, the news coming through in the emergency
operations room in New Delhi (we were then in 1946 expecting
one of the recurring threats of an Indian outbreak) as I was
trying to snatch a few minutes rest on a table. We were asked to
convey the news to Viceregal Lodge and for a plane to fly rela¬
tives to the scene of the crash, for it was not then known that
Astley was dead.
Now with the tragic death of the second Earl, the title, con¬
ferred for war services becomes extinct. It seems a
that this title should not be carried on and the name of Wavell
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
111
be enshrined in the peerage. If like the other wartime peerages
of Earl Mountbatten and Viscount Portal a special remainder
were permitted the Wavell Earldom could then pass to the first
Earl’s daughters and their issue. It is hard to see why a simple
remedial measure of this nature cannot be decreed to preserve
the name of Wavell.
The shield of arms of Wavell shows in its main charge the
connection of olden days with Normandy, in the fleur de lis;
the Sussex martlets denote the ancestral lines in Sussex. The
melancholy words ‘Extinct Peerage’ have now conveyed into the
mounds of the past the life of a great family which never
hesitated to give of its best in peace or war to its country. May
new life spring from the remaining lines to add fresh lustre to
the name.
Chapter seven
MONTROSE
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
W avell in England, Montrose in Scotland; one in the 20th
century, the other in the 17th, 300 years between them
but the principle of honour and service the same. Some years ago
it was my pleasure and pride to hold in my hands the sword of
Red John of the Battles, the nickname of John Graham of Claver-
house. Viscount Dundee. I was a guest in the home of a descen¬
dant of one of the lines of the house of Graham, and all around
me there were pictures and other memorials of the family. L.ong
dead Grahams looked down upon me, swords, daggers and jewels
which had belonged to this great historic family were there, but
to me none equalled in interest the short simple blade with its
unelaborate handle, for it had belonged to Bonnie Dundee. Yet
such is the ignorance of many people that to-day those who
read of the Duke of Montrose and the fact that many of the old
ancestral Graham lands have been sold for taxation purposes,
may well have no knowledge of the part which the Grahams
have played in British history. Even those who have a smattering
of knowledge of Claverhouse, may not easily remember or reahze
that he was a kinsman of the great Marquess of Montrose, the
last hope of Charles I. The Great Marquess as he is usually
termed in Scotland was descended, as was Claverhouse, from Sir
William Graham of Kincardine, who lived about 1407. The line
of the Marquess is the senior line of Graham, and he was the
ancestor of the Duke of Montrose. From the younger sons of
Sir William Graham descend the various and numerous lines of
112
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
113
Grahams, such as the Grahams of Fintry, of Claverhouse (hence
the name by which John Graham of Claverhouse is usually
called), and of Morphie and many others. The Great Mirrquess
and Claverhouse had much in common beside tlie fact that they
belonged to the same family. Each served with selfless devotion
the house of Stuart; each was badly rewarded by the Stuart
sovereign to whom he gave his all; each was a skilful soldier and
an accomplished man of the world; each gave his life in the
cause in which he believed. But Montrose was of the more
chivalrous cast; as Cardinal de Betz observed, he seemed to be
made in the mould of one the great heroes of antiquity. On his
fame no aspersions have been cast save for the fanatical untruths
of some of the contemporary Presbyterian ministers. But in the
case of Claverhouse, other views, notably those of Macaulay and
Sir Walter Scott have prevailed, for long periods, and it has not
been until very recent times that champions have appeared to
clear his name.
Montrose towers out above his contemporaries as the one man
who not only adhered to his king even when the king was plan¬
ning to discard him, but also as the true chivalrous knight of
legend, set in the sordid ways of history. In an age when hateful
religious strife had made men more cruel than they deserved to
be by nature, Montrose preserved his integrity. When his friends
were being murdered at the instigation of the ministers of the
Scotch Kirk, he resisted the urgent appeals of his officers to
make reprisals on the prisoners he held at Blair AthoU. On the
battle-field he gave quarter when others urged him to a massacre.
Merciful to his enemies, he was very true to his friends. At Dun¬
dee when the grim news came of the approach from a short
distance of a greatly superior force, he was urged to abandon
his infantry, but he refused to consider such a thing. In the event,
he steered his small force to the safety of the mountains. He did
not become vituperative, even when he was being led to an
ignominious death. He passed through the troubled scene of tlie
nth century like one of those paladins of romance, or as the
truly s^tless knight of Arthur’s Table without fear and without
reproach.
114
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
With this high souJed character there went a consummate
ability as a general. He was only 38 when he was executed, and
at the age of 33, with hardly any tra inin g, he became the Com-
mander-in-Chief in Scotland of the King’s forces. Indeed, after
an amazing run of victories for over a year, Montrose was able
to subdue all Scotland for Charles I, and was appointed Gover¬
nor of the kingdom. Yet these victories and this wonderful result
were achieved with armies which never exceeded 4000 or 5000,
while the enemy opposed to him had nearly always superior
numbers. Nor was the Marquess a rough soldier of uncultivated
manners. He was the most accomplished gentleman of his time
in Scotland, a good if not exact scholar, a man of taste, and a
poet.
How was this man with no professional training, opposed to
Scots who had served in the Swedish or German wars, with
inferior numbers and resources, witliout the full backing of the
King whom he served, able to hold together the Highlanders
who were wont to disperse to their homes when they had
collected sufficient booty? Montrose and Claverhouse were both
of the Lowland stock and yet no Highland chief could have had
as devoted and enthusiastic a following.
The circumstances of the time into which Montrose was bom
are difficult for the modem mind to understand. While we in
some ways feel very close to the second century of the Roman
Empire, although it is so far distant fiom us in time, our own
country 300 years ago often appears to be sited in a past which
is incomprehensible. In Scotland more than in England, Puri¬
tanism was a harsh, intolerant creed. The appeals of Cromwell
for toleration fell on unresponsive ears. The arguments of Milton
in theAreopagitica were unheeded. But if toleration was a virtue
little valued in England, the position was far worse in Scotland.
As Andrew Lang remarked, the Scots had never been docde
children of Rome, none of the colour or gaiety of CathoHcism
had entered into their Hves. With the outburst of the Refor¬
mation. tlie Catholic system was swept away, and the naine o
Papist became synonymous ^vith everything bad and decadent.
Appeal was made to the word of God. the Bible, from the cor-
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
115
rupt Romish church. Unfortunately now that the authority of the
Church had been put aside, there was the new difficulty of inter¬
preting the Bible. Guides were needed, and in Calvin, the great
French reformer, and in his disciple, John Knox and others, the
guides were found. A very rigorous code was drawn up, and
strange to say, this church of Scotland, which was a mere new¬
comer among churches, arrogated to itself the claims made in
the Bible for God Himself, and His chosen instruments. In fact
the new church, which was described as the very tabernacle of
the Most High, soon laid upon its members tasks grievous to be
borne, and which were not undertaken in the Roman Church.
For 200 years the Presbyterian Church of Scotland was to rule
the State with a rod of iron, with the result that in due course,
when education became widespread and knowledge had in¬
creased, the Scots, except for a small minority', cast off the Kirk.
The Scottish reformers, faced with the difficulty of devising a
standard by which rehgion was to be ruled and the individual
speculator restrained, fell upon Calvin’s Institutes and adopted
them as the norm for their new church. There was none of the
stubborn conservatism of the English which caused them to
adhere to the bishops, the sacramental system, and simple cere¬
monies which made a Catholic revival a certainty one day.
Among the ministers and elders of the Kirk, the harshest feeUngs
prevailed. They wished to use force for their o\vn ends. They
could not find much excuse for it in the New Testament, so they
turned to the Old Testament, where the actions of Joshua, Elijah,
and David made excellent precedents. The root and branch
theory was advanced; an unbeliever, which meant anyone who
was not a devout Presbyterian was to be destroyed, his home,
family and kinsfolk to be wiped out, as per the Book of Judges,
and his possessions divided among the godly.
This ghastly travesty of Christ’s teachings went hand in hand
with the horrible ideas of Calvin, according to which God from
eternity forewilled, as well as foresaw, the eternal damnation
of the bulk of His creatures. It can hardly be wondered at that
the religion of Scotland under the influence of such teaching
became gloomy in the extreme. This influence has persisted so
116
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
that even now when the bulk of the Scots, like their English
neighbours, have tacitly abandoned the practice of religion, a
heavy gloom lies over Scotland, particularly on the first day of
the week which has been misnamed the Sabbath. This is the
legacy of the grim ministers who planted on the ruins of the
Catholic Church their ovim Church; but gloom and doumess were
not the only legacies to Scotland from the 17th century. For a
long time a most cruel and wicked form of persecution existed
in the very shadow of the Kirk; indeed it was ordained by it.
The men who had ever the name of Christ on their lips and who
were daring to refer to their own man-made institution as His
Church, forgot all about the Gospel once they had their enemies
in their grip. When Montrose in his early days as a soldier of
the Covenant had marched into Aberdeen he gave his word that
there should be no looting, that everything should be paid for
that was taken and that he would put some of the leading
citizens under his own protection. The first part of his promise
had no meaning because the troops of General Leslie, a soldier
who had been trained in Germany, were allowed to plunder as
they pleased. The Covenanting army was accompanied by a
large body of ministers. These not only said nothing about the
looting but actually blamed Montrose for saving the Aber¬
donians. According to these lights of the Church, the people of
Aberdeen were no better than those of Jericho and should have
been treated in the same way as Joshua had behaved to that
unfortunate city. When the Marquess of Huntly parleyed with
Montrose, the latter pledged his word that no harm should be¬
fall Huntly if he came to Aberdeen. Montrose had the shame of
finding out that a word of honour meant nothing to a minister of
the Gospel; the Presbyterian attitude was exactly the same as
that of the Crusaders towards the Moslems, the word given to an
infidel was of no account and need not be kept. Huntly and his
eldest son were taken prisoners to Edinburgh.
Montrose had been bred a staunch Presbyterian md he ad-
hered to the religion to the end of his life, but he had had a
shock. He had not understood the lengths to wWch hjs feUow
religionists would go, and he had not realized that in resisting
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
117
the authority of King Charles, the Covenanters, whetlier they
avowed their intention or not, were bent upon setting up a new
kind of rule in Scotland. The majority of the people were too
poor to take any active part in poUtics. There were two active
classes, the nobility, wliich in Scotland as always includes people
without titles as well as those who have them, and the middle
class, as we may describe the merchants, clergy and the la\vyers.
The natural leaders of the people, the aristocracy, were in a most
despicable condition; this was nothing unusual in Scottish
history as there have hardly ever in any land been nobles who
have exhibited more frequently the traits of meanness, treachery,
and sordid greed combined \vith ferocity worthy of savages. If
this judgment should seem prejudiced I will set beside it that of
one of the greatest modem Scottish writers. John Buchan, after-
v/ards Lord Tweedsmuir, in his Montrose writes: ‘To one who
studies such portraits as e.xist of the chief figures in tlie Scot¬
land of that epoch, there must come a sense of disappointment.
Few convey the impression of power which is found among the
Puritans and Cavaliers of England. There is Hamilton, self-
conscious, arrogant, and puzzled; Lanark, his brother, dark, sul¬
len and stupid; Huntly, a peacock head surmounting a splendid
body; Rothes, heavy-chinned, goggled-eyed, Pickwickian; Glen-
caira, weak and rustical; old Leven, the eternal bourgeois; the
Border earls, but one removed from the Border prickers; Waris-
ton, obstinate and crack-brained; James Guthrie, lean and fana¬
tical.'
i
It would be easy to extend Buchan’s list, and one of the most
unpleasant nobles of the day would certainly figure in it. This
was the Earl of Traquair, a man who had a good deal to do with
the ruin of Montrose and from whom nobody would want to
claim descent unless they had to. Against such persons the
nobility of Montrose’s character stands out in greater relief. Op¬
posite to him as Buchan notes there are only two other charac¬
ters in Scotland of that period, his great opponent, the Marquess
of Argyll, andAlexander Henderson. Argyll was at first the master
of the game. He had everything in his favour. He was older than
Montrose and much more experienced. He allied himself with
118
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
the dominant majority, and for a long time, by guile, force,
brutality and superstition succeeded in thwarting Montrose’s
aims. Montrose came slowly to maturity, and at 33 was ripe to
take high command. Charles I with his usual lack of understan¬
ding, had snubbed Montrose and it was only when the King’s
fortunes were in ruins in England that he consented to appoint
Montrose as his Lieutenant in Scotland. So poorly was the King
placed that he was unable to supply Montrose even with a troop
of horse with which he could be escorted into Scotland. In the
end Montrose began his daring career by travelling North
disguished as a groom. This is the incident which begins Sir
Walter Scott’s novel A Legend of Montrose. On the way to
Stirling a stranger passed the three men and said to the groom
‘Good day my Lord’. The stranger persisted in addressing the
seeming servant as Lord Montrose, but he did not give away the
secret to others and in a few days Montrose had reached the
Highland Line. He was waiting there for a time for the Mac¬
donalds to come over from Ireland. Before he could join them
however, they were met by the Stewarts and the Robertsons on
the Braes of Atholl. The Stewarts and the Robertsons cared
nothing for politics; they were interested only in saving their
land from the Irish Macdonalds. A clan battle would have taken
place but for the arrival of Montrose and one of his kinsmen.
Black Pate of Inchbrakie. This was in 1644 and with Montrose’s
arrival the first of many miracles began. The hostile clans who
had been facing each other across a river united behind the
King’s General. Montrose with all the romanticism of his cha¬
racter had brought with him not only the Kings Commission but
the Royal Standard. This he had carried in the lining of his
saddle, and it was a moment of pride, exaltation and self-know¬
ledge when in the Highland fastness the Royal Standard flut¬
tered free in the breeze and 2,500 men raised a ^eat shout for
the King, while the pipes skirled forth their stirring notes.
The odds against Montrose were enough to daunt the sta-ongest
heart. Montrose’s army had no artUlery, and few, if any, firearms.
Dirks and claymores were the weapons of his men, who were also
untrained. With the exception of some baggage pomes, the only
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
119
horses were those of Montrose and his two friends. He could
manoeuvre among the mountains no doubt, but if he did this
and his men were imable to collect the booty which all High¬
landers wanted in war, then his host would disappear, melting
away like the snows in the passes with the approach of spring.
If he ventured down on to the plains the well trained army of the
Covenant would be waiting for him, with modem waepons, and
with the powerful arm of cavalry. Yet if Montrose merely skulked
among the mountains he would never be able to fulfill the King s
commands and make Scotland a royal province. It was precisely
the descent into the plains tliat Montrose chose. He marched
down into the Lowlands but only in order to be able to dart
back into the Highland shelter if too great a force were brought
against him. At Tippermuir he won the first of his victories,
where he knocked out a force twice the size of his own. This led
to the capture of Perth; Aberdeen fell next after another battle in
which like that at Tippermuir the Lowland troops had been
swept away by the suddenness of the Highland charge. Until
now it had been the fashion of the Lowland lords and gentry
to despise the Highlanders and to affect to look upon them as
only fit for plundering and hit and mn raids. But Montrose,
though no Highlander, had realized the value of his men’s spirit
and was able to turn it to advantage.
After he learned that Argyll with an army of 4000 well trained
troops was after him, Montrose had decided upon his policy.
He retreated to Blair Atholl, his base, in early November and
after a rest there and a conference with the Macdonalds of
Glengarry and of Clanranald, Montrose decided upon a daring
plan. It was the proud boast of the Campbells — to this day the
most hated of all Highland clans — that it was a far cry to Loch
Awe, their principal seat. But security has been the bane of
many a strong country. Montrose with the Macdonalds went
through the Grampian passes in mid winter and forced his way
down into the Campbell country where he surprised the Camp¬
bells, Argyll himself being at dinner in his castle of Inverary.
got away in time, but the Campbell clan suffered very
heavy losses in property. So great was the impression made by
120
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
this daring attack that General BaiUie, a soldier of distinction,
was sent against Montrose, while Argyll sent to Ireland for fresh
troops. Bodies of the enemy began to converge upon Montrose’s
army. Down the Great Glen, beside what is now the Caledonian
Canal, came Baillie, while up it came the army led by Argyll.
Other forces were also waiting to cut off Montrose, whom they
expected to catch in a trap in the middle of the Glen. Instead
when the armies met there was no trace of Montrose. He had
vanished into the snows, and the blizzards had covered his
tracks. He had found some very difficult passes over the moun¬
tains and was doubling back along his way, so that he could
attack Argyll without the latter being able to effect a junction
vrith Leslie. The march through these mountains in the middle
of winter, in January-February was frightful; the army had no
fires, no place to rest in, and hardly any food; the only sus¬
tenance was oatmeal, mixed with snow, and the occasional deer
which they were able to catch and which was eaten raw and its
blood drunk by those who were lucky enough to find it. Through
it all Montrose went by the side of his men making no attempt
to enjoy better conditions than they. 'The hardships of that march
can be best understood by those who have followed the course
of it in the warmth of summer and with all the modern aids to
travelling; they can appreciate what it must have been like in
the days when the snow lay in drifts upon the ground, when
bitter winds howled across the hills, and when the only thing to
do was to keep going or else to die. Most of the Lowland gentle¬
men had gone home, to rejoin Montrose when the spring came;
only a few had stuck with him, and among these was his eldest
son, a boy of 15 whom Montrose felt to be safer in the rigours of
a Highland winter than at home at the mercies of the Covenan¬
ters. As it happened the boy died from the hardships which he
underwent, and the Dukes of Montrose descend from his youn¬
ger brother.
At last the ordeal ended and Montrose’s outposts came in con¬
tact with the hated Campbells, but the latter thought that ^y
were dealing with only a small party of the Macdonalds. The
Campbells had not placed any pickets or patrols in the tangle of
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
121
mountains around Ben Nevis, and they had no suspicion that
Montrose’s main army was anywhere near them. On the evening
of 1st February the t\vo forces faced each other but Argyll still
thought that the force that faced him near Inverlochy was only a
body of raiders under one of the Macdonald chiefs. The Campbell
watchfires burned brightly in the night and they could be seen
getting their supper ready while Montrose’s men tightened their
belts and contained their hunger as best they could. In the early
hours of Candlemas day the 2nd February the scanty breakfast
of oatmeal watered with melted snow was eaten; Montrose’s
army made ready to come down from the mountain. Then came
a typical gesture on Montrose’s part. AU through the wilderness
he had brought with him the Royal Standard and his trumpets.
The Standard was now unfurled and from the mountain heights
the trumpets sounded a fanfare which was only used when the
King or his Lieutenant was in presence. Argyll must have had
one of the surprises of his life when at last he realized that by
some wizardry Montrose had managed to get into position to
attack him before the juncture with the troops coming from
Inverness. There was little time to prepare for the Highland
onslaught which followed immediately after the trumpets had
sounded. The Macdonalds came down the mountain like the
proverbial winter torrent. The wings of Argyll’s army which
were composed of Lowland troops were swept away in a matter
of minutes. The Lowlanders in fact made little resistance for
they were terror stricken by the prospect of a Highland charge.
This left the centre which was composed of the Campbells un¬
supported and down against it came Montrose himself leading
the rest of the Macdonalds. Here Highlanders were opposed to
Highlanders and there was no swift victory. The Campbells
fought with all the courage of their race and it was only after a
prolonged struggle that they broke and fled. Before the action
had begun, their chief had already gone down Loch Eil in the
famous galley so familiar as the lymphad of the Campbell coat
of arms. Various reasons are given for Argyll’s flight, but cowar¬
dice was not the real one. ('Of his line of a hundred sires, I know
not one who would have retired while the banner of Diarmid
122
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
waved in the wind in the face of its most inveterate foes.'_Sir
Walter Scott in A Legend of Montrose). Whatever the motive,
however, the defection of Argyll dispirited his men and when
they eventually broke there was a terrible slaughter as they fled
along the loch side. More than 1,500 of the Campbells were
killed and their clan never regained its strength as a fighting
unit. That night in Inverlochy castle Montrose and his men
enjoyed warmth, food and some comfort. Montrose wrote his
despatch to King Charles ‘I am in the fairest hopes of reducing
this kingdom to your Majesty’s obedience. And if the measures I
have concocted with your other loyal subjects fail me not, which
they hardly can, I doubt not before the end of this summer I
shall be able to come to your Majesty's assistance with a brave
army, which, backed with the justice of your Majesty’s cause, will
make the rebels in England, as well as in Scotland, feel the just
rewards of rebellion. Only give me leave, after I have reduced
this country to your Majesty’s obedience, and conquered from
Dan to Beersheba, to say to your Majesty then, as David’s general
said to his master, “Come thou thyself lest this country be called
by my name.” ’
Montrose was in high hope. After Inverlochy he went on to
win a fresh series of victories and to conduct an astonishing
retreat from Dundee when with his force composed largely of
infantry he eluded the Covenanters' cavalry. At last the Cove¬
nanting army imder General Baillie met Montrose’s men at Kil¬
syth. 6,000 trained troops were again swept away by the High¬
landers and a small body of Lowland cavalry. This was the
decisive battle and was fought in August 1655 only seven months
after Inverlochy. For eleven months Montrose with his tiny army
had gone from victory to victory and at the end he was in very
truth Lieutenant Governor and Captain General for His Majesty
in the Kingdom of Scotland. For a short while all Scotland lay
at his feet, and he showed himself to the best of his chivalrous
nature in pardoning enemies who had fought against the King
and who had been responsible for proclaiming him (Montrose)
excommunicated from the Kirk and deprived of all his honours
and dignities. To King Charles the success of Montrose’s cam-
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
123
paigns seemed to augur a better prospect than he had loiown
for years. But Montrose required time to raise and train an
army which would hold Scotland while he marched south to
save the King. Time was the very thing which Montrose could
not command. While he was busy upon the borders, General
LesUe had marched into Scotland and with the aid of the treach¬
erous Earl of Traquair who sent his son Lord Linton with false
messages to Montrose, Leslie was able to overwhelm Montrose's
small force at Philiphaugh. This was in September 1645. The
marvellous career was over. He was not to achieve any more
victories and no more miracles were vouchsafed to support the
rapidly sinking fortunes of Charles 1. The course of events which
led the Scots to sell their king for £200.000 to the English Par¬
liament had begun; for Charles it was the road which led to tlie
royal tragedy 'hard by his own Whitehall’. To Charles himself
the world must have seemed upside down as he mounted the
staircase of his former palace and saw above him the decorations
painted by Van Dyke; yet Charles was fortunate in the manner
of his end. He died with a dignity of which his enemies could
not deprive him and in the universal groan which echoed around
Whitehall as his head fell, could be heard the prognostication of
returning monarchy. For Charles’ servants there was not the
same good fortune. Montrose endured four years of exile, and
then gave heart and fealty to Charles II. Charles was as false in
his dealings with Montrose as ever his father had been with the
devoted Strafford. While he commissioned Montrose to proceed
to Scotland and to conquer it for him he was treating with the
Covenanters for their support to become King of Scotland. One
of their terms was of coiuse that he should disown Montrose.
Montrose was in no delusion about all this but his selfless loyalty
led him to go to what he must have known would in all pro¬
bability be certain death. He sailed from Norway in March 1650
with a small following of foreign soldiers. In the Orkneys he
recruited some local troops and took them across to the main¬
land. Complete disaster came upon Montrose and his whole army
was cut to pieces by General Leslie. It was a strange fatality
which preserved Montrose at Philiphaugh and in his last cam-
124
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
paign from dying in battle. He was always venturing his life with¬
out regard for safety, yet he was not lolled. How much happier
it would have been for him if this could have happened. At the
close of the disastrous battle Montrose with two friends was
alone in the north west of Scotland. He tried to find his way to
the coast but he wandered far out of his way in the pathless
wilds. At last he came to the home of a small laird, Ardvreck
Castle where McLeod of Assynt eked out a poverty-stricken
existence. Even poorer were the crofters who sheltered Bonnie
Prince Charlie. They were not tempted by the prospect of un¬
limited wealth, which £30,000 would have meant to them.
McLeod of Assynt lives in Scottish history with Sir John Men-
teith as the most loathsome type of traitor—the man who having
received a guest and given him hospitality then betrays him to
his enemies. As Menteith betrayed Sir William Wallace for the
sake of English favour, so Assynt gave up the unsuspecting
Montrose to a dreadful death — for £5,000 worth of oatmeal,
two-thirds of which was sour. Montrose was led back to Edin¬
burgh, subjected on the way to all manner of indignity. His feet
were tied beneath his horse’s belly, and his hands behind his
back, while all the time he suffered with fever. It was hoped
when he reached the gates of Edinburgh and was led within,
that the mob would stone him, and that as his arms were bound
behind him, he would have no protection. So it would have
seemed likely, but at the entrance to the City gates there oc¬
curred the first of those demonstrations which go some way to
redeem human nature. Montrose arrived and so did the officers
of the Covenant with the sentence which was already decided.
He was to be hanged, this purposely was to be the manner of his
death in order to disgrace one who was a great gentleman and a
soldier; his body was to be hanging on the gibbet for 3 hours,
then it was to be cut down and his head placed upon the Tol-
booth and his limbs having been cut from the body were to be
distributed among Stirling, Glasgow, Perth and Aberdeen. If
James Graham — for the Covenanters refused to reco^ise lus
titles of nobility — were to repent, the ministers would \wth-
draw the sentence of excommunication, and graciously aUow
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
125
his body to be buried in the churchyard of Greyfriars. Otherwise
it would be cast into a pit on the Boroughmuir where the
carcasses of felons were thrown.
This was the sentence and when it had been read out the
prisoner was led within the walls. The anticipated outburst of
the people did not take place; instead there was an almost com¬
plete silence. The dignity of the Great Marquess made itself felt.
Along the Canongate he passed — the journey taking nearly
three hours—and the only murmurs were from those who pitied
or admired. One woman was so low as to break the silence with
a brutal laugh — Lady Jean Gordon. One man spoke out — an
English soldier who remarked when Argyll was seen peering
from behind a lattice. 'They durst not look him in the face these
seven years.' It must have been a curous moment when Argyll
saw the man against whom he had striven but whom he had
never been able to beat in the field.
Montrose was lodged in the Tolbooth to await his death. Ap¬
parently the only reason was to give him time to repent. Of what,
it may well be asked. The dark Geneva ministers, as William
Aytoun calls them, hung aroimd ‘James Graham’ to bring him to
acknowledge his faults, but he refused to retract even though
they told him plaiidy that he, a devout Presbyterian all his life,
should die without the Holy Communion. To the last, Montrose
remained calm and serene in the presence of these hideous
sectaries, with their canting talk of Christ’s grace. Some of
Montrose’s friends had managed to get some fine clothes to him,
knowing that he loved to be brave in his apparel. His suit was
of fine black cloth, he had a richly laced scarlet cloak, a black
beaver hat with a silver band, and his stockings were of car¬
nation silk. There were ribbons on his shoes and white gloves on
his hands. All this bravery he wore to his death, but the petty
spite of his persecutors prevented him from having the attentions
of a barber. On the scaffold he preserved the same grand air of
tranquil courage. The ministers were unable to get between his
soul and God. He stepped to the edge of the scaffold and as the
hangman turned him off, an English agent who was writing a
description of the scene, noted: ‘He is just now a turning off
126
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
from the ladder but his countenance changes not’ The night
before his death he had, like Sir Walter Kaleigh whose history he
so much admired, written some verses:
‘Let them bestow on every airth a limb.
Then open all my veins, that I may s^vim
To Thee, my Maker, in that crimson lake;
Then place my parboiled head upon a stake,
Scatter my ashes, strew them in the air —
Lord! Since Thou knowest where all these atoms are.
I’m hopeful ThouU recover once my dust
And confident Thou’ll raise me with the just.’
When Charles II made his entry into Edinburgh as the poor
minion of the rebellious Covenanters, what must have been his
feelings as he saw exposed to view the whitening skull of the
man who had been his Lieutenant and who had been to him, as
to his father, the truest knight and faithfullest friend? Yet
Charles did not wholly forget. When the Restoration came, the
remains of Montrose were collected with all reverence and
buried in St. Giles, where a noble monument stands above them
with a splendid window containing the arms of Montrose, those
of his friends and of the branches of his family. Argyll was tried
for his crimes and in due course executed. Assynt had his castle
burned and spent much time in prison. The fate of the humbler
Covenanters is well known.
In his Old Mortality, Sir Walter Scott has given a harrowing
and unforgettable picture of the torture of the boot to which
one of the Covenanters was exposed. Unfortunately the detaUs
given there were not fictitious, and only too many of toe sec¬
taries perished for their refusal to conform, often by horrible
forms of death. Under persecution, as so frequently happens the
better side of the Presbyterian character came out. and many o
the hedge preachers and their congregations showed a spirit
worthy of the early Christian martyrs. Traham
In the following up to prison and to death. ^ j
was the terror of the Covenanters. This was John Graham ot
Claverhouse, Viscount Dundee. Over his fame many shadows
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
127
have fallen, due in all probability to the work of his enemies,
but there can be no doubt of his high souled courage and de¬
votion to duty. John Graliam was only two years old when his
illustrious kinsman tlie Great Marquess was put to death, so
that he did not of course have any knowledge of the matter at
that time. In the years that followed, however, he learned about
the gallant Graeme, and came to long to emulate him in his
life and devotion to the Stuarts. One of tlie most remarkable
features in the whole story of the Stuart family is the manner
in which able persons of the most honourable and distinguished
t>’pe were prepared to sacrifice themselves for them to the utter¬
most, although experience would have shoNvn that to serve a
Stuart was to serve a faithless and ungrateful creature who was
likely to intrigue with the very enemies who were harassing his
most devoted friends.
In John Graham of Claverhouse the Stuart Kings, Chiirles II
and James II, had a servant who was ready to adventure him¬
self to death on their behalf. Claverhouse, the name by which he
is usually known until he received tlie peerage of Dundee, won
his spurs in the later part of Charles Il’s reign when he fought
in the engagements of Drumclog and Bothwell Bridge. These
battles arose from the persecution of tlie Covenanters upon
which the government of Charles II was engaged. As there were
no police, and the local authorities had not the will even sup¬
posing they had the power to carry out the government’s orders,
the troops had to be used. Claverhouse like all his family was
of a martial spirit and joined the army as a regular soldier, being
in the Life Guards. His task was to go about the country to seek
out Covenanters and to administer to them the test of confor¬
mity. Claverhouse is described as one of the quickest executio¬
ners of the government’s orders. 'Will you abjure the Covenant?’
he is supposed to have said. ‘No? soldiers shoot!’ Fortunately we
have an account of his doings written in the ordinary course of
his duty. At the end of Charles Il’s reign it was his duty to seek
out a sectary named John Brown of Priesthill. Claverhouse was
a professional soldier who was only concerned to obey orders.
Brown had been an agent of the Covenanters against the govern-
128
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
ment and when Claverhouse eventually came up with him, in
company with another Covenanter, he was asked if he would
abjure the Covenant. ‘John Brown refused it, nor would he not
swear not to rise in arms against the King, but said he knew no
King; upon which and there being found bullets and match in
his house and treasonable papers, I caused shoot him dead,
which he suffered very unconcernedly.' This is the account
given by Claverhouse, who then goes on to say that John
Brown’s companion was spared because he had given infor¬
mation. Claverhouse appears to be no worse than many a British
officer who has been in the field against terrorists in India or
Ireland, Palestine or Africa.
After some foreign service Claverhouse’s military life was
taken up with this police work, and the battles of Drumclog and
Bothwell Bridge were the only interruptions of a truly soldierly
nature in all the years of his police work in Scotland. At Drum-
clog the Covenanters had come together in a body to worship
in the fields, because they were not allowed to meet in a building
recognised by the law. Claverhouse then attacked them and was
beaten back in a rout because of the superior numbers of the
Covenanters and the difficulty of the ground. A few months
later the defeat was avenged when the royal troops beat the
rebels at Bothwell Bridge and large numbers of the latter were
slain. On all occasions Claverhouse performed prodigies of
valour.
One of the most determined sectaries was Balfour of Burley.
He had taken the lead in the murder of Archbishop Sharpe on
the Fifeshire moors and as a leading terrorist had a considerable
price upon his head. Claverhouse pursued him but without
success.
It was at the very end of his brief life — Claverhouse was only
41 when he was killed •— that the sun of glory shone full upon
him. That incredibly stupid and short sighted monarch James II
had got himself turned off the throne of England. He was not
much more popular in Scotland but he had the advantage ere
of the support which Claverhouse was able to give him. Claver-
house must have thought of the desperate enterprise of his kins-
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
129
man, the Great Marquess, who had gone to Scotland to raise it
for King Charles I with only a handful of men. So with Claver-
house. After William and Mary had been proclaimed King and
Queen of Scotland at Edinburgh, Claverhouse had no resource
but to take to the hills. Here he formed a small army, untrained
and undisciplined but of first-class fighting material. He soon
had with him the Camerons, under Lochiel, the Stewarts of
Appin, several branches of the Macdonalds, the Macleans and
the Macleods. This force numbered not more than 2000 men and
in addition, like Montrose before him, he had a body of Irish
troops. With this tiny force he undertook the restoration of the
Stuart King to the throne of his ancestors in Scotland. He had
against him General Hugh Mackay, who had been a soldier of
experience in the Low Countries, and who had a regular army
with him equipped witli proper weapons, whereas Claverhouse’s
men had only what they could bring with them from their glens.
There followed during some months of 1689 the usual manoeu¬
vres of Scottish warfare but at last at the end of July General
Mackay with his army of 4000 marched in to the pass of Killie-
crankie, where with the river Garry at his back he faced tlie
army of Claverhouse on the heights. Mackay had twice the num¬
ber of Claverhouse's army, but the position into which he had
allowed himself to be inveigled was enough to neutralize any
superiority in numbers and discipline. Anyone who passes
through Killiecranlde must notice the impossible position in
which an army placed as Mackay s was, would be in the event of
a Highland charge. In fact it is hard to understand how any
commander would have allowed himself to be manoeuvred into
such a position. Mackay was unable to retreat for fear of an
attack in his rear. He stood his ground hoping that an oppor¬
tunity would come to outflank or overthrow his adversary. Mean¬
while in the heights above, the Highland army waited, until the
sun had set on the opposite hills and was no longer in
the eyes of the Highlanders. Then Claverhouse gave the order
to charge. This was carried out in the traditional manner and
the Lowland troops once more had the opportunity to meet the
Highland tactics. The Highlanders came down the hills like an
130
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
avalanche and some of Mackay’s troops gave way without a shot
being fired. The whole line of 4000 men was strung out no thick¬
er than three deep. There was no room for depth which might
have contained the Highland charge. None the less there was a
steady fire from some parts of Mackay’s line, and many of the
clansmen fell. When the Highlanders came up with the line, the
latter was carried away; when Mackay tried to rally his men
and to redeem the day with his cavalry, the small body of
Claverhouse's cavalry struck fiercely against them and turned
their charge into a rout. Many of Mackay’s troops were drowned
in the Garry and only a small remnant were able to retreat in
any semblance of order. The brief action occupied less than an
hour and this towards sunset, so that the light which was left
gave small chance to Mackay to know what had happened. The
claymore had worked havoc in his disciplined ranks and he
must have felt a deep disgust at his veterans being beaten by
what he regarded as savages. It was to be many years before a
British general was to master the Highland charge, and even
then, at Culloden, the ground was much more favourable to the
regulars than at KiUiecrankie. When once the secret had been
mastered it was to prove invaluable in the British Army’s growing
record of combats with savages who relied more upon fierce
sudden rushes than upon sustained effort.
All this was in the future and Mackay could have no satis-
faction or consolation as he marched the shattered army or what
was left of it out of the pass. He could not know that one of his
soldiers had succeeded in one shot in bringing more advantage
to the arms of King WiUiam III than the whole of the govern¬
ment armed forces which were then in Scotland. At Ae heigh
of Ae brief engagement when his cavalry seemed to be missmg
Ae mark, Dundee led Ae last reserve of cavahers --
16 m all — towards Ae enemy. He stood m his shnups
courage his men and the last charge was decisive “
Remains of Ae government army to bopeless rout A^uUe^A^n
pierced Dundee below his armour, and e e According
Ld. The accounts of his deaA are strangely ^
to one Aeory he was shot Arough Ae eye into Ae bram, m
THE HOUSE OF GRAHAM
131
which case death would have been instantaneous, whereas ac¬
cording to other accounts some life was left in him when his
men found him lying on the ground. There was even a calumny
that one of his followers who was a spy in the government s pay
had finished him off. In fact there is no need for much mystery
about Dundee’s end. The battle had every circumstance of con¬
fusion, the smoke from the discharge of the guns and cannon, the
failing light, the wild terrain, the demoralization of the govern¬
ment troops, and the dispersal of the Highlanders after their
victory. At such a time and place the fall of a single horseman
even though he was the general would pass almost unnoticed
for some little while. Some of the cavalry of Dundee suddenly
became aware of his absence and anxiously returned to find
him. The result was that they discovered his body lying as it had
fallen, having received probably more than one wound. He
seems to have lingered for some hours. With him expired the
cause of King James in Scotland. When William of Orange heard
of the result of the battle he exclaimed that there was no need
to send more troops; Dundee being dead, all was over. Mackay
managed to reach Stirling with only about 800 men, the rest
except for 500 prisoners having been slain by the clansmen or
otherwise killed in the rout; of the army of Dundee about 900
fell, mainly by the fierce fire of the regulars to which they were
e.xposed in their charge. All the equipment and baggage fell into
the Highlanders’ hands. But the victory proved useless for with
Dundee’s death all further effort to restore James in Scotland
came to an end.
Dundee was fortunate to die in battle and in the knowledge
of victory. He who had emulated Montrose, had surpassed him,
(thus he thought) for not even Montrose had been able to gain
a kingdom in a single battle of an hour’s duration. Then in the
arms of victory, Dundee fell, whereas the Great Marquess was
to know all the bitterness of defeat and the misery of a despi¬
cable death among hateful foes. It is not necessary to contrast or
attempt to estimate the relative importance of Dundee and Mont¬
rose. Each gave his selfless all, but it is undeniable that Montrose
had the harder burden. He had to endure to see all his work
132
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
undone, and to be able to have the assurance of faith alone that
right would be done.
Montrose had some years before his death written some verses
which, ostensibly addressed to his wife, are in reality an ode to
his country. The whole poem is beautiful, with its opening ‘My
dear and only Love’ but four lines are grandly prophetic:
‘He either fears his fate too much.
Or his deserts are small.
That dares not put it to the touch,
To gain or lose it all’.
To gain or lose it all — did Montrose think on the last night of
his life of his own lines? As the black Geneva ministers crowded
round, eager to cut off their victim from a loving God, as the
vast crowd was silent to watch him turned off the ladder to be
hanged, did the high-souled Marquess recall his great boast? He
had fulfilled it and we can believe that in that awful moment he
saw the fulfilment of his faith, for which he had fought, and
which far transcended the mere matter of kingship or presbytery,
but which touched the very freedom of man’s soul. Similarly with
Dundee he died as he would have wished in the heart of the
battle for what he believed to be right; in his ears as he died
there sounded the shout of triumph of the clans and the des¬
pairing yells of the drowning fugitives who had once been an
army.
With such a heritage of greatness in the name of Graham,
it would seem natural for any bearer of the name to be intensely
proud of it, and above all the head of the great race of Graham
himself, the 7th Duke of Montrose. But apparently it is not so. 'I
don’t mention my title' said the Duke on inheriting it, according
to a report in the Sunday Express for 24 January 1954, wMch
has gone uncontradicted. He is a farmer in Rhodesia, and to
quote the same source, he said, ‘I went out to Rhodesia 23 years
ago without any money, and for a long time I told no one I
was the Marquess of Graham (this was before the death of his
father, the 6th Duke in January 1954). When people found out I
just shrugged it off: The italics are the present writers. Agreed
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
133
that the value of the Montrose estates has fallen very conside¬
rably in recent years due to the incidence of death duties, but
even so an estimate has been made that the present value is
between £.50,000 and £.100,000. It would have been interesting
to know what the Great Marquess or Claverhouse would have
thought of such a sum when they had to embark on their despe¬
rate enterprises. The Sunday Express did not pass any direct
comment on the attitude of the new Duke, save the worse com¬
ment of all, to quote the verse witten by the Great Marquess
and which is given above.
The author felt impelled to take the matter up and the next
issue of the Sunday Express contained the following letter under
tlie title, ‘Mr. Burke defends noblesse oblige’.
‘It seems to be the fashion now for those who inherit an
ancient title to try to forget about it.
‘There have been two or three instances of baronets who do
not wish to be kno\vn by their titles, and do not propose to take
up their father’s baronetcy. This makes all the more apposite the
verse you quoted from the great Marquess of Montrose, who
risked everything upon a desperate throw. He lost but only after
having very nearly won. And after his death, his cause trium¬
phed, because Charles II and the British monarchy was restored
to this country.
'If these people who are privileged to inherit an ancient title
were to go out into the world determined to uphold the great
name they have inherited they would not find the title a handi¬
cap.’
No amount of taxation or forced sales or other economic
troubles can ruin an aristocracy as long as it still has pride in
itself. When it becomes apologetic and starts to be ashamed of
its honours then it is time for it to go. In fact in such a state it
has already half gone. No measures for the abolition of the Upper
House will be needed if the attitude of 'shrugging off their
honours becomes general among the British aristocracy. They
will have decided that they are no longer worthy of respect.
Chapter eight
MARLBOROUGH
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
T O win or lose it all’. If ever the words of Montrose came
true it was in 1940 when in modem times a man of the
antique mould had to make the choice to win or lose, with a
nation’s destiny, almost a world’s, upon the result of his choice.
If it were ever possible to believe that a Providence really gui¬
des the affairs of men, and that a Divine Hand directs the
education of a chosen nation, then the time for that belief was
in the very crisis of our fate in 1940 when the full momentous
nature of our second struggle with Germany was revealed to us,
and our easy optimism over Norway had been shattered by one
blow after another. From the House of Commons there arose a
shout of rage. 'Go, in the Name of God gol' was the exhortation
of the House, through the mouth of Mr Amery to the Chamber-
lain Government. Despite the formal vote of confidence in the
House of Commons, Neville Chamberlain knew, none better,
that he had not the confidence of the nation. On the morning of
10th May, when the Germans had broken into Holland and Bel¬
gium, Winston Churchill and Lord Halifax were summoned to
10 Downing Street to see Chamberlain. He told them that he was
to resign and that he had to decide whom he should advise the
King to send for. ‘I have had many important interviews in my
public life, and this was certainly the most important. Usually I
talk a great deal, but on this occasion I was silent. Thus Church¬
ill in his account of the matter. Chamberlain talked for a while;
apparently he felt that Churchill might not be able to secure
*34
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
135
Labour support for the National Government which must now
be formed. ‘I do not recall the actual words he used, but this
was the implication. His biographer Mr. Feiling, states definitely
that he preferred Lord Halifax. As I remained silent, a very long
pause ensued. It certainly seemed longer than the two minutes
which one observes in the commemoration of Armistice Day.
Then at length Halifax spoke. He said that he felt liis position as
a Peer, out of the House of Commons, would make it very diffi¬
cult for him to discharge the duties of Prime Minister in a war
hke this.... He spoke for some minutes in this sense, and by the
time he had finished it was clear that the duty would fall upon
me. had in fact fallen upon me. Then for the first time I spoke*.
We are fortunate that this momentous interview has not been left
to be described by a journalist or author who was not in touch
wdth it, but by the principal subject who besides being a great
national leader is also a great artist in words. That silence while
Halifax decided that he could not undertake the terrible task of
Prime Minister owing to his constitutional inability to be present
in the Commons, must have been one of indescribable agony to
Churchill. To have held every high office except the Premiership,
to have been in the political wilderness for many years, then to
be summoned back to place and power when the nation was in
danger, and finally to be within touching distance of the highest
position, yet, perhaps not to be able to secure it, and to have to
give devoted allegiance to another chief — that was a torture
compared to which the physical brutalities which might fall
upon one from Germany were small. It was then that Providence
stepped in and put into the supreme place a man supremely
fitted to hold it. The pilot was at the helm, a pilot who delight¬
ed in storms. 'Thus then on the night of the 10th May, at the
outset of this mighty battle, I acquired the chief power in the
State.... During these last crowded days of the political crisis
my pulse had not quickened at any moment. I took it all as it
came. But I cannot conceal from the reader of this truthful
account that as I went to bed at about 3 a.m., I was conscious of
a profound sense of relief. At last I had the authority to give
directions over the whole scene. I felt as if I were walking with
136
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
destiny, and that all my past life had been but a preparation
for this hour and for this trial. Eleven years in the political
wilderness had freed me from ordinary Party antagonisms. My
warnings over the last six years had been so numerous, so de¬
tailed, and were now so terribly vindicated, that no one could
gainsay me. I could not be reproached either for making the war
or with want of preparation for it. I thought I knew a good deal
about it all, and I was sure I should not fail.*
I have quoted the above passages because they express in
simple words the facts about the appointment of Churchill as
wartime Prime Minister. At the present time, so great is the
popular veneration for Churchill that it is as hard for anyone
who writes an unbiassed appraisal to be heard as for a candid
account of the deficiencies of Aneurin Bevan to be published in a
Welsh newspaper. In fact, looking back over Churchill’s life
from the standpoint of 1940, we can see that nature or Providence
had guided and trained this wayward child of genius to fit him
to save Britain and the freedom of the world. Churchill had held
every position in Government long before 1940, in most cases
before the average politician was out of school. There was there¬
fore vast governmental experience to guide the new Premier
in his grim responsibilities. In addition he had been trained as a
professional soldier, and had fought in five wars, including the
first world war. He had been a pioneer of support for the air
force, several important years had been passed in naval affairs.
He had unrivalled knowledge of the democratic scheme of
government; he knew most of the great political leaders. His
American mother had contributed a natural leaning toward the
Americans which at some times in the war was to prove of im¬
mense value, and at other times to be a decided disadvantage, in
our dealings with Roosevelt. To come to what may seem smaller
qualifications, Churchill was a man of the utmost experience and
skill in the handling of the written and the spoken word.
Nevertheless, despite Churchill’s experience and self-confid¬
ence, the task to which he had been caUed, not by the outcry o
a people, but as some would say by accident, as the more serious
thinking would have put it, by Providence; the task was one
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
137
which if soberly contemplated, must have appeared of frightful
difficulty. In one of his first broadcasts to the nation, Churchill
declared that he had consulted the leaders of the three Services,
and that they had told him that they believed we had a reaso¬
nable chance of victory. This was after the fall of France and
such a declaration at tliat time must have seemed to many a
citizen, uninstructed in our resources, as either a piece of in¬
spired daredevilishness or as the product of some secret know¬
ledge. Whatever the e.xplanation, Churchill certainly succeeded
in rallying the nation from the lethargy into which 20 years of
pacificism. Socialism, blather about the League of Nations,
Conscientious Objection, and other poisonous matter had brought
it. How far Churchill himself believed in his own confidence no
one dare say; there is the story of his aside in the House of
Commons after his famous speech, ‘We will fight them on the
beaches, on the hills, in the fields, in the cities’. As he sat down
he is supposed to have said ‘What with? choppers, I suppose’.
At any rate whatever the cause, Britain stood firm behind her
Premier who had rallied her people to their King and their Flag.
It is not fanciful to imagine Churchill sitting in his room in
Downing Street alone, yet not alone; and that round him would
be gathered the master spirits of our history, Cromwell, Eliza¬
beth, Pitt, Wellington and Drake. Not one of them had faced so
terrible an experience, to be at the helm of an Empire fighting
for its life against murderous foes. I remember an article xvritten
during the war in which it was said and rightly that if Churcliill
should win through, he would leave a name in British history
which would lead all the rest. On the roll of British fame, the
name of Churchill must always be first because of the epic period
of 1940—45. If he had done nothing else of value or eminence in
his long life, his performance for that quinquennium would have
given him the right to be called the British leader far in advance
of all others. The deeds of 1940—45 are known to all and in the
present study I propose merely to analyse some of the features
of Churchill's work during that epoch and to see how they con¬
nect with his life before and since, and also how far we can find
any analogy in the past of his family to his own career. For
138
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Churchill can never be divorced from his ancestors. One of his
earliest greater tasks was the life of his ancestor (through the
female line), John Churchill, the first Duke of Marlborough.
Churchill must always be a cadet of the House of Marlborough,
even if he should eventually receive the Dukedom which is his
due. There never was a clearer case of a man being conscious of
his ancestry and more influenced by it.
First as to age. No doubt he is exceptional, but Churchill is an
instance in our day to remind us of great and famous men whose
achievements were not even begun when they were forty or even
fifty years of age. Narses, the valiant eunuch, won battles when
he was in his eighth decade. Theodore of Tarsus who was called
to be the seventh Archbishop of Canterbury in 668, was 66 when
he began his task, and he carried on the reorganisation of the
English Church and its extension until he was well into his
eighties. Lieutenant Governor Blakeney had been sixty years in
the Army when he put up a resolute defence of Minorca against
the French. To these examples Churchill has added another, for
in 1940 he was sixty-five years of age. Whatever a man s intel¬
lectual faculties, much depends upon his bodily staying power.
At 65 Churchill had to begin the most arduous five years of his
life; working far into the night, working with utmost concen¬
tration on matters of vital concern to his people. Would his
health hold out? It not only did so but enabled him not only to
survive the war but to remain in political life and to be Prime
Minister until he was past 80. So much then for the theory
which appeals to many people who have pensionable jobs that a
man has passed his zenith at 40. There is no reason to suppose
that Churchill’s physical ability is a miracle; with good health as
a foundation, plenty of good food, exercise, and an interest m
life, most men are capable of sustained work well past the age
of 60. Of course this pre-supposes as in Churchill’s case, an in¬
dependence of outlook; what will be the result after a generadon
of so of coddling under the Welfare State, it is hard to say, but
there is a trend, and a strong one, to assume that all experience
and usefulness end at 35, and that anyone who is over that age
should go on the dole. It would have been interesting to av
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
139
seen this trend applied to politicians for then in 1940 Churchill
would have been regarded as fit for burial. Instead not only did
he go on to win the war by the time he was 70 but he had also
stood by the coffins (metaphorically in some cases, actually in
others) of most of his great contemporaries, Roosevelt, Hitler,
Mussolini, Stalin, Cripps, Bevin.
Then there is in Churchill a welcome freedom from the corrosive
vice of hatred. This is a great age of hate. Not even in the period
of the Reformation when Protestants and Catholics burnt, hanged
and tortured each other for the love of Christ, has man behaved
to his fellow man with more horrible cruelty than in this so-
called Century of the Common Man. Most people have seen the
terrible pictures of what occured in a dozen European countries
when Germans, Russians and others had liquidated their op¬
ponents. Accompanying this cruelty there has gone a cynical in¬
difference towards the suffering which has been caused; the
word ‘liquidated’ itself is an example of the kind of new
language, used to disguise a horrible thing, which was so well
satirized in 1984 by George Orwell. There seems no doubt tliat
Hitler could have steered his country on the right path had he
wished, but the splenetic hatred of his diseased mind could find
no outlet save in torturing first, Jews and Communists, and then
in overflowing beyond the boundaries of Germany, into Euro¬
pean lands where he could find fresh subjects for his ferocious
hatreds. In lands behind the Iron Curtain it would seem
that man’s inhumanity to man has led to devilries unknown
since the Middle Ages, but bom of hatred. Hatred is a
disease which gradually proves most dangerous to the one who
cherishes it. From all this Churchill is wonderfully free. He may
bicker with his political adversaries but they know and everyone
else knows that he will be most generous and chivalrous when
the time comes — a wedding, an anniversary, or a presentation
— for one of the little courtesies of life to be employed. More
than this, even during the war when Churchill had to denounce
Hitler, he did not show hatred for him. What was expressed in
Churchill’s speeches was a contempt which it was not possible
140
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
to conceal. It has been said that English is the language in which
a man should speak to his foes, because of the hissing sibilants
which abound in our language. If this be so, Churchill’s vitupe¬
rations must rank among the highest of their kind. For instance,
everyone knows that Hitler in six years service in the German army
could not get himself above the rank of corporal and the award
of an Iron Cross which he probably filched from a dead comrade.
Churchill among his half dozen careers, has been through
Sandhurst, seen much service, and been the Colonel of a Guards
Battalion. It is a different type of career from that of a junior
N.C.O. When the corporal referred to the exploits of military
idiots and said that one never knew what they might do next
and where they might invade next in Europe, well, the profes¬
sional soldier was not unreasonably annoyed. In his next war
speech, in 1943, Churchill in great detail described the agonies
of the German retreat in Russia before the combined onslaught
of the Russians and the winter; he concluded with the remark
that the Germans had the advantage of knowing that their retreat
was being conducted under the directions not of the German
General Staff but of — Corporal Hitler. It seemed that the very
receiving set itself would break under the impact of that mighty
expression of sovereign contempt. Then in dealing with Musso¬
lini, Churchill had at his disposal a magnificent language of
sarcasm and withering contempt. The braggart dictator of Italy
who had assumed such strutting proportions when he had trium¬
phed over Greek schoolchildren at Corfu, half armed Albanians
on Good Friday, and blinded Abyssinians, was then seen in his
proper proportions, the poor shambling lackey of his German
master. The picture which Chiu-chill then called up, of a poor
little heavy-jowled Italian scampering along beside his chief and
looking up to Hitler for words of comfort or a scrap of cheer
was reflected in a thousand cartoons in tlie Allied newspapers,
and wiU never be effaced. For the pinchbeck, sawdust Caesar
there will never be a cult among civilized men, similar to at
which was given to Napoleon. No Hardy or Rosebery wi e
able to pass the boundaries which Churchills scorn has erect
around Mussolini.
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
141
In a consideration of Churchill’s oratory I know that it is con¬
sidered as a kind of sacrilege to attempt a rational criticism of
anything Churchillian. Churchill in his lifetime at least has be¬
come a sort of demi-god, a deified Caesar, as Douglas Reed
called him, and this is strange from men who in the years before
1940 were ready to exclude Churchill from all further partici¬
pation in political life. 'A spent force was their description of
him in 1929. Now it is considered as a kind of l^se majesty to
suggest that he can have imperfections. Undeterred by this how¬
ever, I say that Churchill’s oratory is of the type which will read
better than it sounds. There is no derrogation in this. In the days
of ancient Rome it is quite possible tliat orators such as Mark
Antony, or Julius Caesar may well have ranked above Cicero.
The Pro Milone or the Pro Lege Manilia which to us seem tlie
very height of eloquence may not have so struck tlie ordinary
Roman whether in the Senate or the Forum. Indeed the Pro
Milone never was delivered, although written and sent to the
subject of it — in Gaul where Milo had been exiled, a fate from
which the speech was to have rescued him. In the 18th century
the speeches of Sheridan were better thought of than those of
Edmund Burke which now seem so impressive. Similarly, with
Churchill’s speeches they are the eloquence of a great literary
man. Occasionally great men of action have possessed literary
powers, and Churchill is one. His collected works in their bulk
alone would entitle him to rank among the most prolific authors
and for their quality he can be classed with the great stylists of
our or any language. It is inevitable that this gift of phrase¬
making should be carried over into his orations, but they are set
pieces. They are not oratory in the ordinary sense. Oratory is the
ability, usually abused, to move people by words of burning
power, spoken under the pressure of emotion. It is very difficult
to rehearse and prepare an emotional outburst; true, an actor
learns his piece and when he comes to say it on the stage, his art
is to make it sound as though it were spoken in real life, but
this is precisely because he is an actor. The oratory of a man
like Hitler or Lloyd George is to the greatest extent spontaneous.
Our hostility towards Hitler and other dictators should not blind
142
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
us to the very real power of soul-stirring oratory which they pos¬
sess. I once remember having a talk with a monk in Malta who
was himself an accomplished preacher and who told me that he
heard both Hitler and Mussolini; before they spoke they ap¬
peared, and especially Hitler, to be little insignificant men, but
once they had begun speaking it was impossible not to feel the
vast power which they exerted. Such men do not write their
speeches. They probably have no very clear idea of what they
are to say before they speak. Similarly, in our own country, the
set orations of Lloyd George are not among his greatest. It was
when he spoke in the now almost forgotten controversy of 1910
that the full force of his moving power could be felt.
A Churchillian speech is quite another matter. Churchill has
told us his own method in preparing a speech. During the worst
time of the war he would often take a day’s absence from his
other duties in order to prepare an important speech for the
House of Commons, or for a broadcast. Preparation in this case
meant writing out the speech in full, and as he then speaks from
the script, it is very difficult for him to conceal the fact. All
successful politicians are to some extent actors and Churchill by
no means lacks histrionic ability, but even so I do not think that
the general run of his speeches are oratory in the sense in which
an inspired speech is said to be, remembering that inspiration
can come from below as well as from above. There were occa¬
sions of course in 1940 and 1941 when the very nature of the
time with its supreme danger brought forth Churchill s genius to
the full. It is not likely that anyone, either spontaneously or by
rehearsal, could surpass, even if they could equal, such utterances
of Churchill's as his famous call to the House of Commons on
10th May 1940 when he said that he had nothing to offer to
those who followed him but ‘blood, sweat, toU, and tears.' Or
when he said that our ordeal ‘would prove, even if the British
Commonwealth of nations should endure a thousand years, to
have been her finest hour*; or again the classic reference to the
work of the Royal Air Force in winning the Battle of
‘Never before in the field of human conflict, has so muc een
owed, by so many, to so few'.
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
143
No, the oratory of Churchill is to be judged with his writing.
There is no part of literature except poetry which he has not
touched, and after the revelation that at some period of his life
before the war he wrote a History of the English speaking Peo¬
ples, we do not know that he may not have an epic or two
hidden away at Chartwell. In all other branches of writing he
has distinguished himself. His solitary novel Savrola today com¬
mands a fantastic price among collectors and bibliophiles. The
River War, the Life of Lord Randolph Churchill, The World
Crisis, Marlborough, His Life and Times, Great Contemporaries,
My Early Life, The Second World War, and many other volumes
of speeches and of ephemeral political controversy, attest his
prolific genius, but by no means exhaust it. For Churchill has
been a very considerable journalist. It is not for nothing that he
was made a Fellow of the Institute of Journalists, for his output
in articles and other contributions to the press would have been
a very ample portion for any workaday member of the craft.
Indeed for nine days he was an editor, of tlie British Gazette,
produced during the General Strike of 1926! Some of his books
such as Great Contemporaries are purely journalism but as
sometimes happens they are journalism touched with genius.
Just as Hazlitt had to write his splendid essays with the printer’s
devil at his elbow and with the duns before the door, yet reached
the heights of literature in his occasional pieces so Churchill can
make all who write turn with greater vigour to their humble
tasks when they remember the purple passages and splendid
language which he has put into series of pot-boiling articles for
popular newspapers. It seems almost incredible but it is true
that not much more than 20 years ago The News of the World
announced that the Rt Hon. Winston Churchill P.C., M.P. etc.
would retell the story in a condensed form of some of the great
novels of English literature. Westward Hoi, David Copperfield,
The Mill on the Floss, etc. In the spirit of the lavish newspaper
publicity of the early 1930s, postcards were sent out to thousands
of householders which showed Churchill at his desk about to
write, and which invited the adressee to place an order with
144
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
his newsagent for The News of the World. Of course the writing
was of the highest quality, but looking back it does seem a little
remarkable that the greatest statesman of the*20th century should
have gone into the literary market with a series of articles just
as Godfrey Winn or Hector Bolitho might do. It is however an¬
other facet of Churchill’s extraordinary endowment.
Enough for a working journalist, and then enough output for
a man of letters. The half dozen titles of Churchill’s books which
I have quoted above represent 20 volumes, and I have not given
a complete list. 35 volumes are listed in Who’s Who under
Churchill’s name. The amount of work which is represented by
these books is phenomenal. The World Crisis which is in four
volumes describes the history of the first world war. The history
of The Second World War takes up another six volumes. When
Chester Wilmot wrote The Struggle For Europe he took six
years to do it, yet Churchill has somehow managed to write ten
volumes (twelve if we include The Eastern Front and The
Aftermath) in the intervals of his other occupations as a politi¬
cian, painter and bricklayer. It is true that in writing his account
of the last war Churchill has had the assistance of a battery of
secretaries and research workers, with all the apparatus of mo¬
dern tape-recording machines, libraries of photograplis, and
access to official documents, yet Churchill did not have this
assistance for any of his other books. He himself has remarked
with becoming modesty, T am perhaps the only man who has
passed through both the two supreme cataclysms of recorded
history in high executive office.’ He could have added that there
is hardly an instance in history where the supreme actor in a
world war has recorded his own account of it. The only possible
comparison is with the Commentaries of Julius Caesar, which
are always cited as the one case in which a General has been
able to describe his own campaigns in a work which ranks as
literature. But Churchill’s war makes Caesar’s campaigns seem
like a punitive expedition. A war which involved the whole
world has been described by the chief leader on the victorious
side in a book which will rank with such historical masterpieces
as those of Gibbon and Macaulay. It is with witers of this
I m thIi <aii<aliur nl the |)uk<* otMai Ihtmamh. < arlv
< cnlur\
l.oril Bcasrrbniok
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
145
stature that Churchill must be compared. The present age has
many talented writers, who impart valuable information, in
language which can be understood by people of normal intelli¬
gence, but there is no writer besides Sir Winston Churchill who
has the grand manner. There is something in the air of our pre¬
sent civilization which seems hostile to human greatness; there
are always industrious little scribes who can find a mean or
obscene e.xplanation for everything fine or heroic and great
writing does not flourish in that kind of atmosphere. Churchill
as in so many other things, is in literature a survival from an
ampler age. He has told us himself how unconsciously he formed
his future style. As a young subaltern in India he used to pass the
afternoon hours between regimental duties and polo, when
others were sleeping in the heat, with reading the parcels of
books which his mother sent out to him from England. Gibbon s
Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Macaulay’s History of
England, Plato’s Republic, Dar\vin, Hegel, Aristotle, and many
others, these were the great books which Churchill read and
when he came to write his first book, on the Malakand Field
Force, the sonorous periods of Gibbon and the rhetoric of
Macaulay had been written into his o^vn work.
Soldier, journalist, and author, besides politician and states¬
man, here are four careers, which would have provided enough
activity for one man in each sphere. Four lives, yet this has not
exhausted the powers of this man. For in addition to all that we
have already considered, Churchill has been a painter. In middle
life when most men have settled down to the opinion of their
wives and their friends that they have no more power of lear¬
ning anything, Churchill took up painting in oils. Long before he
was a demi-god, long before he became an honorary member of
the Royal Academy, Churchill s pictures, some of them shown
anonymously, had achieved a high degree of success. Then the
bricklayer — it is almost like a personal incarnation of Shakes¬
peare’s Seven Ages of Man — when Churchill decided that he
would like to lay the bricks of his own wall, and when in his
gusto for life he applied for membership of the Bricklayers
Union, and had some difficulty in entering therein. A worker
146
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
with hand and brain, the terms of the Socialists' manifestos at
election times, Churchill certainly is. Moreover, all this achieve¬
ment has not been like that of Pericles, conceived and carried out
in an austere life, away from the festivities of men. ‘Look at me,
I do not smoke and I do not drink and I am 100 per cent effi¬
cient’ a great military leader is said to have told Churchill. ‘Look
at me, I smoke and drink, and I am 200 per cent efficient’ is the
legendary reply. No recluse is Churchill. He has never been
photographed at a public banquet, like the non-smoker, non¬
drinker, vegetarian, Anglo-Catholic Stafford Cripps, ostentatious¬
ly refusing a glass of wine. Why should he? He knows that the
creature comforts of this world are given us to help us through
the difficulties of life’s journey.
Into the space of 80 years then have been crowded the events
of half a dozen lifetimes. We can see the greatness of the quin¬
quennium, we can see the greatness of the writer, the industry
and talent of the journalist and painter, what of the politician
apart from the world statesman? Can the man who at Fulton
8 years ago made the most prophetic speech of modem times, be
the same who in the House of Commons has risen again and again
to contend with a Stafford Cripps, an Aneurin Sevan, an Ernest
Bevin, or an Attlee, who, whatever their merits in other respects
were certainly not foemen worthy of Churchill’s steel? Men of
his stature were foimd among his older contemporaries, an As¬
quith, a Grey, a Lloyd George, but they are gone, and none
appears who can challenge Churchill. This being so, it must
inevitably sadden those who truly admire Churchill, and not
merely pay him the tribute they can no longer withhold, to see
him in the arena of the House of Commons. One can understand
his action in not wishing to retire from politics after 1945. He
was defeated at an election, dismissed as he said himself from
all participation in the affairs of the British people,
longed to win for himself the election to the highest office whi^
he had never won — for in 1940 he had been as it were coopted.
The prize came to him at last. He led his party to victory, he
was the free peacetime choice of the people of Britain, and he
could then safely rest on his laurels. But to attain that position
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
147
was it really necessary to wrangle in any and every political
argument in the House of Commons? Does it really enchance the
position of a great leader who is internationally famous, for him
to engage in verbal fisticuffs of the kind that prevail at West¬
minster? What value is there in it? And now that Sir Winston
has retired from the Premiership how much more in keeping
with the majesty of his career it would be for him to become the
most senior leader of the war in the Upper House, as a Duke?
Why does he not accept a peerage? His presence in the Upper
House, Britain’s senate as it was called in the 18th century, would
be of unparalleled greatness, and his utterances would gain an
added dignity, while in that august atmosphere even opponents
would talk with a becoming serenity.
From such high themes it seems almost ridiculous to turn to
the petty triRings of genealogy, which only slowly recovers from
the abuses of its friends. Yet even to family history Sir Winston
has given attention. In his life of his great ancestor, the first Duke
of Marlborough, he had perforce to tackle the subject of the
origin of the Churchill family. In peerage books the ancestry of
the Churchills is traced as follows:
‘Charles Churchill, son of Giles Churchill and grandson of
William Churchill, of Rockbear, Devon, was engaged by Tho¬
mas Courtenay, Earl of Devon, in the cause of Edward IV; and
adhering to that Monarch, when the Earl deserted his party,
obtained in marriage, by the King's interest Margaret, daughter
and heiress of Sir William Widville, a lady nearly related to the
Queen. Charles Churchill’s great-great-grandson and represen¬
tative, Matthew Churchill, of Bradford etc., and so on to the
grandson of Matthew’.
This grandson was John Churchill, of Mintem, Devon, who
married Sarah, daughter and co-heir of Sir Henry Winston, of
Standish, co. Gloucester, and was father of Sir Winston Ghiuch-
ill, and grandfather of the first Duke. We have thus a picture of
a line of small west country squires who are to be traced for
about 200 years before the time of the first Duke of Marlbo¬
rough. The first Sir Winston Churchill, who was bom in 1620
and was a remarkable man in his way was very loyal to the
148 TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Stuarts and had at the Restoration an augmentation to his coat
of arms.
‘The King to Sir Edward Walker, Garter, December H, 1661:
Orders an augmentation of a St. George s cross gules, on a canton
argent, to the arms of Winston Churchill, of Mintem, co. Dorset,
for service to the late King as Captain of horse and for his
present loyalty as a member of the House of Commons.’ Aug¬
mentations of arms are very rare in England and are a great
honour but Sir Winston did not think that the distinction was
a sufficient recompense for his services in the Great Rebellion
and perhaps he did not think that it was enough in consideration
of the greatness of his family. For the stout old Cavalier had
engaged in the study of his own ancestry. He wrote an account
of the origin of the Churchills in which he traced his arms, a lion
rampant argent upon a sable shield to Otho de Leon, Castelan of
Gisor (perhaps who knows, a kinsman of the Henri de Leon who
founded the family of the Viscounts Dillon) ‘whom we call our
common ancestor’. The said Otho (I follow Sir Winston’s
account) had two sons, Richard and Wandrill, Lord of Courcelle,
'whose youngest son came to England with William the Con¬
queror.’ Several more generations were given until Sir Winston
arrived at one John the Lord of Currichill or Chirechile, or
Churchill in Somerset. This John had a son Sir Bartholomew
de Churchill who was supposed to be of great note in the time
of King Stephen and to have been concerned in the defence of
Bristol on behalf of that king. It appears that in the time of
King Edward the First the then Churchill took the wrong side in
the disturbances with the Barons so that his property was seized
by the Crown and thus lost to the family. Sir Winston then went
through various little-known generations until he came to John,
whom he described as the ancestor of the Churchills of Muston.
It is interesting to note that at the present time there is still a
flourishing family of Churchills of Muston in Dorsetshire which
bears the same arms as the celebrated Churchill family ®
difference of a bendlet. This family has no crest, a fact which
demonstrates its antiquity and also that like the ongin
ChurchiUs themselves it was not of sufficient importance m the
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
149
Middle Ages to rate as of tournament rank, crests being used by
families which took part in tournaments. To resume Sir Win¬
ston’s account he mentions a Roger Churchill who by the daugh¬
ter of Peverell the widow of Nicholas Meggs had issue Mathew,
the father of Jasper, Sir Winston’s grandfather. At this point it
will be obser\'ed that Sir Winstons account agrees with tliat in
the peerage books but one commentator, Edward Harley, asser¬
ted that John Churchills greatgrandfather was a blacksmith
who worked in the family of tlie Meggs. In about two gene¬
rations before the time of the alleged blacksmith, one of the
Churchills did marry a Mrs Meggs.
It seems fairly certain that the name of Churchill is derived
not from Courcelle, but from a place name in Somerset, and that
the real ancestry of the Churchills cannot be traced back for
more than 200 years before the time of the first Duke. The fact
which contributed most to the advancement of the Churchill
family was the marriage of John Churchill to Sarah Winston.
John Churchill was a successful lawyer, a member of the Middle
Temple, and his marriage connected him with a family of greater
standing than his own. This in its turn made possible the mar¬
riage of his son the first Sir Winston, whose account I have been
following, with Elizabeth Drake, a member of a famous family
of the Drakes of Ash in Devonshire. Sir Winston himself cheri¬
shed a certain resentment for the ingratitude of a court. Ap¬
parently he put into his coat of arms or took as an additional
crest an uprooted oak with the motto Kiel Pero Desdichado —
Faithful but unfortunate'. This crest is not now used by the
Churchills, but the fact that a crest was granted to Sir Winston’s
family shows that his line like that of the present day Churchills
of Muston was not sufficiently wealthy to have taken part in the
tournaments, where crests were used by the important families.
For the earlier part of the pedigree as given in Sir Winston’s
account this may be dismissed as one of the imaginings which
have troubled English gentlepeople for more than 600 years.
It has always been the idea of English people, at least since the
days of Richard 11, as soon as they have imagined themselves to
be important, to think that they are of Norman origin. There is
150
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
a prevailing habit among English people, the desire to be con¬
nected with the best people, and as conquerors must necessarily
be the best people, the Normans, the last in the list of England’s
conquerors, are perforce the best of the best people. Therefore as
families have risen in the social scale they have always wanted to
show that their ancestors were great, that is that they have not
risen at all, and so Norman pedigrees have been worked out time
and again. This habit has been productive of much good as well as
of harm, for while ‘keeping up with the Jones’ can run a man into
expenditure beyond his income, it can also provide that little
extra spur which makes for successful effort.
However, when we get to real genealogy instead of mytho¬
logy and fairy tales, most of our great families can be shown to
have come up from fairly humble origins; there is no accounting
for genius, which makes its appearance like the wind in the Old
Testament, blowing where it listeth, and no man knoweth
whence it cometh; but apart from genius we can usually trace
in a family the moment when someone with a little extra ability
took advantage of some good luck. In the case of the Russells it
was the presence of John Russell at Weymouth which led to his
advancement. He had qualified as a linguist, and as good luck
would have it the King and Queen of Castille landed at Wey¬
mouth with great need of an interpreter. Hence by a combi¬
nation of talent and good luck, the rise of the Dukes of Bedford.
So it was with the Churchills. The good old Cavalier Sir Winston
Churchill might believe the story of his Norman ancestry and
think that the rise of his children in the world was due to the
gentle Norman blood working itself out. In fact the real cause
of their success was their grandfather John Churchill's marriage
vrith the Winston heiress. The Churchills were small fry before
this time but with the increase in their estate it was possible tor
them to go to court and to rise in various profession^ Jota
Churchill, the Duke of Marlborough was the eldest son, but the
other chUdren did very weU. George the younger brother was
in the Navy and had a distinguished career, being Admnal ot
the Blue. M.P. for St Albans, and one of the Council ^
George of Denmark, the husband of Queen Anne. George
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
151
Churchill merited burial in Westminster Abbey. The youngest
brother Charles, sei^'ed with distinction at the battles of Stein-
kirk and Landen. He was made a Lieut-General and Governor
of Kingsale in Ireland by William of Orange, and was later
Governor of the Tower, Governor of Bnissels, Colonel of the
Coldstream Guards, and Governor of Guernsey. Both George
and Charles died without issue. The issue of John Churchill
failed in the male line when his only son the Marquess of Bland-
ford died of smallpox at Cambridge at the age of 13. The females
of the family were more successful. The only sister of the first
Duke was the famous Arabella Churchill. She was eventually the
wife of Colonel Charles Godfrey, Master of the Jewel Office, by
whom she had children; she had already had a family by the
Duke of York, afterwards King James II. One of the sons of this
connection was the Duke of Berwick who figures in English
peerage books as the holder of an attainted peerage. In Continent¬
al books on aristocracy he is shown as the ancestor of the Span¬
ish Duke of Alba and of Benvick, for the title has not been
considered as forfeited (at least in Europe). Similarly in France
the Due de Fitz-James descends from the Duke of Berwick. The
latter had a very distinguished career in exile where he followed
the fortunes of his father. The Duke of Berwick became a
Marshal of France and won the battle of Almanza in the War
of the Spanish Succession, a battle rendered all the more peculiar
by die fact that a British General in command of foreign troops
defeated a British army commanded by a foreigner.
On the relationship between Arabella and James II has been
built the beginning of the vast edifice of shame and immorality
which so many historians have associated with the first Duke of
Marlborough. The modem Sir Winston Churchill has told us
of the irritation which he felt as a young subaltern in India when,
although delighted with Macaulay's style, he came across that
historians violent attack upon his ancestor the first Duke. One
may surmise that Churchill had then first the idea of writing a
vindication of his ancestor. He would enter the lists against
Macaulay. He certainly fulfilled this intention, for nearly 40
years afterwards (in 1933) he published his life of Marlborough
152
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
in which he endeavoured to show that Macaulay was wrong,
not only in stating that John Churchill owed his rise at Court to
his sister s accommodating ways, but also in his account of John
Churchill’s numerous treacheries. Whatever may be thought
of the Life of Marlborough in this connection, it would appear
that there is at least a case to be put on the other side against
Macaulay’s estimate. The old Duchess, the famous Sarah, wrote
a letter in which she said T want to say something more than I
have done in the enclosed paper to show how extremely mis¬
taken Mr. Lediard was in naming the Duke of Marlborough’s
sister and her train of bastards. Because they had titles he seems
to think that was an honour to the Duke. I think quite the con¬
trary. For it seems to insinuate that his first introduction (i.e. to
Court) was from an infamous relation, when the whole truth of
the matter was as follows. His sister was a Maid of Honour to
the first Duchess of York, Hyde. She had at least two or three
bastards by the Duke of York, or others, when her brother was
whipped at St Paul’s School for not reading his book. Now I
would fain have any reasonable body tell me what the Duke of
Marlborough could do when a boy at School to prevent the in¬
famy of his sister, or why Mr. Lediard could have any judgement
in mentioning King James’ favourite*.
Whatever the truth about this matter, John Churchill served
in a most dissolute court and is unlikely to have escaped the
normal vices of the age. What is much more important is the
charge brought against him by Macaulay that he betrayed his
master James II and even went beyond that and betrayed his
country, causing the death of some hundreds of British soldiers
and sailors. There does not seem to be much room for argument
that the Duke served both James and Wilham of Orange. Most
noblemen of the time were engaged in similar conspiracies, but
Churchill must have been much deeper in them than anyone
else; for although William at first used his services he evidentiy
had a profound distrust for him because he never employed him
in any capacity after the beginning of his reign. The correspon¬
dence between Marlborough and William of Orange at the time
when the former was in James II’s service may perhaps be ex-
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
153
cused in the same way that a person employed by one company
who negotiates with another may be looked upon as prudent
and far seeing. The charge against the Duke of Marlborough is
rendered the worse by the fact that he received a title, the
Barony of Churchill in the peerage of Scotland, during the reign
of Charles II. This was due to the influence of the Duke of York
and when the latter became James II, an English peerage went
to Marlborough.
A man who can betray a master who has given him such
substantial marks of favour is not likely to hestitate at any other
kind of treachery. Being in William Ill’s disfavour, Marlborough
was confined for a time in the Tower. After his release he turned
to fresh double dealing. He wrote to James II and endeavoured
once more to ingratiate himself witli his former master. The
latter, a credulous easy soul, instead of spurning Marlborough,
gave him encouragement. After tliis, according to many histori¬
ans, occurred the incident of Camaret Bay. The story is that
Marlborough wrote a letter to King James in which he said that
he had only that day (May 1694) learned that 'the bomb ketches
and the twelve regiments encamped at Portsmouth, \vith the two
regiments of marines, all commanded by Talmash, are destined
for burning the Port of Brest and destroying all the men of war
that are there, this will be a great advantage to England. But no
consideration can prevent, or ever shall prevent me from infor¬
ming you of all that I believe can be for your service. Therefore
you can make your use of this intelligence, which you may rely
upon as exactly true. But I must conjure you for your own in¬
terest to let no one know it but the Queen and the bearer of this
letter. Russell will set sail tomorrow with forty ships, the rest
being not yet paid; but it is said that in ten days the rest of the
fleet will follow; and at the same time, the land forces. I attemp¬
ted to learn this some time ago from Admiral Russell. But he al¬
ways denied it to me, though I am very sure that he knew the
design for more than six weeks. This gives me a bad sign of this
man’s intentions. I shall be very well pleased to learn that this
letter has come safely to your hands.’
It is probably impossible after all this time to disentangle the
154
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
truth from the falsehood in the charges against Marlborough,
but there seems little doubt that he was responsible for an
enormous web of intrigue over a large period of years. Even¬
tually in 1702 when Queen Anne succeeded to the throne he
obtained his reward. He was already Earl of Marlborough but
by Queen Anne he was swiftly appointed a Knight of the Gar¬
ter and Captain General of all the forces in England and of the
troops who were to act in conjunction with the allies. At this
time Marlborough was 52 and his experience of war was con¬
fined to some siege operations in the Low Countries, and to the
Battle of Sedgemoor, where he had led troops to victory over the
peasants of Somerset.
Consequently when he was appointed Commander-in-Chief of
the allied forces in Western Europe, his Dutch allies could be
excused from wondering how he would fare in a battle since he
had never fought one in full command. It is a wonderful example
of native genius that Marlborough with his slight experience and
without anything like the detailed training of a modem officer,
was able to feel confidence in setting out to meet the celebrated
marshals of Louis XIV who had for 40 years been accustomed to
fight with success in every campaign. In the course of a few
years the whole of the military situation was reversed, in 1704
Marlborough won Blenheim, in 1706 Ramillies, 1708 Oudenarde,
and 1709 Malplaquet. In these four battles and in the many
successful sieges which he carried through Marlborough humbled
the power of Louis XIV to the dust Whereas at the beginning
of the war the French King had been dreaded throughout
Europe, within a few years he was fighting with his back to the
wall, calling upon his impoverished people to support him for
one last effort. It has been said that France never really recove¬
red from the great exertions which she was forced to make in the
time of Louis XIV.
Nor although Marlboroughs victories with the exception of
Blenheim were won in the Low Countries, could Marlborough
confine his attention only to Belgium and to Northern France.
He had to be a statesman and a continent wide strategist as well
as a brilliant commander in the field. The war of the Spanish
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER-CHURCHILL
155
Succession was on the way to being a world war in the cycle
which began with the struggles of Holland and England against
Spain and which went on to the Seven Years War, the Napoleonic
Wars and the first and second World Wars of our time. In the
east of Europe the allies — England. Holland, Denmark and the
Empire had a commander in Prince Eugene of Savoy. One of
the most important parts of Marlborough’s task was to remain
on good terms with Prince Eugene. This was essential in order
that both generals should use their forces in unison. Before the
war had properly got under way Marlborough had visited tlie
northern capitals of Europe in order to ensure their neutrality,
if he could not obtain their participation in the war on the allied
side. In this he had been successful and in particular in dealing
with Charles XII of Sweden. Quite apart from his long experience
of court intrigue and dissimulation Marlborough had therefore
had valuable experience in diplomacy; moreover during the
earlier campaigns, at least in the Netherlands, he was accom¬
panied by inspectors who were supplied by the Dutch govern¬
ment. The function of these men was to be constantly at Marl¬
borough’s side in order to watch over his movements and to see
that he did nothing which would unduly endanger the safety of
the Dutch troops who were under his command. Marlborough
was in fact the Commander-in-Chief of the allied forces in wes¬
tern Europe and had to experience the frustrations and difficul¬
ties which are incumbent upon such a position; in theory he had
complete command over all the troops in the area, but in fact he
was subjected to the very rigorous control of his Dutch allies.
They frustrated his plans for the first two years of the war.
Despite his difficulties he did contrive to capture several French
fortresses — Venloo, Stevenswaert, Roermond and Liege — but
he was not allowed to fight a battle in the open with the French.
On the Dutch side there was the natural feeling that here was a
general who was well past fifty and who had had no experience
in actual combat of large scale action, whereas the French com¬
manders were all men experienced in the frequent warfare of
Louis XIVs campaigns. After two years of this very trying ordeal
even Marlborough’s suavity of manner was penetrated and when
156
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
he returned on leave to England in the winter of 1703—04 it
was with the fixed determination either to have his own way or
to resign the command.
It is curious to think how very easily Marlborough might not
have gone down in history as one of its greatest captains. Had
the Dutch inspectorate been able to pursue its inquisitions a little
further, Marlborough would in all probability have thrown up
his command in disgust. As it was he succeeded in getting his
own way by guile. He managed to escape from his Dutch
tormentors mainly because he did not tell them where he was
going, and partly because he deceived them as to his destination.
Had he told the Dutch where he intended to march they would
have gone out of their minds with anxiety. What Marlborough
did is of course well known, but this cannot lessen the splendour
of it. As his great descendant has written: ‘The annals of the
British Army contain no more heroic episode than this march
from the North Sea to the Danube.’ For it was nothing less and
Marlborough crossed Europe to succour the Empire which was
hard pressed by the French. He had some 20,000 British troops
with him, some Dutch troops and was joined later by some
7,000 Danes. He effected a junction with Prince Eugene and
their combined force defeated Marshal Tallard at Blenheim on
the Danube on 13th August 1704. That is the bare blunt fact,
but the brain of Marlborough was the brain of a coalition. Had
he failed at Blenheim, the allies must have gone down before the
might of Louis XIV. However great Marlborough might have
been on the battlefield this would not have compensated for a
failure in overall strategy or in inability to grasp the political
significance of his actions. He had to maintain correspondence
with the government in England where much of his work con¬
sisted in keeping his own party in power; he had to keep in
reserve a sufficient force to hold the French back in the Nether¬
lands; he had to plan the details of a march into the ®
Europe and to know that on the event of his gamble would de¬
pend the neutrality of several of the European powers. When
his army had disappeared into Germany no news of its true
progress reached England for weeks; all sorts of rumours came
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER^CHURCHILL
157
instead. Marlborough’s enemies rejoiced and his friends were
downcast. If the army had been destroyed a deadly blow would
have been given to the allied cause. Queen Anne was gazing
pensively from the windows of Windsor Castle when the mess¬
enger bearing Marlborough’s despatches came in sight. This
officer was shown at once into tlie Queen’s presence where he
had the honour to inform her of the great victory which had
been won. She presented him witli a purse of 1000 guineas and
the munificence of her gift reflected her own joy and that of tlie
nation. Marlborough had already received the highest honours
in the peerage; in reward for his capture of fortresses in 1702 he
had been created Marquess of Blandford and Duke of Marl¬
borough. Now, however, for his vastly greater services he was
voted by Parliament a grant of the Royal manor of Woodstock
in Oxfordshire. By the Queen's orders the palace of Blenheim
was built at the public expense and the terms on which the
property was held were that a captured French standard should
be rendered as rent on each anniversary of Blenheim. A sum of
£5,000 was settled on the Duke and his successors annually for
ever. The Emperor Leopold made Marlborough a Count of the
Holy Roman Empire, and by the next Emperor, Joseph, he was
created Prince of Mindelheim in Swabia.
Nor were these honours deserved only by the victory of Blen¬
heim; the three other great victories, Ramillies, Oudenarde and
Malplaquet, were equally destructive of French hegemony in
Europe. Had Marlborough been able to go on for another year
he would probably have captured Paris.
It was not to be however, and Marlborough experienced the
same neglect and hostility which came to the Duke of Welling¬
ton. He lived for many years after his great victories (he died in
1722) but although employed by George I he never had the
oportunity again to signalize himself as he had done in the War
of the Spanish Succession. He had the misfortune to survive
his own powers of reason and the anecdote is handed down that
one day he looked at a picture of himself at Blenheim Palace and
remarked sorrowfully that he had once been a man. As he had
lost his only son, he secured Royal permission for his properties
158
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
and honours to pass to his elder daughter Henrietta who became
Duchess of Marlborough in 1722. She was married to the second
Earl of Godolphin and all her children by him died without issue,
so that the Dukedom and other honours with Blenheim Palace
passed to her nephew Charles Spencer the fifth earl of Sunder¬
land, who became the third Duke of Marlborough. He was of
course the grandson of John Churchill, Duke of Marlborough,
but in his paternal line he was a Spencer. Consequently to this
day the family name is Spencer-Churchill.
We thus have the remarkable fact that separated by 200 years
the family of Churchill or of Spencer-Churchill has produced
two of the greatest men in British, and in world, history. The
first Duke of Marlborough was a greater man than the Duke
of Wellington for he not only gained great victories in the field,
but was also a great statesman and diplomatist who was able to
put heart into a coalition of unruly princes, nobles, burghers and
other nondescripts, while at the same time training the British
army which was in a wretched state when he took it over, and
indulging in party politics. He defeated the ambitious plans of
Louis XIV; his descendant was the principal means of defeating
Hitler. There have been other men in the Churchill family of
considerable ability. Lord Randolph Churchill, the father of Sir
Winston Churchill, was an outstanding politician who failed
to meet the expectations which had been formed about his
career. We do not know what would have happened if he had
lived longer for he was only 46 when he died. It would be in¬
vidious to single out other members of the Churchill family who
have shown undoubted brilliance, but it is interesting to com¬
pare this continuance of ability in the Churchills with the more
ordinary course of other noble families. In the case of the Coo¬
pers, the first Earl of Shaftesbury was one of the most celebrated
figures of the later 17th century but of his successors for several
generations it has been said that it was sufficient that they were
Earls. When we come to the seventh Earl of Shaftesbi^y we
come again upon a man whose name will always live, but ere is
a case of solitary achievement after several generations of quie¬
tude. Again in the Cecil family ability slumbered for some
THE HOUSE OF SPENCER CHURCHILL
159
generations until the time of the third Marquess of Salisbury
when the political talents to which the family owed its foun¬
dation were once more apparent.
The name of Churchill is now reno^vned throughout the world
and should, as we like to think, be known to everyone. Yet it is
probable that a majority of people have never heard itl Once in
India during tlie war when fairly near to Agra a party of officers
found themselves near a native village. They tried to talk to the
Indians and to see if anything would awaken their interest. The
names of Churchill, Stalin, Roosevelt, Hitler and Mussolini were
tried without the slightest glimmer of recognition. Only Gandhi s
name stirred some interest. Among the many hundreds of mil¬
lions of India, China, Africa, Siberia, and South America, the
names of the greatest men in the world in all probability mean
nothing. The existence of these native multitudes is bounded by
a few miles around their squalid homes.
Chapter nine
SACKVILLE
THE HOUSE OF SACKVILLE-WEST
A few miles from Sevenoaks in Kent is the rounded hill or
knoll which gives its name to one of the greatest houses in
England. This is Knole, the seat of Lord Sackville. Although the
property has been made over to the National trust Lord Sackville
still retains the right of residence in it. There are seven court¬
yards at Knole, fifty-two staircases and 365 rooms, correspon¬
ding to the days of the week, weeks of the year and days of the
year respectively. It is associated with the Sackville family, but
it has a history going back long before their ownership of it. For
some years it belonged to the Archbishops of Canterbury, and
Thomas Boxu’chier, one of the Archbishops, bought it in 1456
and presented it to the See of Canterbury in 1480. From the Arch¬
bishops it passed into the always ready grip of Henry VIII. ‘As
for Knole, it standeth on a sound, perfect, and wholesome
ground; and if I should make abode here, as I do surely mind
to do now and then, I will live at Knole.' Thus Henry VIII, who
seldom took no for an answer, but under his younger daughter,
Elizabeth I, the lease was given to her cousin Thomas Sackville
in 1566. He did not however come into possession of the pro¬
perty until 1603 but since that date a Sackville has always lived
at Knole. Knole is a tieasure house of the beautiful things with
which the family have enriched it generation by generation. Now
that the National Trust are to preserve it we know that at least
it will not be pulled down or turned into a school, but we are
bound to feel as we view it now that much of the glory has de¬
i6o
Kiny William 1\ . \»\ su \i.irim \tchif shrf Mrs. jnrclan as R<isaliiulv John }i.>ppii«i
THE HOUSE OF SACKVILLE-WEST
161
parted from this great house, since it is no longer purely and
simply a home but in part at least a museum.
The Sackvilles are a family of great interest. Long before 1603
they were famous. For this is one of the few cases in the British
peerage in which an allegedly Norman family is really and truly
Norman. The history of the family has been traced in great detail
by Mr Charles Phillips and the Norman origin of the Sackvilles
is vouched for in the Complete Peerage and in the writings of
the vitriolic dyspeptic Horace Round.
The Sackvilles take their name from Sauqueville, a little south¬
west of Dieppe in Normandy. In Domesday Book of 1086 Her-
brand de Sauqueville is mentioned as holding Fawley in Buck¬
inghamshire. He was the owner of that property about 1070.
A complete pedigree of the family is given in various works
besides those mentioned above. Herbrand is thought to have
been the steward of Walter Giffard, one of the greatest of the
early companions of the Conqueror. One of the descendants of
Herbrand was John Sackville of Chiddingly in Kent who married
Margaret BuUen, aunt of Anne BuUen, the second wife of Henry
VIII. Hence the kinship of John Sackvilles son. Sir Richard Sack¬
ville, with Queen Elizabeth I. This Sir Richard Sackville was a
member of the Privy Council in the reigns of Mary I and Eliza¬
beth I, also M.P. for Kent and subsequently for Surrey. His son
Thomas Sackville was born in 1536 at Buckhurst in the parish of
Withyham in Sussex, and rose rapidly in Queen Elizabeth's
favour. For several years he was a member of Parliament but on
8th June 1567 he was knighted by the Duke of Norfolk in the
presence of Queen Elizabeth, and on the same day he was
created a peer of the realm as Baron Buckhurst of Buckhurst in
Sussex. It was some time before he could benefit from his pos¬
session of Knole but fortunately Thomas Sackville was a man
who had inherited great wealth from his father. It will be by the
way easier to refer to him by his surname than by his title, al¬
though he was afterwards advanced to an earldom as Earl of
Dorset, for he has made a name as Sackville in English literature.
Sir Richard Sackville, the earl s father, was unflatteringly nick¬
named FiUsack on account of his rapacity in gathering property
162
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
from the Crown and from other sources. Among other properties
he obtained a London estate which covered an area from Fleet
Street to the Thames and from Blackfriars to Bridewell. Conse¬
quently it was not necessary for Thomas Sackville to worry over¬
much about his fortune, and he was able to devote himself in the
first place to poetry and afterwards to politics.
In the first category he left behind him a small body of poetry
which shows that he possessed literary talent, a quality very
much apparent in the Sackville family to this day. He produced
Gorboduc or Ferrex and Porrex, a tragedy in five acts. Even the
ancestral devotion of Miss V. Sackville-West is bound to des¬
cribe this composition as of unbearable dullness. The argument
of the tragedy, as it was then called, is set out as follows: ‘Gor¬
boduc, King of Britain, divided his realm in his lifetime to his
sons, Ferrex and Porrex. The sons fell to dissension. The younger
killed the elder. The mother, that more dearly loved the elder,
for revenge killed the younger. The people, moved with the
cruelty of the fact, rose in rebellion, and slew both father and
mother. The nobility assembled, and most terribly destroyed the
rebels; and afterwards, for want of issue of the Prince, whereby
the succession of the crown became uncertain, they fell to civil
war, in which both they and many of their issues were slain, and
the land for a long time almost desolate and miserable wasted.'
As an example of the verse in the poem may be taken a piece
at random from a speech by one of Ferrex’ counsellors, Dordan:
‘O heaven I was there even heard or known.
So wicked counsel to a noble prince?
Let me, my lord, disclose unto your grace.
This heinous tale, what mischief it contains;
Your father’s death, your brother’s, and your own,
Your present murder, and eternal shame.
Hear me, o king, and suffer not to sink
So high a treason in your princely breast.’
However, we may mercifully leave this strangely named play
to the historians of EngUsh literature; even the most casual ob-
THE HOUSE OF SACKVILLE-WEST
163
server must notice the hint of Lear. Then we come however to
Sackville’s other poems, the Induction and The Complaint of the
Duke of Buckingham. It was intended by Sackville that the
Induction should be a preface or introduction to a poem to be
called The Mirror for Magistrates. In the plan of this work it was
intended that all the illustrious but unfortunate characters of
English history, from the Norman Conquest to the end of the
14th century should pass in review before the poet, who, like
Dante, descended into Hell for the purpose of his work. The
object of the poem was to show, as so often occurred with the
Elizabethans, the mutability of fortune. As Sackville never
finished his poem, the Induction acts now as the opening piece
to tlie Complaint. When the verse in these poems is compared
with the t>'pe of verse which had afflicted England under such
poets as Skelton, we see why Sackville is so important a figure
in our literature.
‘Lastly stood War, in glittering arms yclad,
With visage grim, stem looks, and blackly hued;
In his right hand a naked sword he had,
That to the hilts was all with blood imbrued;
And in his left (that kings and kingdoms rued)
Famine and fire he held, and therewithal
He razed towns, and threw down towers and all.’
Before leaving the subject of Sackville’s writings it may be
noticed that Gorboduc was presented before Queen Elizabeth I
at Whitehall by the gentlemen of the Inner Temple, SackviUe
himself being one of the latter for he had been entered as a
student at that Inn, though in those days such a step did not by
any means imply that in every case the student intended to
study law. In fact in the 16th century the Inns of Court were
regarded as very like a university, only perhaps more elastic in
what they taught, for at this time they had teachers in such
subjects as dancing.
In politics Thomas Sackville held many appointments. I quote
from Miss Sackville-West: ‘He was twice sent on embassies to
France, three times to the Low Countries; Chancellor of O.vford.
164
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Lord High Treasurer and Lord High Steward of England, a
Knight of the Garter.'
Fortunately we have some of Sackville’s letters and one of
these in particular which is addressed to the Lords of the Privy
Council is especially interesting. It is written in 1568 in which
year Sackville had been ordered to receive Cardinal de Chatillon,
tlie brother of the Admiral Coligni who had become a Protestant
and had taken refuge in England. Sackville was at that time keep¬
ing house in part of the Queen’s palace at Sheen and the letter
refers to his housekeeping difficulties. The Queen was dis¬
pleased with him because she felt that he had not entertained
the Cardinal with sufficient care and sumptuousness. The letter
throws a great light on the manners of the age and on the penury
or at least penurious habits of Sackville. He excuses himself as
follows:
T brought them (i.e. the Queen’s officers) into every part of the
house that I possessed, and showed them all such stuff and fur¬
niture as I had. And where they required plate of me, I told them
as troth is, that I had no plate at all. Such glass vessels as I had
I offered them, which they thought too base; for napery I could
not satisfy their turn, for they desired damask work for a long
table, and I had none other but plain linen for a square table.
The table whereon I dine myself I offered them, and for that
it was but a square table they refused it. One only tester and
bedstead not occupied I had, and those I delivered for the
Cardinal himself, and when we could not in so short a time
procure another bedstead for the bishop, I assigned them the
bedstead on which my wife's waiting women did lie, and laid
them on the ground. Mine own bason and ewer I lent to the
Cardinal and wanted myself. So did I the candlesticks for mine
own table, with divers drinking glasses, small cushions, small
pots for the kitchen, and sundry other such like trifles, although
indeed I had no great store of them than I presently occupied.
And albeit this be not worth the writing, yet mistrusting lest the
misorder of some others in denying of such like kind of stuff not
occupied by themselves, hath been percase informed as towards
me, I have thought good not to omit it. Long tables, forms, brass
THE HOUSE OF SACKVILLE-WEST
165
for the kitchen, and all such necessaries as could not be furnished
by me, we took order to provide in the town; hangings and beds
we received from the yeoman of the wardrobe at Richmond, and
when we saw that napery and sheets could no where here be
had, I sent word thereof to the officers at the Court, by which
means we received from my lord of Leicester two pair of fine
sheets for the Cardinal, and from my lord Chamberlain, one
pair of fine for the bishop, with two other coarse pair, and order
beside for ten pair more from London. At which time also be¬
cause I would be sure your Lordships should be ascertained of
the simpleness and scarcity of such stuff as I had here, I sent a
man of mine to the Court, specially to declare to your Lordships
tliat for plate, damask, napery and fine sheets, I had none at
all etc., etc.’
This passage makes all the more curious reading when we
recall the huge sums spent by Sackville, especially at Knole. His
father’s fortune was very considerable and he had this to draw
upon, quite apart from his own official emoluments which in that
age of courtly perquisites would not be inconsiderable. In ten
months at Knole, 1607—1608, he spent about £40,000 in our
money, and it is said that he imported 300 workmen from Italy
for the adornment of his home. He was a lover of music and had
a private orchestra of ten in his service. This expenditure on
Knole occured nearly 40 years after the incident of the Cardinal
so that perhaps meanness had gone from him by that time. When
he died he had gone far towards the completion of Knole. 'Tho¬
mas Sackville died at the Council table in April 1608. He left vast
property to his son who was Earl of Dorset and lord of Knole
for only a year. He founded and built Sackville College at East
Grinstead. He also left behind a memorial of a more dubious
character in the person of his son, Richard Sackville, the 3rd
Earl of Dorset. He spent vast sums of money, and is said to have
counted the day wasted if he did not spend in it £ 100. No for¬
tune however great could stand up to treatment of this nature,
and the Earl was reduced to trying to prey upon the fortune of
his wife, who was Lady Anne Clifford, the daughter of the 3rd
Earl of Cumberland. In the Ballroom at Knole, which is fur-
166
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Dished with furniture of the period of Louis XIV and Louis XV,
we can see the pictures of the 3rd Earl and of his Countess. The
waster and spendthrift is easily seen in his face and equally her
stem lineaments promise no easy spoil to her wastrel lord.
The 3rd Earl went from bad to worse, and in order to pay his
debts he had to sell the immensely valuable Manor of Holbom
and the property of Shoe Lane in London (where the Express
office now stands). These properties produced nearly £.1,000,000
in modem money. Despite all his sales, however, when he died,
he was in debt to the amount of £60,000. He was fond of litera¬
ture and finished the building of Sackville College.
The 3rd Earl was succeeded by his brother Edward, and he in
turn by the 5th Earl his son. The latter although he succeeded in
the midst of the Civil War in 1652 and although the family had
suffered losses from the Parliamentarians, managed to restore
the splendour of Knole. He married the daughter and heiress of
the Earl of Middlesex, who brought much wealth into the family.
It is impossible to overestimate the beauty and very hard to
estimate the value of the contents of Knoll. Most English coun¬
try houses have a great gallery, but at Knole, owing to its vast size,
there are several. The Great Hall is of course most impressive,
though it has not the vastness of that at Arundel Castle, but
seems more in the style of a home. The Brown Gallery, which
is also called the Reformers’ Gallery contains many valuable
paintings, as does the Leicester Gallery. In the latter are two
genealogical rolls or roller pedigrees as they are often called,
those of Sackville and Curzon. In the Cartoon Gallery there are
copies by Daniel Mytens of Raphaels cartoons, the originals
being at Hampton Court. As for paintings it would require a
special book to catalogue them. In the Crimson Drawing Room
or Reynolds Room, as it is called, there are many pictures by
Reynolds, a Romney and a Gainsborough.
Perhaps the most remarkable room at Knole is that which is
called King James Is room. There is a tradition that it was
specially prepared for that King but there is no real evidence
that he ever visited Knole. It is however a magnificent room,
worthy of a King. A great deal of the furniture of the room is
THE HOUSE OF SACKVILLE-WEST
167
made of silver and this presents a most remarkable appearance.
The King’s Room is perhaps one of the most famous of tlie
beasures of Knole, but in fact at Knole there is as it were a
museum of all that generations of e.xquisite taste have been
able to bring together. One would hardly class among the finest
treasures of Knole the stained glass window which one sees in
the Old Billiard Room but it is none the less of great interest.
This window shows tlie martial features and mailed form of the
original Herbrand, qui venit in Anglia cum Gulielmo Conqui-
store. It would be interesting if one could have the reflections
of Herbrand as he looks down upon the crowds of sightseers
whom the guides of the National Trust conduct so ably round the
house. Herbrand was the fitting start of a great line. The splen¬
did house at Knole is now the memorial of his family.
After the Elizabethan period the family continued to rise in
greatness until in 1720, Lionel Sackville was created Duke of
Dorset. He was the son of the 6th Earl of Dorset who had suc¬
ceeded in the right of his mother to the estates of the Earl of
Middlesex his maternal grandfather, and who was himself crea¬
ted Earl of Middlesex. It was this nobleman, the first Duke, who
was the father of the famous, or infamous, according to the pre¬
dilection of the reader. Lord George Sackville, or Lord George
Germain as he became. This celebrated man has claims to fame
which may not be the envy of others. He had been credited
with the authorship of the Letters of Junius but it is not likely
that he had anything to do with them. One indisputable claim
to renown Lord George possessed and that was for his failure to
destroy the defeated French forces at the Battle of Minden in
1758. This was one of the few triumphs won on land in Eiuope
by the British in the Seven Years War - they had been successful
in every other part of the world. It was solely an infantry triumph,
for Lord George who was in charge of the cavalry refused to
charge. For this he was courtmartialled and adjudged unfit to
serve the King in any military capacity. Despite his disgrace he
was made a P.C., and later received a peerage as Viscount
Sackville. His son eventually succeeded to the Dukedom of
Dorset and was the fifth and last Duke of that creation. Lord
168
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
George Sackville became Lord George Germain in consequence
of receiving a large fortune, with the usual name and arms
clause in the will. It was thus from this line that the present
family descend. The last Duke left no children and all his titles
became extinct. He was suceeded in the representation of the
family by the sisters of the 4th Duke. Of these the yoimger,
Elizabeth, Countess de la Warr, was created a peeress in her
own right as Lady Buckhurst, from the original property in
Sussex where the early Tudor Sackvilles had lived. It was this
lady’s fourth son who succeeded to the Knole property and who
was created Lord Sackville. The present peer is the fourth of the
line, but the family name is Sackville-West, so that the family is
Sackville through the female line, just as the Churchills are
Churchills through the female line. The niece of the present peer
is Miss Victoria Sackville-West the celebrated writer, who has
produced many works of literature and among these has applied
her talents to the story of Knole. Not only is she gifted as an
author but she has lived in and loved Knole. She is married to
Sir Harold Nicolson, Lord Camock’s son, and their younger son
is that very brilliant and gifted politician and business man,
Nigel Nicolson, who in 1952 was elected M.P. for Bournemouth.
He is a partner in the publishing house of Weidenfeld and
Nicolson.
Literary talent abounds in this family, for the son and heir of
the present Lord Sackville, the Hon. Edward Sackville-West is
an author of note. Then too. Lady Margaret Sackville, the 3rd
daughter of the 7th Earl de la Warr is a gifted poetess. It would
seem that the heritage of the famous Thomas Sackville has
passed to his descendants in the tenth generation.
How very different would have been the manner of describing
this famous house and family 100 years ago or even 50 years
back. Then they would have been in the midst of their greatness
and would have been looked upon as firmly seated in their
properties and .their ancestral glory. Now well within the span
of a moderate lifetime they have seen their heritage pass to the
keeping of trusts and institutions well enough in their way but
not exactly proper representatives of the greatness of the past.
Chapter ten
BEAVERBROOK
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
T he house of Aitken and the house of Sackville — certainly no
aristocracy in the world could show a greater contrast with¬
in the same noble framework. There are people who cast scorn
on the British principle of enoblement. ‘Where is your King
now?* was the rhetorical question of the ex-Kaiser, to be fol¬
lowed by what he considered a crushing remark, ‘I thought that
he was yachting with his grocer." But Edward VII as the King
of all the Britons had the right to bestow a title upon whom he
pleased. He did not have to study protocol or chamberlains’
lists, he gave the title if he pleased or if his ministers advised
that he should do so. So the grocer Sir Thomas Lipton was
created a baronet, and in due course many other persons who
on the Continent would be considered unfit for noble honours
likewise received, and do receive to this day, honours from the
Fountain of Honours, the Sovereign. That is, in Britain, honours
are still bestowed in large measure by a Sovereign who pos¬
sesses the tiirone of his or her own ancestor, whereas on the
Continent there is usually no throne left and consequently no
aristocracy to squabble and argue over the matter.
It is said that Lord Beaverbrook is not interested in titles and
that he despises them, in short that he wishes diat he had never
accepted his peerage and gone into the nobility of Britain. This
rumour is probably only one of the numerous tales which gather
around a great man. Max Aitken, as the young Canadian mil¬
lionaire, and as M.P. for Ashton-imder-Lyme, all at the age of
169
170
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
31, accepted a knighthood in 1911, a baronetcy in 1916, and a
peerage in 1917. He presumably knew what he was doing, he
has usually done so throughout his career. He has a son and
tliree grandsons in the line of succession to his baronetcy and
barony and thus has founded a new noble house, which in an¬
other hundred years will rank with the greatest in our history.
It may be worth while to say something about the alleged regrets
of the Beaver that he ever accepted a peerage, because, say some
critics, he wanted to be Prime Minister. If he ever did nourish
such an idea, he might well not have found his title an obstacle
in the way. Beaverbrook’s earlier days in politics when he was
engaged so closely in the overthrow of the Asquith administra¬
tion, saw the progress to great place of a peer, Lord Curzon,
who should have been Prime Minister after the death of Bonar
Law, but who was denied the leadership of the Conservative
party by the intervention of Balfour (later himself a peer) with
the Sovereign. Just why Curzon should not have become Prime
Minister is not very clear. A peer Premier cannot be present in
the Commons but then there have been many peer Premiers so
that one would suppose the Commons to have grown used to the
habit. As for ability Curzon had it every time over his success¬
ful rival, Stanley Baldwin. Curzon had held place after place in the
government including the supreme position of Viceroy of India,
and that at a time when India required very careful handling.
With this example before him Beaverbrook could hardly have
concluded that a peer was necessarily invalidated as a con¬
testant for the post of Premier. In fact as every good observer
of politics knows, a peer is not barred from being Premier by
any law but only by a ridiculous modern convention.
Right at the beginning of the Beaverbrook story we are con¬
fronted with a mystery which is all the more remarkable because
of the huge publicity which has attended the Beaver for many
years. Put bluntly, where did his money come from? A man who
can be a millionaire at the age of 30 is a remarkable phenomenon
in any society but a man who comes to the fore financially with¬
out any of the ordinary success stories attached to him is a much
more remarkable phenomenon. There are innumerable cases o
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
171
rich men who started \vith little or nothing and one has only to
think of Ford in America or Nuffield in Britain to remember in¬
stances where the rise to wealth and fame is a real romance. But
in cases such as those just quoted, one man became rich because
he made motorcars cheaper than any one else had ever done,
and turned them out in huge quantities, while the otlier progress¬
ed from a small cycle shop to a similar production of cars. We
know what they did, and although this does not lessen the great¬
ness of the acliievement there is at least no mystery about it.
But a great and wealthy man for whose rise there is no adequate
explanation is surely the most remarkable feature in biographies
in an age when everytliing is documented. How did Beaverbrook
become wealthy? No account of his career ever gives us the
answer and this goes as much for his latest biographer as for
every other. Mr. Driberg in his interesting life of Beaverbrook
has a little to say on the matter. He gives us about four pages
out of a total of 250, and those four pages convey the impression
of having been introduced because the author felt that he must
say something on the subject. We are told in Driberg’s book of
the formation of trusts in Canada, of various obscure intrigues,
of a deal when the enemies of the rising Beaverbrook had con¬
siderable influence on the Bank of Montreal and might have
denied him financial backing from that institution. Beaver-
brook’s answer was to turn to London and to make his first
English visit. He secured the financial backing which he need¬
ed. We hear too that great odium was created in Canada over
some of these trust deals — monopolizations would be a better
term than trusts — and that for a time Canada was well glad
to be free of the Aitken presence. We hear that the appointment
of Beaverbrook as official Canadian eyewitness in France in the
first World War did much to soften Canadian resentment to¬
wards him.
Yet after all this (only four pages anyway) we have no real
e.xplanation. Here is a wonderful field for the inquirer. The
research worker who can solve the problem of how the Beaver¬
brook fortune originated will have tackled the most difficult
question of all in the newspaper world. If, as Mr. Driberg tells
172
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
us, the Canadians were displeased with Beaverbrook in his ear¬
lier days, and if, as everyone knows, he has created enemies in
the course of his career, what a wonderful story to have invited
hostile comment there would have been in the rise of the young
Aitken. So far from any such story appearing in the world’s
press, the feeling, such as it once was in Canada, has now so
much declined that Beaverbrook can reside in the province of
New Brunswick and act the part of a fairy godfather to the neigh¬
bourhood, having been Chancellor of the University and dis¬
pensing gifts which make him a revered figure in the district If
this is the transformation in Canada, there is no hope that any¬
one is going to be able to imearth a discreditable story at this
time of day about the Beaverbrook fortune. If such a story had
existed it must have come out by now and would have been
certain to have had an echo in Driberg’s book. In Mr. Robert
Harling’s clever novel The Paper Palace there is a story about a
newspaper proprietor who made a sudden rise to fame and for¬
tune from beginnings as obscure and penurious as those of
Beaverbrook. His employees wonder about it, until at last one
clever editor manages to unearth the grim secret and to black¬
mail his chief. No one will ever succeed in any exploit of this
nature in the Beaverbrook story and any resemblance in Har¬
ling’s novel to Beaverbrook can be dismissed.
So the curious mystery remains — how did the Beaverbrook
millions originate? It seems that there were deals in Canada
which involved the formation of large amalgamations, and this in
the days when various Canadian industries were in an inchoate
and unbalanced condition. The name of cement is mentioned in
this connection. The basic problem is however, how did the
young Aitken acquire the first capital to start any deals at all?
When he did start, how did he, the imtutored rustic from the
backwoods, overcome the hardened capitalists of Canada, and
obtain a loan from British bankers? A veil of impenetrable dark¬
ness falls over these questions. One can understand the possi¬
bility of success in operations after the beginnings have^ pros¬
pered, but how came that initial success? As Beaverbrook s foes
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
173
have not answered these questions and as he has not seen fit
to enlighten us, we can only pose the problem which gains in
fascination from the impossibility of ever securing an answer
to it.
There is something intriguing in the position of the Beaver in
the British peerage. I think that to many people who are not
used to seeing and hearing him, there must have been a great
surprise in his t^vo television appearances. The former of these
was some four years ago in connection with the thirtieth anni¬
versary of the death of Lord Northcliffe. Most of us are used,
and too well used, to the sort of panegyric which seems always to
attend the obituary or anniversary notice of any great person.
No matter how much backbiting and calumnious whispering
there has been against him while he lived, the obituarists seem
obsessed with the principle of nil de mortuis nisi bonum. This
is a very good principle if one has been practising Cliristian
charity habitually but it sits ill upon those who, having no real
belief in speaking no ill of persons while they live, are yet afraid
of or hypocritical about them when dead. For this reason the
public appraiser of the great is usually suspect.
To all such viewers the appearance of Lord Beaverbrook to
speak of his friend Northcliffe must have come as a tremendous
shock. Straight into our homes came a man who had been just
announced and who then was left alone in tire studio. The studio
looked like an ordinary room, with a table, desk and bowl of
flowers, and the speaker was by himself. To those who knew him
it was quite impossible to imagine that the Beaver would submit
to B.B.C. interviewing. But that was not the main impression.
At once he came to talk with us. He did not shuffle, or betray
any sign of nervousness, in fact he acted just as he does in
ordinary conversation, he seemed to be talking with his audience
while at the same time talking at them. He described the experi¬
ences which he had had with Northcliffe, his journey down to
Thanet to see Northcliffe and his consultations with him. In
those days one gathered that of the two great publicists. Beaver-
brook had been in the position of a learner. Apart from the
details of the picture however, what really emerged was the
174
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
brilliance of the speaker and the freshness of his approach. Too
many public men are insufferably dull and wedded to the
prosaic and ordinary phrase.
Two more years were to pass before Beaverbrook again ap¬
peared upon the television screen. This time in 1954 it was in
Speaking Personally’ the B.B.C. programme in which various
persons were brought before the British pubhc. In Lord Beaver-
brook’s case he was presented in his great room in Cherkley
Court in Surrey, and spoke at once as though we were all in the
room with him. He spoke rather sadly as if he were thinking
over former days with regret at what might have been. He took
us back over the past and with special reference to the Premiers
whom he remembered and who might have given us Empire
unity. Asquith, Lloyd George, Bonar Law, Baldwin, Churchill,
he spoke of them all. Of Bonar Law he spoke with the affection
which he has always expressed for his friend. But none of them,
whether they were friends or political enemies, had done much
for the Empire, the recurrent theme of Beaverbrook’s life. And
now he was alone there in his room, with the memories of the
past falling around him like leaves from a dying tree. That
evening there was to be a celebration of his birthday, his 75th,
and a cake was to be cut. At the end of his talk there was a
moment when Beaverbrook mentioned this and said that he
must not be late. T am never late’ he added and then went out
of the door, which slowly closed behind him. It was a piece of
supreme artistry and a fitting conclusion to the talk. In that
there had been an infinite pathos and sadness, and witlial a
spirit of humility. He had instanced the career of Churchill as
an example of the value of perseverance, for people had not liked
Churchill and yet he had won through. There was such a homely
touch about this note that it went right to people’s hearts.
A most impressive speaker, was the thought of the majority
of us, and to many it must have seemed that a great actor had
been lost to politics and the press in Lord Beaverbrook. The
great point about the numerous gifts of Beaverbrook is that they
are developments of his own effort and personality and not the
result of careful training by great masters in each particular
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
175
sphere. It is doubtful I should say that he has ever had a lesson
in speechmaking or histrionics, yet there are very few public
speakers as effective as he. 'I swear I use no art at all'. Then this
is the perfection of art or else its complete absence, in short,
untutored genius. There are many persons who are spoken of as
orators who are really great writers of speeches. The only person
who can really be described as an orator is the speaker who
rises to his feet with few notes and who goes on to speak from
his heart. ‘Out of tlie heart proceed all manner of evils’, but be¬
cause of this we must not deny to a Hitler tlie power of oratory.
Beaverbrook as a speaker must be seen to be believed and be
heard to be felt. I heard him speak on his beloved subject of the
Empire, its unity and its trade. In a vast hall, crammed to capa¬
city, he has held a crowd of people, not by any means all friend¬
ly, with the force of his oratory. When he is on the platform he
does all those things which the elocution class speakers have
been taught to avoid. He shuffles about, he moves his hands and
his body to give emphasis to his remarks. The classic stance of
hands behind the back or at the side he eschews completely.
His voice is bad, it has no smoothness, no grace; if in the Law
Courts counsel is spoken of as possessing a golden voice, tlie
analogy of Beaverbrook’s would be that of iron. The voice is
raised and a shout comes forth for extra emphasis. The table is
thumped, and glasses and books shake and rattle. The speaker
goes on too long, according to the book of rules, the speaker
does not endeavour to introduce graces or humour into his talk
unless it suits him to be humorous.
How then does Beaverbrook hold an audience? Because from
first to last the speech on politics or economics is made >Aith
evangelical fervour. It comes unmistakably from the heart and
for that reason it has appeal which is utterly wanting in the
polished and carefully thougt-out orations written up by those
who often pass as orators but who succeed in emptying halls
rather than filling them.
Here comes in the principle of ancestry and background. It is
useless to adopt the attitude that heredity does not coimt. It
does and it comes into everyone’s life. When people denounce
176
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
heredity they really mean that they don’t have Norman barons
or Plantaganet princes in their ancestry but they forget that this
does not mean that they are without the influence of heredity.
No one can escape from the influence of the past So with Bea-
verbrook the most potent factor is that his father was a Scottish
clergyman, and he is a son of the Manse. When the late Ramsay
Muir subjected Beaverbrook’s theories on the economics of the
British Empire to much unnecessary abuse, and descended to
personalities, he was rebuked by Beaverbrook on the ground
that he did not expect a son of the Manse to have so far for¬
gotten his manners. Beaverbrook’s father was the Rev. William
Cuthbert Aitken, the minister of Newcastle, New Brunswick,
Canada, who emigrated from Scotland to Canada. He was the
son of Robert Aitken, of Silver Mine, Torpichen, Linlithgowshire,
who was a gardener. Probably research would give us a few
more generations of the line, of hardworking Scottish peasants,
honest and simple. The Rev. William Aitken rose out of this
environment by being able to profit from the excellent system of
education which prevails in Scotland. He was the ‘lad of pairts
without whom the Beaverbrook career would not have occurred.
If he had stayed in Scotland, then Beaverbrook would perhaps
never have had his chance. He might have grown up in Scot¬
land as an agitator in a working class neighbourhood.
To his son, the Rev. William bequeatlied more than the great
chance of life in Canada, a freer environment; from his father.
Lord Beaverbrook inherited gifts of sterling value. A training in
the more rigorous side of character, a predilection to forceful
oratory of the old-fashioned pulpit type, and a deep knowledge
of the Bible. Stories of Beaverbrook’s Biblical learning are legion;
perhaps the best is that of the joke made by one of his Daily
Express staff about one of the great figures of the Old Testa¬
ment. Followed a cable from Beaverbrook: ‘The Bible is the
WORD OF God, I will not have the heroes of the Old Testament
RIDICULED.’ Again and again in his speeches, Beaverbrook quotes
the Bible with all the ease of early knowledge. It is something
tliat in the Dady Express in a leader there can be a quotation
from the Book of Kings: 'Are not Abana and Pharfar, nvers of
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
177
Damascus better tlian all the rivers of Israel?’ (With of course the
obvious analogy, are not the St Lawrence and the Murray bet¬
ter than all the Rhines and Danubes of Europe?). Yet before
there is ridicule, is anyone able to say that such quotations from
the Book of Life are likely to be found in the Continental Press?
When Beaverbrook gave in his evidence to the Royal Com¬
mission on the Press he reminded the members of one of the
exhortations of the Shorter Catechism, that we were intended in
this world to increase our own and others’ wealth. This must
have been an uncomfortable reminder to those on the Commiss¬
ion who had swallowed Socialist principles as to the wickedness
of gaining wealth.
All other matters are subsidiary in an account of Beaverbrook’s
career to his love of Empire and his lifelong advocacy of Empire
union. He is a Canadian, although Uke most Scottish Canadians
he does not forget his Scottish origin. He is a Canadian and as
such he thinks far more of the Empire than do people in this
country. He has always been an Empire Crusader. It was in the
darkest days of British economic distress that he launched his
Empire Free Trade Crusade. In 1930 he began with the power¬
ful instruments at his command in his own newspapers and with
the help of Lord Rothermere, to instil into the British people the
principles of Empire cohesion and self-help. He succeeded in a
very moderate manner. He brought that very remarkable states¬
man, Mr., later Earl, Baldwin to realize that the new movement
might well draw away votes from the Conservatives and by
splitting the Conservative poll, let in Labour or Liberal Can¬
didates. So far therefore Baldwin was willing to go along with
Beaverbrook. A truce was patched up between them and Bald¬
win agreed to accept some measure of Empire Free Trade. Then
Beaverbrook discovered that Baldwin was not really carrying
out the agreement and war began between them. One of tire
most remarkable phenomena in modem politics has been the
failure of vast press interests to overcome the plans and wishes
of one not very well endowed politician. Baldwin was faced with
the opposition of Beaverbrook, Rothermere, the Labour and
Liberal parties, the latter headed by the formidable Lloyd
178
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
George, and by dissension in his own party. Yet Baldwin sur¬
vived and retired when he wanted to and not before. When the
economic crisis had reached its worst phase in 1931 the incom¬
petent Labour administration of Ramsay Macdonald was forced
to give way and a National Government was formed. This
government negotiated among other things a series of agree¬
ments with the governments of the British Dominions at Ottawa.
The agreements which constituted Imperial Preference in the
modern form are with us still. It has always been the wish of the
United States government to do away with the British Empire and
of course the Ottawa Agreements were not welcome to the
Americans. Fortunately for their outlook there came the war of
1939 in which the British were involved from the very beginning
and were compelled to shoot away their overseas investments
and their export trade, before the Americans were forced by the
Japanese attack at Pearl Harbour into a war in which they had
no choice but to fight At the end of the six years struggle in
1945 the U.S.A. emerged as the greatest power in the world,
and as the price of financial aid to Britain the policy of Imperial
Preference had to be gradually abolished, and of necessity the
Americans interfered in the conduct of British government in
India and other eastern countries. There have been many coun¬
tries conquered by others in the history of the world and many
great empires have been overthrown by others, but there has
been only one mighty empire which has been given away by its
own citizens, and that after a war in which all the enemies of
that empire were beaten to the ground. In the first world war
we preserved our heritage at a terrible price, the loss of our
rising generation, of men typified by Rupert Brooke, JuHan Gren¬
fell, Warneford and many others; we came out of the war with
a burden of debt to the Yank, and between the wars we never
succeeded in keeping our unemployed at less than one
Yet we did recover and in 1939 the British Navy was still the
worlds largest fleet and Britain was still the worlds creditor
nation, with the vastest empire seen in the history o man.
influence of Beaverbrook was cast always into ® ^ ® ,
strengtliening the Empire. He was not interested m po
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
179
economic theories, such as the redistribution of wealth; obviously
there is little point in arguing about wealth and its redistribution
unless the wealth exists, and if finance is to be subjected to weird
experiments it needs to be greatly increased in strength to stand
up to them. Beaverbrook advocated closer imperial unity, Empire
Free Trade, and isolationism from Europe. It is easy to say now
tliat this policy is mistaken, but it may be remembered that tlie
only free and steadfast allies whom we possessed from 1939 to
1945 were found in the British Empire; that tlie only real revival
of British trade came from the time of the Ottawa Agreements,
when at last this country for the first time since 1860 had some¬
thing to bargain with.
While both sides in the war of 1939-45 were deserted by a
Latin ally, and while the British were reinforced by the Russians
and the Americans only because the latter had to fight, the
Australians, Canadians, South Africans, New Zealanders and
Indians, were fighting and toiling at our side in every theatre of
war from the beginning.
The Ottawa Agreements did not represent the full fruit of
Empire policy which Beaverbrook wished for, but they were
something which counted for a great deal and which must have
been of value because of the dislike which they excited in
American breasts. The G.A.T.T. (General Agreement on Tariffs
and Trade), which was brought out of the deliberations of the
United Nations, and to which Britain became a signatory, was
the enemy of Imperial Preference. The British Empire in the
American view had at last been dismembered, and it only re¬
mained for Imperial Preference to be done away with.
It is not difficult to envisage Beaverbrook's feeling of bitter¬
ness and loneliness as he looks back upon the failure of so many
efforts to unite the Empire. The British are the only people who
having a great empire are not proud of it and do not care what
happens to it. Occasionally someone comes from abroad to this
country and endeavours to awaken the British people to a sense
of their own inheritance. The most that such a hardy soul will
get for his pains is a mild amount of applause. He will not get
any active support Some years ago I became interested in the
180
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
Empire Youth Movement. I remember attending a conference of
youth workers who represented various movements and who
were being asked to co-ordinate their efforts on behalf of the
youth of the Empire. I have never attended such a frustrating
meeting. One could plead with fervour the necessity of standing
together against the forces of Communism, but at the last one
found that the minds of the delegates were taken up with mat¬
ters of routine and procedure. They were concerned not with
what would happen to the British Empire but with how the
proper authorities in their own small movements were to be
approached.
It is precisely because the efforts of Beaverbrook have met
with much the same attitude on the part of those whom he has
addressed that the note of sadness crept in to the television
speech which he made in ‘Speaking Personally*. His Empire
Crusade has not met with anything resembling the success that
it deserved. He is very largely a voice crying in the wilderness.
It is pleasanter to turn to his undoubted success in the field of
journalism. If the Harmsworths were the great influence in re¬
moulding newspapers so that they were to be worthy of the
modern age and not mere replicas of the sheets which came out
fiom the times of Defoe and Steele, then the greatest learner
from the Harmsworths was Lord Beaverbrook. The facts speak
for themselves. In 1913 he acquired the principal interest in the
Daily Express, but it was not until the period of 1918 that he
began to take an active control of that newspaper. From then
on he took an ever greater interest, not the interest which a
rich owner talces in a new toy, but the interest of one who is
himself a craftsman. As Lord Camrose remarked in his survey of
the British Press, 'Lord Beaverbrook is still the controlling owner,
the master mind and the final arbiter of all that affects e
Express and the newspapers to which it is allied. In 191 e
sale of the Express was about 270,000 copies per day. By l^u
sales had doubled and they have never gone back ^til at las
they reached the region of over 4 millions copies a day. llus is
a phenomenal rise and is primarily due to the efforts of Beaver¬
brook. His restless energy forged the means of success, and
THE HOUSE OF AITKES
181
nothing was allowed to stand in his way. One feature of liis
work is to be seen in the number of distinguished joiumalists
whom he has trained, yet he himself is largely self-trained as a
joiumalist. The same zest for his work which has made him such
a formidable and exhilarating speaker made him also a supreme
master of the journalistic craft. There are of course many who
sneer at the popular press, and others who deplore its sensation¬
alism, yet what would reading of a lighter kind be if all the
national newspapers were what is known as ‘responsible. There
are many people whose sole diet of newspaper reading is The
Times. How they do it no one can say, for such a course of
reading must be of ineffable dullness. After a course of what is
knoNvn as serious newspaper reading, one is only too glad to get
back to the popular press. In any event all serious students of
current affairs and all who are concerned with the psychology
of the nation must notice the Daily Express. Any paper wliich
has a readership of something like 10 millions (counting the num¬
ber of readers per copy) must be a potent influence. This vast
machine has been created out of a tiny circulation of little
more than a quarter of a million. This is one of the achievements
of Beaverbrook and another is the e.xistence of the Sunday Ex¬
press. This paper was bom in 1920. One of the most interesting
features in connection with the Sunday Express is the reader-
ship which it has among the higher classes — precisely tliose
persons who are the subject matter of this book. In aristocratic
homes, in castle and manor houses throughout Britain, the Sun¬
day Express is one of the most favoured newspapers among the
peerage and baronetcy. I had an amusing instance of this some
years ago. When I had nearly completed my work on the cur¬
rent Burke’s Landed Gentry, I was interviewed by the Sunday
E.xpress. Something in the article led readers to suppose that my
work was not completed, and in the course of the week following
that in which the review of Landed Gentry appeared in tlie
Sunday Express, I received 200 letters. So great was the interest
shown by the writers of these letters that I was compelled to
accept many of their pedigrees and as they could not be accom¬
modated in the main book I had to bring out a supplement, a
182
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
separate volume which carried over 100 pedigrees.
Undoubtedly the Sunday Express is one of the liveliest of the
Sunday papers and contains many exposures of current matters
which would otherwise be hushed up.
A speaker of magnetism, a newspaper chief who not only
commands but also instructs and exemplifies what he wants,
Beaverbrook has many side talents which he seldom uses. He
has written a number of witty, well written books, but it is a
pity that he has not produced more. His Politicians and the War
is an outstanding study. His Politicians and the Press, Canada in
Flanders, and other books are studies of importance to the
historian of the first part of the 20th century. The books are in¬
teresting to read as well as being valuable studies.
Britain has the habit of breaking the hearts of her best and
greatest sons, but of calling them in without any hesitation when
the time of crisis threatens. A Churchill is left in the wilderness
for eleven years and is howled down by the very House of Com¬
mons which later fawns upon him and accords the most ridicu¬
lous and preposterous admiration to what are really somewhat
juvenile and sometimes banal remarks. Similarly, a Beaverbrook
is allowed to expend his enormous energies and for the re.sult to
be ridiculed by demagogues of the stamp of Bevan. Yet in 1940
when Britain was threatened more terribly than she had been
for many centuries, with the enemy only 20 miles away,
Churchill was called to form a government and to Beaver¬
brook went one of the most arduous of ministerial appointments,
that of Minister for Aircraft Production. He held this post for
one year, enough to give us the planes to sustain our airforce. If
the British airforce was good in quality in 1940 it was undoubtedly
poor in quantity and as continual battle wastage took toll of our
numbers, we should have eventually been exhausted in the battle
with the Luftwaffe if there had not been a man of almost super¬
human drive in charge of the production of planes. The anec¬
dotes which circulated in the Air Ministry in 1940 41 as to
doings at M.A.P. were sometimes highly diverting, provided one
was not the subject of them. The Minister seemed not to sleep.
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
183
The fearful energy and push with which his staff in tlic Express
building were only too familiiir, were now transferred to the
quiet purlieus of Whitehall. CivU Serx'ants who had never known
anything more drastic than the curtailment of sick leave were
now exposed to calls wliich might occur at any hour of the day
or night. It was related of one senior Civil Servant that the
Minister kept him up normally to three in the morning and yet
expected to see him perfectly fresh and unconcened at nine
o’ clock the same morning. Favourite procedures were curtailed
or circumvented. Strange and uncouth language was heard in
places where hitliero only tlie most stilted euphemisms had been
employed.
Still, we got the planes, but perhaps it was better for every¬
one that after the crucial twelve months had passed. Beaver-
brook should have become Minister of Supply (1941—42) and
tlicn for the rest of the war. Lord Privy Seal, a post in wliich
like Jimmy Thomas before him he no doubt found tlie duties
extremely heavy.
There is something peculiarly fascinating in tlie display of
energy on the part of such a man. It is impossible to predict how
and where the force will show itself, but tlie miracle is usually
the same; a man of such overflowing powers nvUI show them early
and continue to demonstrate them right into old age. The sort
of mentality which is interested in carpet slippers and in potter¬
ing around a patch of garden in the early tliirties can have no
conception of the apparently feverish, yet in fact completely
calm and controlled force, of men like Beaverbrook. They rise
above the ordinary limitations of humanity and the body is bent
and forced into conformity with the wishes of the soul. In no
respect does the remarkable quality of triumphing over bodily
limitations show itself more than in the case of Beaverbrook.
In 1930 there occurred a momentous by-election in Fulham.
Up to that time there had been a number of campaigns
in various by-elections in which the Empire Free Trade
candidates of Beaverbrook had put up against all comers
including the official Conservative candidates. But in Fulham the
184
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
official Conservative, Sir Cyril Cobb, was ready to accept the
Beaverbrook mandate. Sir Cyril had been member for Fulham
West for several years and had only lost the seat to a Labour
candidate at the 1929 election. The Labour candidate had gone
and tlien in 1930 a by-election became necessary. It so happen¬
ed that in Fulham Lord Beaverbrook possessed a house called
the Vineyard. This house stood in a part of Fulham which was
usually regarded as a dead loss by Labour canvassers, Hurling-
ham, which many people to this day still imagine to be in Putney
because many of its telephone numbers are on the Putney ex¬
change. Hurlingham in 1930 was very different from what it is
to-day. Then the manificent grounds of the great Hurhng-
ham club were the centre of many outstanding social
events, including some splendid polo matches. It was nothing
unusual to see a crowned head or other royal personage at the
polo games. Around the polo club there were roads of a gra¬
dually declining social importance and there were several oldish
houses which were reminders from the Victorian period of the
days when socially important people had lived in Hurlingham.
One such house was Vineyard. Its ownership has not so far as
I know been mentioned in any of the accounts of the Beaver’s
activities. This is probably the reason for the occupation of the
house. It was near enough in London to be extremely useful for
any public man who wanted to be close to the seat of govern¬
ment and of business affairs, and yet not to be pestered by un¬
due publicity or attention.
During the 1930 by-election, of course, the ownership of
Vineyard must have been a godsend to Beaverbrook. One of his
earliest appearances on the side of Cobb was marked by his
declaration that he was a Fulham man himself and therefore had
a claim to speak to the people of the district. ‘The school chil¬
dren in New King’s Road wake me up in the morning.’
No speaker could have thrown himself into the election contest
with more zest than Beaverbrook. He was everywhere in all
sorts of obscure halls where the local vicars were only too happy
to be able to preside at meetings where a real lord — Canadian
or not did not matter — was the principal speaker. And speak
THE HOUSE OF AITKEN
185
Beaverbrook did with immense energy and witli an earnestness
which had the revivalist fer\'our about it.
Yet his principal work for the cause of Cobb, and of course of
Empire Free Trade, was not done on platforms but in the garden
at Hurlingham were he received visitors and where also he
thought out his speeches and his campaigns. It was in his
garden that he spent many hours and where he seemed to be
immune from the ordinary wants of humanity. Meals were
brought into the garden which was large enough to be secluded
without being entirely innaccessible to view. Meals were taken
out again, untasted. At one time his daughter came to see Iiim.
She had a very unsocial lunch for while she partook of refresh¬
ment her father continued to read his papers without doing more
tlian drink a glass of some medicinal substance. Her presence did
not seem particularly welcome and after a while her handbag
was thrown on to the ground while papers of importance were
brought into line.
Hours were passed in the Vineyard garden sometimes with the
Beaver sitting or lying full lengtli on his couch while he read
or meditated. Ever and anon there would be a cry of ‘Albert’
and a harassed looking man servant would emerge from the back
of the house and come hurrying towards the ‘governor’, as his
servants often call him. 'rhis was Beaverbrook’s right hand per¬
sonal servant who was expected very often to anticipate his
master s wishes. As Albert found it very difficult to hear the
repeated summonses Beaverbrook provided himself wth a bell
with which he summoned Albert whenever he needed him. This
was, on an average, every five minutes.
The garden was the scene of more active labours. The crux of
the problem in West Fulham was that the strong Labour interest
(they have held the seat since 1945, although it was formerly a
Conservative centre) would be sure to retain the seat if there
were again to be a Liberal candidate, for in 1929 it was con¬
sidered that the intervention of a Liberal had had the effect of
allo^ving the Labour candidate to get in. In the early stages of
the election campaign it was not absolutely decided that there
would not be a Liberal candidate. A local man’s name was
186
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
mentioned as a possible intervener. Before Nomination day this
matter had to be settled in the interest of Sir Cyril Cobb. It was
a task of great delicacy to persuade the Liberal potential can¬
didate that he would best serve Liberalism by standing down in
order that a protectionist Tory should win the seat. Beaverbrook
had him to call upon him and it was amusing to watch persuasion
at work, almost like watching a film of the old silent days
without accompanying captions. The pair walked up and down
the garden, they sat on the sofa together, they talked earnestly
and they debated. For hours it seemed that the conference
would continue, but the end came with the would-be Liberal
candidate arriving on the platform in support of Cobb.
The campaign attracted great attention in the press quite apart
from the Beaverbrook section of it. Political leaders watched
the election and speculated on its progress. Then came the
night of the result. Cobbs majority was 200. But it was an¬
other victory for Empire preference and Beaverbrook had the
‘Glory, glory. Hallelujah’ attitude. Straightway he forsook the
Vineyard save for brief visits which for aught I know he may
still be paying there.
The heir to the barony and baronetcy is the elder and only
surviving son of Lord Beaverbrook, the Hon. John William Max¬
well Aitken, who served with great distinction in the Au.riliary
Air Force in the last war. He was a Group Captain and won the
D.S.O. and D.F.C. He has also had political experience, having
been M.P. for Holborn for five years after the war. His position
as second to his father in the Beaverbrook Newspapers Group
guarantees the successful continuance of the great house which
his father founded.
Chapter eleven
LEICESTER
THE HOUSE OF COKE
O ne of the show places of Norfolk is the famous Holkham
Hall and on visiting days the park is full of cars and
coaches converging upon the house. Holkham stands upon a
slight rise looking towards a valley on the other side of which is
a tall obelisk. I do not think that anyone could describe the ex¬
terior as beautiful. It is too much laid out in formal lines and
there is a plainess about it which is increased at the present day
by the fact that there is a yellow ochre tint upon it. The build¬
ing dates from the middle of the 18th century when Sir Thomas
Coke was created Earl of Leicester in 1744. The present Earl¬
dom dates from the time of his great-nephew Thomas William
Coke who was his heir through the female line and whose
father Mr Wenman Roberts had assumed the name and arms of
Coke upon succeeding to the Holkham estates. The interior of
the house, though it is filled with magnificent furniture and art
treasures, has all the appearance of a museum; as one enters,
duly paying one’s fee, one is met by the sight of a gallery of
statues with rails in front of them. The huge crowds of visitors
and the necessarily slow progress which one makes, all help to
lead one to forget that this is still one of the stately homes of Eng¬
land with the accent on the word home, for the fifth Earl of
Leicester (of the 1837 creation) has Holkham for his principal
seat Of the immense wealth of the interior, some who have not
visited die house may be able to judge if they have seen the
splendours of the book and manuscript collection from Holkham
187
188
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
which has been displayed in the British Museum.
Yet there is no family in the British aristocracy which has
more claim to renown for varied and intrinsic ability than that
of the Cokes of Holkham. The origin of the family is not among
the most ancient in the aristocracy; it goes back only some four
and a half centuries to about 1480, when Robert Coke of East
Ruston in Norfolk, who is described as a gentleman, married Agnes
the daughter and heiress of Robert Crispyng. The son of this
couple was another Robert Coke and his son, also Robert Coke,
was the father of one of the most celebrated lawyers ever to be
produced by the English Bar. This was Sir Edward Coke, whose
portrait in his robes as Lord Chief Justice of the Common Pleas or
of King’s Bench (he held both posts) looks down forbiddingly
upon the student of the Inner Temple as he eats his lunches and
dinners. For Sir Edward Coke, known more familiarly as Coke
upon Littleton, is one of tlie greatest ornaments of that famous
Inn of Court. A fierce old man he looks, without any of the milk
of human kindness. From what we know of him he was guilty in
his daily life as a judge, of faults, almost crimes, of which for-
timately no member of the English judicial system has been
guilty for over two centuries. If we read Coke’s interchanges
with Sir Walter Raleigh, or with some of the conspirators in the
Gunpowder Plot, we shall condemn him as a man worthy to
rank with Judge Jeffreys, and say that he was a sycophantic
fawner upon that monstrosity of kingship, James I, just as Jef¬
freys fawned upon the hapless James II. Yet this same man
who appears by his life, at least the earlier portion of it, to have
been the perfect comtier-judge, was in his latter days among
those strenuous opponents of the humbug of Divine Monarchy
which Charles I was trying in a muddled manner to set up in
England. It would be easy of course to find a facile explanation
of Coke’s change of outlook; it is a pity that neither Macaulay
nor Belloc have left us a description of Coke, for their pieces
would have been all blackness or all light with no intemediate
shades of grey. The old man of the Inner Temple has a ™ l^'^
and a commanding carriage; he does not look as though he held
his office purely at the bidding of Majesty. He served a master
THE HOUSE OF COKE
189
more imperious than any sovereign. The Common Law of Eng¬
land was his first love and his last In the name of tliat great
master, and not so much in tlie name of James I, he was prepared
to browbeat helpless prisoners and terrify juries into compliance
with the Royal will. But when that same Royal will tlireatened
tlie Common Law. Coke refused to yield. At the ripe age of 72
he was dismissed ignominiously from his post of Lord Chief
Justice of the King’s Bench. He was committed to the Tower
and dismissed from the Privy Council. No doubt James I, that
British Solomon who knew so e.Kcellently all that would have
qualified him to be head master of an Elizabethan Grammar
school, but nothing which fitted him to rule a great nation, no
doubt James thought that he had finished with Coke. He or at
any rate his son, Charles I, was very rapidly to find out his
mistake. Coke became the most uncompromising upholder of the
rights of the Commons and in 1628 he was elected M.P. for the
county of Buckingham. He was the strength of the opposition to
the unfettered Royal Prerogative; from Coke the leaders of the
Parliamentary party drew constant stores of precedents and
supplies of knowledge as to their rights and to the constitutional
position of the Sovereign.
It could be said that Coke changed his views because he lost
his job, but this would be very far wide of the mark. Coke’s
grandfather on the maternal side had been William Knightley,
an attorney of Norwich and it was perhaps from this source that
he derived his first impulse to the law. He remained a student
until he was 28 when he took his first case as a barrister. Law
students who are reading for the Bar may tliink it hard to be¬
lieve that anything can be worse than the studies which they
have to learn; yet four or five hundred years ago the Bar student
had infinitely more difficulties. For one thing all the pleadings
and most of the books were written in that weird jargon, law-
French or Norman French, which persisted in use in the English
Law Courts until 1732. Apart from this there were no such things
as aids for the student. Cases were very imperfectly reported
and instead of students’ manuals, the books which the learner was
expected to use were the same as those employed by the
190
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
practitioner. As one of Cokes biographers remarked: ‘The books
which he studied so steadily and so perseveringly, were of a
nature which almost defy the mental digestion of a modern
student. There were then no law books written with the elegance
of Blackstone’s Commentaries, or Feame’s Contingent Remain¬
ders. Every law authority was composed in the barbarous law
P'rench of the age, and Coke had to struggle to obtain knowledge
from such authors as Fleta, Britton, Hengham, and Littleton,
from the year books, and the reports of Plowden and Dyer.’
Coke must have been a man of outstanding mental toughness to
be able to digest such a mass of ungainly learning, but in so
doing he fell in love with the fabric of the Common Law. It
entered into the very fibre of his being. He could not conceive
of England without it. Perhaps to be able the better to get across
his feelings for the Common Law to younger men, Coke wrote
his famous Commentaries upon the Tenures of Lyttleton. This
has been described as the most profound work of humane
science in any language; a large claim but perhaps not as wide
as it seems. At the base of most disputes in England’s history
has lain the problem, who is to control the land? If this be so,
then the law relating to Real Property must be the most impor¬
tant feature of English study. Real Property. There in that term
lies the English appreciation of the things which really count.
Real Property as divorced from something insubstantial. It was
a bad day for England when we parted with the tangible and
substantial forms of real property for those of stocks and shares,
and other properties, not so solid. Coke came to know and love
the Common Law, as no one was to know it after him. When
James dismissed him from his offices, it was because he had
refused to bow to the Court of Chancery which he regarded as
an interloper and which interfered with the Common Law. He
felt in his bones that something was fundamentally wrong, and
against this he made his stand. It is to Coke and others that we
owe the existence of a law in England which is not that of Rome.
In the 16th century when other nations in Europe were turning
to the acceptance of the Roman law, it was due to the stand of
men like Coke that our own system of law was preserved. As it
THE HOUSE OF COKE
191
has turned out, the Common Law has become the legal system
of a large and influential part of the world.
Coke was educated at Norwich, then at Trinity College Cam¬
bridge, after which he went to the Inner Temple. He passed
through the then usual course of study of 8 years and was called
to the Bar at the age of 27. His biographers have been unable
to discover much in the way of detail of his early life, but they
have provided him with a pedigree which is supposed to meet
his subsequent greatness. To the outline which I have given
above they have added the details of an earlier line which might
have been connected with that of Sir Edward but of which there
is no proof.
From very early days in his career at the Bar, Coke had
accumulated landed property. His first marriage was to Bridget,
daughter and co-heiress of John Paston, of Huntingfield Hall,
Suffolk; he was the third son of Sir William Paston of Paston.
Thus Coke married into a family of great note in East Anglia.
His bride brought him a jointure, but almost as much as her for¬
tune, Coke wanted her lineage. Having little of his o\vn, Coke
wanted his wife's family to be outstanding. It was the same vrith
his second wife. She was Lady Elizabeth, daugliter of tlie first
Earl of Exeter, and widow of Sir William Hatton, Knight. He
had children by both his wives. He had property by tliem too,
and with this and the property left him by his father, together
with his own exertions, he acquired estates in his native Nor¬
folk, in Essex, in Dorset and in Buckinghamshire. His life took
on the usual form of the Elizabethan courtiers and lawyer’s. He
gathered wealth. There is much in Shakespeare’s plays about the
wise man of the world who garners property. Shakespeare him¬
self was a snob and a seeker after wealth. He preferred the
ownership of New Place in Stratford, as far as we can tell, to
tlie authorship of Hamlet, for while he cared about the owner¬
ship of New Place, he did not worry very much about what
happened to the plays.
Diuing the 30 years of Queen Elizabeth’s reign while Coke
was a barrister, he spent some of his time in practice at the Bar,
then as Solicitor General, and finally as Attorney General. It was
192
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
not unta the accession to the throne of James VI of Scotland
as James I of England that Cokes position came into the public
eye. The death of Queen Elizabeth must have been a terrible
thing for those vi'ho had grown old in her service. In one case
especially, that of Sir Walter Raleigh, we know that it meant the
difference behveen success and failure. T think but rawly of
thee was the sage remark of James I to Raleigh when he met
him. For a generous spirit like Raleigh, the advent of James I
was the sign that a lesser age had come. He was soon imprisoned
to please the Spaniards whom he had chatised in an earlier
period, and his very life was in danger.
Far otherwise was it with Coke. To him the coming of the new
king was a great gain. Under the haughty and discerning Eliza¬
beth, no one, not even a favourite was expected to be able to
slip past the scrutiny of the Queen and no one did. She evaluated
all alike, but in the time of her successor venal considerations and
vile habits were as likely as not to prove the passport to court
favour. Mr. George Vilbers passed in six years from a plain
esquire through all the grades of the peerage to become Duke
of Buckingham. He managed to get his mother made a countess
while titles were handed out to the rest of his family as easily
as though they were merely letters of credit. Only one of Vil-
liers’ sisters or brothers escaped a connection with the peerage
and this was his half sister Frances who died unmarried. Villiers
owed his advancement to his handsome person on which James I
used to like to loll and slobber. ‘Steenie’, James would exclaim,
this being his nickname for his favourite, ‘do you not think, you
and Baby Charles, that etc etc’, whatever sage proposition the
wisest fool in Christendom might be enunciating at the time.
This was the pass to which Majesty was reduced in Jacobean
times, enough to make Elizabeth turn in her grave. In such an
atmosphere almost anyone who was prepared to speak com¬
fortingly to the King and do what he wanted was sure of ad¬
vancement. Coke began by describing the Gunpowder Plot as
the greatest conspiracy ever made in England before the greatest
King who ever reigned in England, surely the most astounding
example of hyperbole in the English language! Such a man must
THE HOUSE OF COKE
193
be rewarded and he was very shortly appointed from being
Attorney General to Lord Chief Justice both of tire Comnion
Pleas and of the King’s Bench. His career until this date (1605—
06) is summed up in tlie great monument erected to his memory
in Tittleshall Chmch in Norfolk with his effigy in tlie Judge's
robes lying at full length, above him a canopy supported by two
marble pillars, on tlie top of which were four large figures. Be¬
tween the pillars were two marble tables the one inscribed in
Latin, the other in English. In the latter he is described in the
following terms: ‘A late Reverend Judge. E.xcellent in all learii-
ing, divine and humane. That for his own. this for his country’s
food, especially in the knowledge and practice of the municipal
laws of this kingdom, a famous Reader, a sound councillor; in his
younger years. Recorder of the cities of Norwich and London.
Ne.xt Solicitor General to Queen Elizabeth, and Speaker of the
Parliament in the 25 years of her reign. Afterwards Attorney to
the same Queen.’
With all his faults Coke had gone so deeply into tlie study of
the Common Law that he could not endure that a profane hand
should touch the Ark of the Covenant. All through the reign of
Elizabeth there had been rivalry betsveen Coke and the famous
Francis Bacon; the latter was a man of genius but this does not
always prove helpful in the rough and tumble of the courts,
especially in courts as brutal as those of the Elizabethan and
Stuart periods. No D.A. portrayed by Hollywood has ever brow¬
beaten witnesses or threatened a jury as Tudor lawyers were
wont to do. In such a contest the large views and cultured out¬
look of Bacon would cause him to lose before the narrower but
fiercer mind of Coke. Besides Bacon had been so imprudent, one
of the rare occasions when he was guilty of this fault, as to have
opposed Queen Elizabeth over the passage of a bill through tlie
Commons. That sealed his doom as regards preferment while she
lived, but with the advent of James, Bacon also managed to
secure advancement, though he was nearly 60 when he became
Lord High Chancellor and a peer. The wheel of fortune turned
full circle before Bacon triumphed over Coke. In brief, a contest
arose between the Court of the Lord Chancellor and the Court
194
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
of King’s Bench. As this account may otherwise be unintelligible
to the average reader, it will be as well to explain how the two
Courts came to be in conflict.
The legal history of England is summed up in the fact that
for many centuries there were two legal systems in the country.
One was that of Common Law which was administered by the
Royal Courts and which professed to administer either the law
as it had always been or at least the law as declared by Act of
Parliament. Should a man be dissatisfied with the decisions of
the ordinary law courts, he could have recourse to the King’s
Grace, in other words he could petition the King for redress of
wrong. The King referred the petition to the Chancellor who
acted as the Royal secretary. By this means there grew up a Court
of Chancery and there was naturally great jealousy between the
Common Law lawyers and those of the Chancellor’s court. It is
quite understandable that people should have been allowed to
petition the Sovereign when they felt that the Law Courts had
denied them justice but why it was necessary for two systems of
law to be allowed to grow up side by side in the same country is
surely a mystery. It was not until 1875—76 that the two systems
were finally merged, but by that time the distinction between
Law and Equity was so pronounced that to this day lawyers will
always refer to the law and/or equity of a subject.
One of the means by which conflict could come about be*
hveen the tu'o law courts lay in the habit of the Court of Chan¬
cery in issuing orders that a case which the Common Law Courts
had closed should be reopened. It thus could easily happen that
a person whom Coke had sent to prison could be released by a
mandamus from the Chancellor, or that a case which Coke
was considering could be removed from his court into that of the
Chancellor by a writ of certiorari issued by the latter. This is
described by one of Coke's biographers: ‘The dissensions arose
between the courts of King’s Bench and Chancery, regarding the
superior jurisdiction claimed over the former by the latter, even
to the power of reversing its judgment, a power which Coke
strenuously opposed, and which, after much strenuous discus¬
sion. was finally disposed of by an order from the King, July 14.
THE HOUSE OF COKE
195
1616 in which he confirmed to tlie Court of Chancery all the
powers that it had before claimed and exercised.’
To make matters worse, at the King’s right hand to advise liim
was Bacon, who now saw at last liis chance to crush his rival.
Lord Ellesmere, who was tlien Lord Chancellor, was a sick man,
and Bacon could see that if he now used his advantage to tlie
best of his ability, the King would confirm the jurisdiction of the
Court of Chancery, and on the death of Ellesmere would ap¬
point Bacon in his place. This was exactly what happened and
Bacon became Chancellor in 1618. In the preceding two years
Coke was completely degraded from his great position. There
were plenty of actions in Coke’s legal career which would have
justified his removal from his profession, but when he fell, he
fell, however misguided in the cause of law, the desire to uphold
the authority of his court. He was degraded as few felons have
been, for he was made to feel his fall; he was sent to the Tower
and deprived of his place in the Privy Council. Bacon may not
have exalted over him, for revenge and cruelty were not vices of
that curious nature. In any event Bacon’s gratification was short
lived. Within two years he was himself deprived of his position.
He was found guilty of having taken bribes or at least of having
known that his servants had taken them. Coke took no part in
the condemnation of Bacon because there was no need to do so.
He knew that his rival’s guilt was so clearly established that
nothing could be added to it.
After Coke had recovered from his fall — incidentally he tried
to regain the royal favour — he did not lose heart. He still had
the immense fortune which he had accumulated in his legal
career, and soon afterwards married Lady Elizabeth Hatton, a
widow with means and pedigree or at least connections. Then,
as he had left the office of Lord Chief Justice, which did not then,
as it does nowadays, carry a peerage with it, he was eligible for
election to the House of Commons. He became M.P. for Nor¬
folk and from that time was one of the main opposers of the
Court party. Not that he appears to have been vindictive, but
he had seen the fabric of the law in danger and he longed to
vindicate its true position. The Court recognised the danger which
196
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
this great adversary could bring against it. His papers were
seized, his houses and his chambers in the Temple were sealed
and his liberty was in danger. Yet right until the end of his life
he was a pillar of the opposition. In one of his speeches he warns
the Commons of the dangers of a power above the law. ‘Look
into all the petitions of former times; they never petitioned
wherein there was a saving of the King s sovereignty. I know that
prerogative is a part of the law; but “sovereign power” is no
parliamentary word. In my opinion it weakens Magna Charta
and all the statutes for they are absolute without any saving of
sovereign power.... If we grant this by implication, we give a
sovereign power above all laws.' He had a big part in the Petition
of Right. In 1628 he retired from Parliament, but as he did so he
made a last energetic speech against the favourite, the Duke of
Buckingham, who was then to be charged with having ill ad¬
vised his King. In that last Parliament of Coke’s, a new member
made a speech, a maiden speech; this was Oliver Cromwell, the
Huntingdonshire grazier as John Buchan called him. How much
influence did the career and speeches of Coke have upon that
mighty spirit?
We can conclude the account of Coke’s life by a further quo¬
tation from his epitaph in which he is thus referred to: ‘By King
James constituted Chief Justice of both Benches successively, in
both a just, in both an exemplary judge, one of His Majesty’s
most honourable Privy Council, as also of Council to Queen
Anne and Chief Justice in Eyre of all her forests, parks, and
chases, recorder of the City of Coventry, and High Steward of
the University of Cambridge, whereof he was sometime a Mem¬
ber of Trinity College. He had two wives. By Bridget his first
wife (one of the daughters and coheirs of John Paston, Esquire),
he had issue, 7 sons, and 3 daughters; and by the Lady Elizabeth,
his second wife, (one of the daughters of the Rt. Hon. Thomas,
late Earl of Exeter) he had issue two daughters. A chaste hus¬
band, a provident father.’ To which may be added the inscription
beneath the effigies: ‘He crowned his pious life with as pious
and Christian departure at Stoke Poges in the county of Buck¬
ingham on Wednesday the 3rd day of September in the year of
THE HOUSE OF COKE
197
Our Lord MDCXXXIII/ He was 84. His last words were Thy
Kingdom Come, Thy Will be done.
So much for this undoubtedly great man, whose fame can
never die save with the deatli of English law. His sons were left
by him with as much wealtli, each of them, as if each were an
eldest son. From this fact arose the subsequent fame and fortune
of the Earls of Leicester. The family could hardly fail to succeed
on such a foundation. One of Coke’s descendants. Sir Thomas
Coke, K.B. was created Earl of Leicester in 1744 but as his only
son. Viscount Coke, died before him, the titles became extinct,
but the estates devolved upon the son of the Earl’s sister who had
married a Mr. Roberts. This nephew, Wenman Roberts, took the
name and arms of Coke, thus following the usual device of
English families whereby a great name is perpetuated altliough
in the male line it has become extinct. Wenman Roberts or Coke
had a son who was to be one of the greatest agricultural im¬
provers this country has kno\vn. He was the great Mr. Thomas
Coke of Holkham whose portrait appears at the beginning of the
first volume of Burkes Landed Gentry, or of Burke’s Commoners,
as it was originally and more appropriately called. The full wor¬
ding of the title page of this work exactly describes the position
of the great Mr. Coke. ‘A Genealogical and Heraldic History of
the Landed Gentry or Commoners of Great Britain and Ireland
enjoying territorial possessions or high official rank but un¬
invested with heritable honours.’ The author explained in his
preface that 'to this grade in her social system — her indepen¬
dent country gentlemen — England is mainly indebted for her
greatness abroad, and her prosperity at home. In this and her
free institutions, she differs from every other country in Europe.’
The author had as frontispiece to his first volume an engraving
of Coke of Norfolk, namely T. W. Coke, esq., of Holkham. This
was in 1837 but in that same year Mr. Coke of Norfolk was
created Earl of Leicester, of Holkham, and Viscount Coke. He
thus became ineligible for the Landed Gentry or Commoners
and went into the next edition of Burke’s Peerage. But whether
as commoner or peer, Thomas William Coke was certainly re¬
presentative of the great country gentlemen of England. His
198
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
was the second creation of Leicester in the Coke family, but he
did not receive his Earldom until he was 82 and might well have
continued for the whole of his life as a plain squire, though had
he done so his country seat, his estates and his rent roll of
£20,000 a year (equal to some £70,000 now) would have been
no mean patrimony for a continental duke. Coke of Norfolk, as
he is usually known, was fundamentally an agriculturist and it
has been said that every book on modem agriculture derives
from his practice. When he took over the Holkham estates he
found that both crops and cattle were very poor, but by obtaining
the best advice and putting it into practice he was soon able to
transform his property. Coke was one of the improvers of British
agriculture. He succeeded to his father’s estates in 1776, the year
of the American Revolution. It was during this last quarter of the
18th century that some of the greatest improvements in British
farming were made. The quality of the wheat improved and so
did the breeds of pigs, sheep and cattle. It is very easy to point
out that some thousands of enclosure acts were passed in the
second half of the 18th century and well into the 19th century;
by this means much common land was taken from smallholders
and the poor and much hardship must have been caused to them,
yet there can be no doubt that the enclosure movement greatly
increased the amount of food produced and for the first time
made British agriculture lead the world. One has only to read
the travels of Arthur Young in France and to note the comments
which he makes upon the feeble state of French agriculture as
contrasted with British, to realize that men like Coke were on
the whole benefactors of the country. It was not until well into
the 19th century that a succession of very bad harvests accom¬
panied by an enormous influx of cheap food from abroad, broke
the back of British farming and turned it into the ailing and weU-
nigh forgotten industry which it was in 1914, and again after
the scare of the war years, in 1939. In Cokes day however our
farming was the envy of the world because it was conducted on
scientific lines with the best knowledge of the period, on a
sufficiently large scale, and by men who had enough ^^slon to
be able to look beyond the next year. The rental of the Holkham
THE HOUSE OF COKE
199
estate went up tenfold under Coke’s directions, from a little
over £.2,000 a year to over £20,000 a year. Of course the land¬
lord was interested in obtaining as much money as possible for
his estate, but in so doing he increased the value of tlie land,
employed many more hands, and built up a food supply for the
teeming new millions of industrial workers in the cities of the
midlands and the north. It was H. G. Wells who said that a race
of gentry was really essential if the pursuit of knowledge for
its own sake was to continue, and he went back as far as 500 B.C.
to find in Gautama the Buddha an e.xample of his thesis. Cer¬
tainly in England our science would be the poorer if it were not
for some of the great men who have belonged to our leisiued
class, such as Bacon, Cavendish, Darwin, Blackstone and Gib¬
bon. We could put it another way, in Hazlitt’s words, and say
that there have been among us great men, Shakespeare, Milton
Bacon, Newton, Cromwell, whose shadows lengthen towards us
across the centuries; of these only Shakespeare had to work for
his living and he made haste to join the gentle class to which his
mother had belonged.
Allied with Coke’s work in farming there went an aggressive
political partizanship which made him a staunch Whig suppor¬
ter and admirer of Charles James Fox. Coke had been brought
up by his father in the belief that one should never trust a Tory,
but contrary to the modem belief, there was nothing incongruous
in this determined Whig entering the Upper House as an earl.
It was not imtil the I9th century and well into it that a Tory
majority in the Lords became an established matter. Conse¬
quently the new Earl of Leicester found many people of his own
political persuasion among the peers.
The first earl was twice married and left numerous descen¬
dants. His eldest son by his second marriage succeeded him in
the earldom and received many high honours. He was for neai'ly
40 years Keeper of the Privy Seal to the Prince of Wales, after¬
wards Edward VII and he was made a Knight of the Garter.
Like his father he was twice married and left many children,
being prudent and successful in his marriages as in everything
else. His first wife was Juliana the eldest daughter of Samuel
200
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
WTiitbread of Cardington in Bedfordshire, a member of the
great brewing family; his second wife was the Hon. Georgina
Cavendish, eldest daughter of Lord Chesham.
The Earls of Leicester have maintained a close connection with
Royalty. One of tlie second earl's younger sons the Hon. John
Coke, was Gentleman Usher to George VI and Equerry to
Queen Mary. The third earl was A.D.C. to both Edward VII
and George V. The present (5th earl) was Extra Equerry to
George VI and also to Queen Elizabeth II. Sponsorships at bap-
tizms by tlie Sovereign or others members of the Royal family
are commonplaces in the Leicester family. Lady Anne Coke was
one of the Maids of Honour at the Coronation in 1953.
Like all other great landed families, that of tlie Cokes of Holk-
ham now faces the possibility of sale of ancestral property owing
to the exigencies of taxation. Nothing has been more marked
among the modern aristocracy than the attempt which they have
made to meet this problem by self help. Properties have been
passed over to the National Trust while the owners have re*
tained an interest in them; in this way Sir Henr>' Cameron-
Ramsay-Fairax-Lucy has been able to live at Charlecote Park in
Warwickshire where the Elizabethan Sir Thomas Lucy, the
original of Justice Shallow, fined William Shakespeare for stea¬
ling deer in his park. In other cases our nobles have made a vir¬
tue of necessity by opening their houses at a charge of half a
crown a visit and have often acted as tlie guides themselves in
going round the property. Yet again self help in the face of appa¬
rently inevitable ruin has led to the development of small local
industries. Thus at Lullingstone Castle in Kent there is a silk
worm farm as well as a carefully laid out Roman villa as an
additional attraction for the visitors.
At Holkham after the tour of the house, exit is made through
the pottery shop. Under the care of the present countess, who be¬
fore her marriage was Lady Elizabeth Yorke, the only child of
tlie 8th Earl of Hardwicke, a small industry for the making of
pottery has been established. There are many examples of small
ware to be seen in the shop which is often served by the Coun¬
tess herself and her two elder daughters, Lady Anne and Lady
THE HOUSE OF FITZCLARENCE
201
Carey Coke. A number of people are employed in making the
pottery and it is not fanciful to see in this the return to the
practice of a great mediaeval household where the various
craftsmen found shelter to pursue their occupations under the
guidance of the chatelaine herself. Again it is a pleasant thought
that what one may call the cottage industry which has almost
disappeared in England under the pressure of industrialism,
should now appear once more with our aristocracy as the leaders
in the revival. Certainly it is a long way from the fiery and testy
Sir Edward Coke but it is a continuation of his life work, for
usefulness has been the key to the Coke family greatness through
the ages.
Chapter twelve
MUNSTER
THE HOUSE OF FITZCLARENCE
A fter the strenuous race of the Cokes the bastard progeny of a
king may seem rather a falling off to some readers, but on
the other hand the reading public would think a book on peerage
and romance sadly wanting without at least one reference to
royal bastards. The popular conception on this point is very
curious. I have never known a case in which I have been asked
to write a popular article on peers without being also asked,
perhaps a little shyly, to bring in Nell G%vynne. Not only is this
the case with editors — after all they are merely trying to put
in what they think the public likes — but many private people
seem to believe that the bulk of the peerage is made up of the
descendants of royal illegitimate issue. It is true that there are
a number of dukedoms which derive from the amusements of
Charles II, but the bulk of the peerage has been recruited from
the gentle or professional classes. Wire pulling and intrigue may
well have entered into many of the elevations but not intrigue of
the romantic variety. Charles II is credited with 12 bastard
children, but his attainments in this direction are much less
than tliose of an earlier King, Henry I, the well known Beau-
Clerk, who left, according to the austere authority of the Com¬
plete Peerage, 19 illegitimate cliildren.
The Earl of Munster, 5th of his line, is the descendant of
George Augustus Frederick FitzClarence, who was the son of the
Duke of Clarence, afterwards King William IV, and the actress
Mrs. Jordan. The story of the FitzClarences is one of the more
the house of FITZCLAREHCE
203
interesting among those royal romances which always seem to
involve births on the wrong side of the blanket and for this
reason I have selected it in preference to the usual Grafton, St.
Albans, or Richmond and Gordon cases, which stem from
Charles II.
Anyone who looks up Munster in Burke’s Peerage will find
that the first Earl of Munster was only the eldest of ten children.
It must seem at first sight that it was a strange kind of passion
which could linger on to the procreation of ten children. Hardly
a case of fire and swiftness. It looks much more like what it was,
a domestic life; for 20 years the Duke of Clarence lived with
Mrs. Jordan and they lived as husband and wife, very much as
Louis XV used to treat Madame de Pompadom-, in fact as a
returning business man does his wife. The reason for this is not
difficult to find. The Duke wanted to get married. He was well
suited to domestic life, but unfortunately under the regime of
George III it was not easy for the royal line to find suitable con¬
sorts of their own rank and they were not allowed to marry
anyone who was ‘beneath them’. The Duke of Clarence made
many attempts to get married. He also tried a mistress or Uvo, a
Miss Finch, with whom he lived at Richmond, being the best
known. With different men se.xual passion takes various forms.
There are those, for whom in a well regulated state, an operation
would undoubtedly be prescribed in early youth, since in their
natural condition they are merely a menace to others and a
nuisance to themselves; there are those who genuinely do not want
to be tied in marriage but who want a woman’s society. There
are others who being frustrated in their marriages go around
talking and thinking of women. Lastly, and fortunately much the
most numerous section of mankind, are those who want a home
and a woman in it, with children of their own. For such, a
reasonably agreeable partner provides the best stimulus in life
and at the same time the urges of sex are absorbed in a very easy
manner.
The Duke of Clarence, the third son of George III, was a man
of the last type. He would have been quite happy in domestic
life, given a sufficiency of money and some interesting work to
204
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
keep him busy. He had been bred for the Navy, but though he
served at sea, and even had visions of leading the British Fleet
to glorious victory, he soon found himself deprived of command.
He was never able, until he became King, to obtain the pro¬
motion which he wanted and then it was too late; England had
settled into the safe sea supremacy which we owed to Nelson.
Clarence was a friend and to some extent a patron of Nelson,
but he was destined to spend a great deal of his life ashore,
and 20 years of it with Mrs. Jordan. She was Dorothy Bland, the
younger daughter of Francis Bland, an actor who was the son of
Nathaniel Bland an Irish judge. Jordan was her stage name.
The Duke of Clarence was after all only following tlie example
of his elder brothers and indeed of all his brothers. There has
probably never been a Royal family in which there was so much
dissolute behaviour as in that of the seven sons of George III.
The prince of Wales, afterwards George IV, has made a name
for himself in the histories of so called romance; lus least dis¬
creditable connection was his marriage to Mrs Fitz Herbert, which
was of course legally invalid as he had not his fathers per¬
mission to marry and Mrs Fitzherbert was in any case a Catholic.
George IV or rather the Prince Regent had many mistresses. The
Duke of York, although married when he was 28 to the Princess
Royal of Prussia, set up house in Gloucester Place with Mrs
Clarke described as a common woman who, having lived with a
succession of lovers had at last risen to share the bed of a prince.
The Duke of Kent (later to be the father of Queen Victoria by
the Princess Victoria) took great care in his choice of a mistress
when he was in Canada and brought the lady of his choice,
Madame de St Laurent, back with him to England. In the case
of the Duke of Kent his mistress was to all intents and purposes
his wife, for he lived with her for 30 years, and it was not until
he was 51 that he married the widow of the Prince of Leiningen.
He had children by Madame de St Laurent so that Queen
Victoria had half brothers and sisters, though the fact was veiled
in a profound obscurity. The Duke of Cumberland, who was to
become King of Hanover in 1837 when the law Salic prevente
Queen Victoria from succeeding to that throne, had numerous
THE HOUSE OF FITZCLARENCE
205
entanglements. One of these was supposed to be with Mrs. Sellis,
the wife of his valet and it was rumoured that he had been
discovered by the valet in bed with Mrs Sellis and that in in¬
dignation at being interrupted the Duke had murdered Sellis. It
seems however that in fact the valet had attempted to murder
him. The sucth son of George III, tlie Duke of Sussex, went
through a form of marriage in Rome in April 1793 and again at
St. Georges Square in London in December 1793 \vith Lady
Augusta Murray. By this lady he had Uvo children, a son and a
daughter, but the marriage was deemed to have been null and
void as at the time the Duke was only 20 and had not received
his father’s permission under the Royal Marriage Act of 1772.
The son of the marriage, who was known as Augustus Frederick
D’Este, claimed the Dukedom of Sussex in 1844 and the Sussex
Peerage Case has gone into English legal history as an example
of the rule that the provisions of the Royal Marriage Act apply
throughout the world. Later on the Duke was married to Lady
Cecilia, the widow of Sir George Buggin and the eldest daughter
of the second Earl of Arran. This however did not take place
until after the death of Lady Augusta Murray. We come at last
to the seventh son of George 11, Adolphus Frederick, Duke of
Cambridge who was undoubtedly a remarkable phenomenon in
that peculiar family, for he was virtuous.
It must be admitted that the Duke of Clarence and the Duke
of Kent did in fact remain faithful to their respective consorts
(1 understand that that is the word now normally used to
describe a lady with whom one is living, but whom it is impossible
to marry). Still, the overall pattern of the lives of the sons of
George III could hardly have been inspiring for the nation.
After the marriage of Queen Victoria to Albert the Good, an
attempt was made to hush up all the scandals of the Regency
period, but not even the thickest veil could obscure the facts
about the doings of Queen Victoria’s uncles. One does wonder
at times how such a book as Charles Bradlaugh’s House of
Brunswick could ever have been allowed to be published by
any government, even the feeblest, which cared for its monarchy.
Bradlaugh’s pages constitute the grossest and most dangerous
206
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
libel, if the statements are not true; he even impugns the mar¬
riage of George III to Princess Charlotte, giving out that the
King was already married to Hannah Lightbody.
To return to the Duke of Clarence and Mrs. Jordan. They
lived together happily until her death in 1816 so that he did not
have to put her away on his marriage to the Princess Adelaide,
as his brother the Duke of Kent did with Madame de St. Lau¬
rent. The Duke and Mrs Jordan had ten children and the polite
fiction that they were the Duke’s step children or wards was
discontinued after the Duke succeeded to the throne as William
IV. The eldest son, George Augustus Frederick FitzClarence (that
was the surname which was adopted for them) was created Earl
of Munster on the 4th June 1831 with special remainder to his
brotliers should his own male issue not survive. This young man
was determined to make as much capital as possible out of his
connection with the Crown. His father had only been on the
throne a year when the Earldom of Munster was conferred. It
had been demanded by George Augustus with menaces, in fact
he had tried to bully his father into making him a Duke, but
tlie old man, although very worried by his children, refused to
give in on this score. The first Earl took up a military career,
became a Major General in the army, Lieutenant of the Tower,
Governor of Windsor Castle, and most interesting of all, A.D.C.
to Queen Victoria. In Burke’s Peerage the Earl is described, very
decorously, as having died in 1842; this is true, but in fact he
committed suicide. Perhaps he could not face the new moral
atmosphere which prevailed at Windsor after the advent of
Prince Albert. The first earl married Miss Mary Wyndham, who
was the natural daughter of the Earl of Egremont. The blazoning
of their combined coat of arms must have been quite a curiosity;
few people can boast a double representation of bastardy in
their arms. From the first Earl descend the four subsequent Earls
so that the provision of the special remainder has not been
needed, but as the present Earl has no children there will be a
reversion to the descendants of the second son of the first Earl.
Of the numerous younger children of the Duke of Clarence and
Mrs Jordan there are hardly any descendants today wth the
THE HOUSE OF FITZCLARENCE
207
exception of Mrs Orred.
It is worth looking at the careers of the younger children. The
second son, Henry, became a soldier and died as a captain in
India. Frederick the third son was a Lieutenant in the army;
Adolphus, the fourth son went into the navy and became a Rear-
Admiral, being Naval A.D.C. to Queen Victoria. The fifth son
Augustus took Holy Orders and became rector of Mapledurham
in O.xfordshire. He was appointed Chaplain to Queen Victoria,
who it must be admitted did not forget her relatives. It is from
him that Mrs Orred descends. So much for the five sons. The
five daughters were married off into the peerage. All the youn¬
ger sons and daughters incidentally were given the rank and
precedence of the younger children of a marquess in 1831 when
their eldest brother was made an Earl.
The eldest daughter, Sophia married the first Lord De Lisle
and Dudley and from this marriage the present peer of that line
descends. Mary the second daughter married General Charles
Fox, bastard son of the third Lord Holland. Elizabeth, the third
daughter, married the 18th Earl of Erroll. Augusta married tlie
Hon. John Kennedy Erskine, son of the Marquess of Ailsa. Her
second husband was Lord John Frederick Gordon. The 5th
daughter Amelia married the tenth Viscount Falkland.
The arms of the Earl of Munster are extremely interesting as
they show the Royal arms of England as used by William IV
when Hanover was still part of the British Empire. There is the
familiar quarterly division of the Royal arms with England in the
first and fourth quarters, Scotland in the second and Ireland in
the third but Nvith an inescutcheon in the middle of the sliield
showing the arms of Hanover, and with the whole debruised, as
it is called in heraldry by a baton sinister, on which there are
three golden anchors. The latter are in allusion to William IV’s
profession as a sailor. The baton sinister is the herald’s way of
showing that the bearer of the Royal arms comes on the wrong
side of the blanket.
One of the peculiarities of English snobbery is that while a
man will do everything in his power to cover up the fact that
his grandfather was in trade or his great grandfather an honest
artisan, he will be thrilled to his marrow if he can discover that
208
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
the same great-grandfather was the result of an affair between
someone of Royal Blood and a lady whom he did not marry.
There is of course one advantage in having a bastard descent
from a royal house, provided that it can be proved; one does
know at every stage back to the year 500 A.D. who was one’s
ancestor, which is more than the majority of people can say.
Anyway the Royal line itself has got as its Norman founder
William the Bastard, so peers who trace their descent to a
similar source are after all only keeping up the tradition of 900
years.
Chapter thirteen
PEERAGE SEEKERS
F rom time to time there is news of someone who claims a
peerage and very occasionally the announcement that a
claim has been allowed by the Committee For Privileges. One
such case occurred in 1952—1953 when Henry James Scrym-
geour-Wedderbum proved his claim to the viscounty of Dudhope,
and later his claim to the Earldom of Dundee. Just before the
Coronation in 1953 he was informed that he could prepare him¬
self for that event as an earl.
Such a story in the newspapers will often prompt people to
enquire if there are many such claims. ‘Many’ like everything
else is a relative term, but I would say that to come across seven
or eight cases of peerage claims in twelve months would indicate
that the subject does interest quite a number of people. In most
instances the claim is not really a claim at all. Someone has
heard that his grandmother was the daughter of a peer. He can¬
not find the name of this peer in any current book of reference,
but he learns that peerages can became dormant or fall into
abeyance. Thereupon he concludes that that is what has hap¬
pened to the barony or earldom in his own family. Sometimes he
soliloquizes as follows: 'Of course if we had our rights in our
family I ought to be Lord Clapham Junction, and in fact the
whole of the area around Wandsworth and Clapham should be¬
long to our family. Still, I know that it would cost a great deal of
money to go on with it. My father had a try but found that
some certificates were missing, and anyway he was advised that
209
210
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
£2,000 or £3,000 would be needed/ Now that is the sensible
attitude to take up, but unfortunately when the idea of a peerage
dignity comes into a family common sense usually departs. As
very few of these people have the necessary cash to follow up
their enquiries, the mirage of a coronet remains with them
throughout life, ruining their chances of success in any normal
occupation and becoming at the best a nuisance and at the worst
an eccentricity which makes their fellow creatures avoid them
as bores.
The commonest form of the delusion is that a large estate
exists somewhere in a vague region known as Chancery. This
estate may run into millions — it does in the case of the Drake
millions — and sometimes the claim is so preposterous (to the
freehold of the City of London for instance) that one begins to
doubt the sanity of the persons concerned. However there is a
general belief among the uninitiated that a peerage is always
accompanied by an estate. Tliis is a hangover from schooltime
history. Most people know that the barons in the Middle Ages
possessed large estates and in fact right up until quite modem
times the idea of a peer who lived in a bungalow or a semi¬
detached house would have been unthinkable. The germ of truth
in this mistake over estates is that at one time no one would have
been created a peer without either receiving a grant of land or
being already provided with sufficient property to uphold the
dignity. It suffices to say that a claim to a peerage may be
successful and yet bring to the claimant nothing but the honour
of his new rank. The estate which was once held by the peer in
the particular case will have long since passed into other hands.
As to fortunes in Chancery those who harbour delusions on this
subject should really consult a leaflet put out by the Supreme
Courts Pay Office at the Royal Courts of Justice in the Strand,
London This leaflet is written expressly to free people from
foolish notions about the Chancery fortunes. Less than
£2,500.000 is held in Chancery. None of this constitutes a great
unti-aced fortune. There are many small accounts of a few hun¬
dred pounds belonging to persons whose next of kin have not
yet been traced and there are more modern cases where an
PEERAGE SEEKERS
211
estate has to be held in Chancery for a short period, until some¬
one comes of age or until the expiration of a trust. These solid
facts have been reiterated again and again but they have little
chance of prevailing once the enthusiasm of newspaper reporters
has been aroused. Savoy Dishwasher Heir to Millions* is a slogan
which makes a good headline and against which the sober leaflet
from the Courts does not stand a chance.
Yet in fairness to peerage seekers one must admit that the
most persistent of them are not motivated by base materialistic
ideas. In their thirst for the glories of nobility they lift up their
eyes to the House of Lords and wliile they watch the glittering
coronets of aristocracy, they disdain the ordinary ways of life.
I have known a window-cleaner and an old-age pensioner both
of whom were deeply concerned witli the revival of a barony.
In one of these cases the peerage in question had actually been
the subject of a petition to the Crown over one hundred years
ago. The claim had then had to be abandoned for lack of
evidence, so what hope was there that it could be revived at the
present day? It is impossible not to feel sorry for people like this
whose hopes are destined to constant failure.
One of the reasons for the prevalence of ideas about peerages
in all sorts of families is the legal doctrine that a person who was
once summoned to Parliament (otherwise of course than as a
burgess or a Knight of the Shire) was created thereby a peer.
The legal doctrine goes on that the son of such a person must
also have been a peer. This doctrine has been riddled by the
scholarship of men like John Horace Round, who have shown the
extreme fluidity of the conception of peerage in the 13th and 14th
centuries. In one case a man who had sat in the House of Lords
in one Parliament in the 14th century sat in the House of Com¬
mons in tlie following year. It is not known whether he was a
precursor of Anthony Wedgewood Benn in preferring the Com¬
mons to the Lords.
What is perfectly clear is that if a person could sit in the Lords
in one year and tlie next year in the Commons, the whole idea
of peerage as we now understand it had not been settled. Tliis
need not cause any surprise for all human institutions have their
212
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
periods of growth and development. It is not until the 15th
century with the decay in feudalism that the modem idea of
peerage begins to be known. The legal doctrine which I have
mentioned is a very useful fiction. In the 19th century however
this doctrine came to the notice of some enterprising genealogists
who saw their chance of making money. Being familiar with
various pedigrees which went back into the Middle Ages they
knew who were the modem representatives of ancient baronies.
They persuaded the latter to put forward their claims and a
large number of baronies by writ were called out of abeyance.
Thus in 1879, Lord Stourton, himself the holder of a very an¬
cient barony and the twentieth of his line, had the abeyance of
the baronies of Mowbray and Segrave determined in his favour.
This is the origin of the title of Lord Mowbray, Segrave and
Stourton which must surely be one of the most awkward in
social usage (one can imagine how long drawn out it would be
to use the full title ). The successor to Lord Stourton claimed
unsuccessfully in 1906 the ancient Earldom of Norfolk, to which
he was senior co-heir. He was also senior co-heir to an entire
moiety of the baronies of Strange de Blackmere, Talbot, and
Howard, and senior co-heir to the baronies of Braose of Gower,
Greystock, Dacre of Gillesland, Ferrers of Wemme, Verdun,
Darcy of Darcy, and Giffard of Brimmesfield, and a co-heir to
the baronies of Kerdestone, Dagworth, Fitz-Warine, Fitz-Payne,
Argentine, etc. He claimed as Lord Mowbray to be premier
baron of England. This claimant who rejoiced in being 24th
Lord Mowbray, 25th Lord Segrave, and 21st Lord Stourton died
in 1936, but before his death decisive action had been taken by
the authorities. A Select Committee had been set up in 1926 to
report on peerages in abeyance.
The report of this committee makes interesting reading. It was
shown that the number of cases in which abeyances were ter¬
minated were, in the 17th century, two (beside two other cases
which do not strictly fall under the doctrine of abeyance), in the
18th century, seven, in the 19th century, nineteen, and in the
present century (in 1926) eleven. The Report said that there¬
fore the proceedings had noticeably increased. It went on to
PEERAGE SEEKERS
213
point out that in modern times there had been a great deal of
research which had shed fresh light on the subject of what
constituted a peerage. There is grave reason to doubt, to say the
least of it, whether during these two centuries eitlier Sovereign
or subject had ever any idea that by a summons to a Parliament
a hereditary right either was being or had been created. It is
only very gradually that any suggestion of the kind can be
identified, and the development of the suggestion can be traced
in recognisable stages.
As a result of this very careful consideration and study, tlie
Committee made the following general recommendations which
it was suggested that the House of Lords should submit to tlie
King. The effect of these suggestions was that unless tliere were
special circumstances to the contrary, no abeyance was to be
terminated, the first commencement of which occurred more
than one hundred years before the presentation of the petition.
Should there have been any collusion behveen co-heirs to a title,
then the Committee for Privileges should report accordingly if
there were considered to be any taint of impropriety about it.
Regard was also to be had to the fitness of a person for the
termination of a peerage as for the creation of a peerage.
The report of the Committee put an end to the fantastic claims
of various people to revive ancient baronies which had in fact
probably never existed. Unfortunately many persons who want
to put forward these claims are unfamiliar with the ruling of tlie
1926 Committee and so they still persist in pressing them, al¬
though any good lawyer could tell them that they have no case.
They perhaps think that in their cases the special circumstances
exist which are referred to in the report.
Leaving aside claims which are now seen to be untenable by
reason of the ruling of the Committee there are still a number of
cases in which people exist who have quite a good claim to the
title of a former peerage family. I would say that there are
several such at present. One is that of the Earldom of
of Traquair, about which I have myself written a small book,
and where the evidence is very good. The last acknowledged
Earl of Traquair was Charles Stuart who died in 1861. He is
214
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
described in peerage books as having died unmarried, and the
title as becoming dormant which would imply that there was
the possibility of an heir somewhere. In the possession of Mr.
Charles Edward Traquair Stuart-Linton of 66th East 56th Street,
New York, there is the following document:
These are to certify all persons whom it may concern that
Charles Stuart, Lord Linton, of the County of Peebles and Eliza¬
beth Mary Johnston, of the County of Northumberland who
came before me declaring themselves to be both single persons
were lawfully married by the way of the Church of England and
agreeable to our Laws of the Kingdom and Kirk of Scotland.
Given under my hand at Coldstream Bridge, Coldstream, Scot¬
land this 28 day of April, 1818.
Scribe and Witness John Armstrong
William Bigger Linton
Witness — John Waugh Elizabeth Mary Johnston
To put the whole matter briefly, the story of the Traquair case
is that there was a marriage by one of the Border ‘priests’, in this
instance, Jock or John Armstrong. He is said to have performed
a similar ceremony for the great statesman Lord Brougham and
Vaux in 1821. The person referred to as Linton is the subsequent
8th Earl of Traquair. In his earlier day before he had succeeded
to the Earldom he would have been known by the courtesy title
of Lord Linton. From this marriage there descends the present
representative Mr. Charles Stuart-Linton of New York. Accor¬
ding to the genealogy which has already appeared twice in print
— in two editions of Burke’s Landed Gentry, 1939 and 1952
he is the great-grandson of the last Earl. I have not the least
doubt that the certificate to which I have referred is genuine and
therefore Mr. Stuart-Linton should be the Earl of Traquair.
From time to time over the 20 years during which I have known
him he has been engaged in preparing a claim but nothing has
come of it so far though many good judges think that it is a
sound one. ,
Then there is the Gardner peerage where there has not been
a peer to bear the title since the death of the 3rd Baron m 1883.
PEERAGE SEEKERS
215
It is perfectly clear that there is an heir to this title somewhere,
as there are many living males in the family. The matter has been
complicated by the habit in a branch of this family of marriage
with people of Indian birtli and not always of the Christian
religion. On the death of the 3rd Baron a claim was advanced by
Alan Hyde Gardner and later by his son Alan Legge Gardner. No
information is available as to why these claims were not pro¬
ceeded with. There may have been lack of vital evidence or the
claim may have broken down because the claimants were the off¬
spring of marriages which, being between Christian and non
Christian, are regarded by the law of England as not being true
marriages. It is unlikely that the case will ever be cleared up for
with the cessation of British rule in India there is very little
probability that an Indian or rather Anglo-Indian claimantwould
be able to find the money, the time or the inclination to prosecute
his claim. Meanwhile there are members of the Gardner family
in England who on their part cannot proceed with a claim while
there is the unsettled possibility of a claimant appearing from
India.
Another interesting case is that of the Viscounty of Valentia.
As this is an Irish peerage there is not the possibility as in
British cases that the would be holder could be summoned to sit
in the House of Lords. As no seat in the House is now involved
for Irish peers, there will undoubtedly be cases in which people
will simply assume an Irish title and no one will be in an official
position to say them nay. In the Valentia case there is also a
baronetcy and therefore as this has to be on the roll of baronets
which is maintained by the Home Office, there is an automatic
check on the peerage as well. In fact no holder of the Valentia
title has bothered to register his succession since 1844. The
ludicrous part of this matter is that the 11th Viscount had been
Comptroller of the Household and a Gentleman in Waiting to
George V. Whilst holding these posts it had never occurred to
anyone to inquire if he had formally proved his claim. The pre¬
sent claimant is faced with the necessity therefore of proving his
claim and that of three of his predecessors as well.
Enough has been said to show that the seeker after a peerage
216
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
has by no means deserted us. The time, energy and money which
he puts into his quest would enable him, usually, to secure a
peerage, one of a new creation. Instead he is led on by the
mirage of peerage honours, to spend weary and disappointing
hours seeking a title which may elude him, because some crab¬
bed scholar has decided that one of his ancestors had no real
right to a claim. In the Dundee case to which I have referred
above, the claim hung about for over 250 years. Some of the
huge research work needed to prove it was undertaken by a
cadet of the family who wanted to substantiate the claim, not
that he would benefit by it, but for the sake of the family honour.
Years later the claimant to the title entered into this man’s
labours.
Chapter fourteen
THE ANGLO-JEWISH PEERAGE
F or reasons which are not apparent I am the recipient of a
great deal of anti-Semitic propaganda, from people in
Britain and also in America. One pamphlet which reached me
had for its title 'Our Jewish Aristocracy'. It gave the names of
45 peers and of 54 baronets who were said to have Jewish blood.
Following these were lists of hereditary title holders who had
married Jewish women, of peers and baronets whose heirs were
married to Jewesses, and then came a list of Jewish knights or
rather of knights of Jewish blood. The author of the pamphlet
remarked that ‘the Jewish penetration also extends to sisters,
uncles, etc. of many other I^iOrds and Baronets, whilst in some
cases British Lords have had Jews as godfathers to their chil¬
dren.' The pamphlet was not without illustration. A sketch
showed a typical English nurse holding up a grisly looking child
to its horrified father (he being portrayed as a specimen of the
old aristocracy) and saying ‘Dont he take after his mother, my
Lord?' In the background a Jewish woman could be seen re¬
clining in bed, while also in the background the picture of the
Lord’s ancestor looked down reprovingly from the wall. The
whole was headed ‘Assimilation'.
Another pamphlet which came to me, this time from the
U.S.A. and which was called To-day's Greatest Problem was
written by A. N. Field, and was printed in New Zealand. It dealt
scientifically with the Jewish problem and gave many quo¬
tations from the Talmud, quotations horrible in their import for
every Gentile.
2X7
218
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
These instances which I quote from booklets received by me
are only two specimens of anti-Semitic literature. It is produced
in most European and North American countries, and the reason
behind it is the hold which powerful Jewish business interests
secure on the life of ostensibly Gentile communities. I have
heard that in Hollywood there is always an obstacle to the pre¬
paration and showing of a film on the life of Jesus Christ be¬
cause the Moguls of the film industry are Jewish and have no
desire that the life of their rejected Messiah should be publicised.
However this may be I was very interested in the smear con¬
tained in the first mentioned pamphlet, as to the ne.\us between
the Jews and the British aristocracy. It so happened that about
the time that I received this pamphlet I received also an in-
\’itation from Mr Harold Soref to hear a lecture which he was
to deliver to the Anglo-Jewish Historical society on the very
subject of the Anglo-Jewish peerage. Mr. Soref is a speaker and
writer of great brilliance and I knew that any subject which he
had made his own by research would be of fascinating interest.
Moreover I had not studied the subject of the interrelation of
the Jews with the Peerage in any great detail.
As a result I found Mr. Sorefs lecture of absorbing interest.
He traced the first beginnings of Jewish infiltration into the
aristocracy 200 years ago. He showed that for each in¬
stance of a Rothschild or a Disraeli which is familiar to everyone,
there are ten cases of Jewish connection which are now half-for¬
gotten. One of the most curious of these was concerned with
the late Lord Southwood, more usually known in business as J. S.
Elias, the reviver of Odhams Press and the man who made it
into the vast undertaking it now is. Soref pointed out that in
Southwood’s biography no reference appeared to his Jewish
origin. This is a phenomenon which is not peculiar to the bio¬
grapher of Lord Southwood, for in many other cases Jewish
origin is concealed.
The details given by Soref are of great interest. Jews were
emancipated long before they were able to penetrate the peer¬
age to any considerable extent, but once they got under way,
they lost few opportunities. In 1837 Sir Moses Montefiore was
THE ANGLO‘]EWISH PEERAGE
219
the first professing Jew to be knighted since 1700, when one of
William of Orange’s army contractors was so honoured. In 1846
Sir Moses became a baronet. In 1885 Nathaniel Rothschild was
the first professing Jew to become a peer, although the Roth¬
schilds in various European countries had received honours from
the state, and one of them, Baron Lionel de Rothschild had been
the first Jewish M.P. to take his seat.
There are at present 14 peers who are of Jewish persuasion.
They are the Marquess of Reading, Viscounts Bearsted and
Samuel, Lords Cohen (a Law Lord) Cohen of Birkenhead, Green-
hill, Hore-Belisha, Jessel, Mancroft, Morris of Kenwood, Nathan,
Rothschild, Silkin and Swaythling. But this was merely to show
the purely Jewish families who had been ennobled. Soref was able
to give a long list of instances of marriages into the British
aristocracy on the part of Jews and Jewesses, particularly the
latter. In many cases these instances occurred relatively far back
in our history, sometimes as much as two hundred years ago. Few
people think of members of the Jewish community playing a part
in connection with the British aristocracy in the 18th century yet
such is the case. Some title holders of the present day do not
descend from these Anglo-Jewish alliances as the ancestor in
question was what is known as collateral. Other titles have died
out but their connections often still exist through the female line
and they are themselves only a fraction of the number of cases
quoted by Soref. These citations prove beyond doubt that the
Jews, not only of English origin but also those from abroad who
have settled in England, have made themselves so closely con¬
nected with the British peerage that the two classes are unlikely
to suffer loss which is not mutual. So closely linked are the Jews
and the lords that a blow against the Jews in this country would
not be possible without injuring the aristocracy also. Conversely
the destruction of the House of Lords, and the failure any longer
to create hereditary titles would have its effect upon English
Jewry. The wealthy Jew would no longer be able to look for\vard
to the honours due to his power and position in the community.
Those Jews who were peers would find that their titles, instead of
220
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
being an advantage to them would become a decided disadvan¬
tage.
What conclusions are we to draw from the close alliance of
Jew and lord? First that from it one can understand how im¬
possible the success of any anti-Semitic propaganda could be in
present day Britain. No Fascist movement can be in the way of
success while the ruling class of Britain is composed of those
who have friends and relatives in Jewry. There is a great deal of
latent anti-Jewish feeling in the working class of Great Britain,
and in certain circumstances they would respond to the advances
of a nationalist leader, who would lead them to the pillage of
the Jews, as in Germany where every economic error was
attributed to Jewish influence according to Hitlerite propaganda.
Then the facts of connection of the Jews with the peerage do
not lend themselves to the maintenance of a good opinion of the
aristocracy. A man is not usually thought the more of, because he
has married a woman for her money. The majority of marriages
with Jewesses into the peerage must be actuated by the desire
for financial security. An ancient estate is likely to be sold un¬
less some large sums are found. The sums are found from
marriage with a Jewish heiress, and therefore she is valued
accordingly. The most outstanding instance is that of the 5th
Earl of Rosebery, who had three avowed aims in life, to marry
an heiress, to win the Derby and to become Prime Minister. He
achieved all three but laid the foundation of his success by
marrying when he was 31, Hannah, the only daughter and heiress
of Baron Mayer Amschel de Rothschild. She stayed in the Jewish
religion but her children were educated as Christians. Her wealth
brought to Rosebery the means whereby many ways to success
were opened. The alliances between Jewish ladies and British
lords are mostly of this type, the wife providing large sums of
n)oney while the aristocrat has the title and ancient estate. The
children are able to look back upon a varied bag of ancestors.
Such alliances do certainly enliven the somewhat dull pages
of genealogy, which in older days chronicled merely the mar
riages of persons of the same type. Some of these cases do not
THE ANGLO-JEWISH PEERAGE
221
shed much credit upon the British aristocracy for they indicate
that there are few connections which a lord will not make in
order to get this worlds goods.
What is the Jewish attitude towards these marriages with
the Gentiles? Largely I think it is one of satisfaction that Jews
and Jewesses have been able to get into the most exclusive
circles, and to mix their blood with that of the old patricians.
Some Jews are inclined to quote the verses of Defoe, about
‘Roman, Saxon, Dane, Norman — there you have your true bom
Englishman', and to show that the English are a hopelessly mixed
race. In fact of course this is nonsense. The English Conquest in
the 5th and 6th centuries obliterated the Romano-British pro¬
vincials pretty thoroughly, and the succeeding invasions of Danes
and Normans were after all only the arrival of kinsfolk of the
English, albeit very hard and unpleasant kinsfolk. In the cen¬
turies following the Norman Conquest there were infiltrations
of various small minorities, such as the Lombards, the Flemings,
and the Huguenots, but these were not in large numbers suffi¬
cient to upset the racial content. The general remark that the
English are a mongrel race is based on the idea that the names,
Norman, Saxon, Dane etc. denote races widely different in blood,
whereas there were really closely akin.
At first therefore there is great joy in the Jewish community at
the friendliness of peers and Jews and this is reflected in the
accounts of the tercentenary of the return of the Jews to Eng¬
land. It is often remarked that those English families which were
friendly to the Jews are friendly to them still after the period of
300 years. This means of course that the great families are among
the friends of the Jews, for 300 years ago only the great families
had influence.
But among the deeper thinking Jews, the present connections
between Jewry and the House of Lords do not always give
cause for satisfaction, undiluted and untrammelled by fear. I
quote from Mr. SoreFs admirable paper. ‘As those who have
been ennobled form a cross-section of Anglo-Jewry they form
an ideal group of identifiable Jewish families displaying attach¬
ment to the community or otherwise during the past 70 years.
222
TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
It is a remarkable fact that those subjected to the forces of
social assimilation over the period of centuries have frequently
tended to retain their Jewish allegiance with greater consistency
and determination than those of foreign birth or the sons of
immigrants. Other marked deductions are the inter-relationship
of the older peerages and their early identification with the
Liberal party to whom they showed gratitude for emancipation.’
Then going on to a survey of the Jewish families, Mr. Soref
adds, 'The heirs of Lords Jessel and Reading were brought up
as Christians. The heirs of Lords Greenhill and Silkin have no
association with the community. Lords Hore-Belisha and Man-
croft are without heirs. Lord Cohen is a Law Lord and not here¬
ditary. Of the remaining six it is doubtful whether more than
three will perpetuate their ancestral faith or communal duties.
Of particular interest is the case of Lord Rothschild.
‘The son of the first Lord Rothschild was the recipient of the
Balfour Declaration. He was the first English Rothschild to
associate himself with Zionism, becoming President of the Zio¬
nist Federation of Great Britain and Ireland. He was not a
partner in the Bank, but took his Jewish responsibilities serious¬
ly. A distinguished zoologist and a Fellow of the Royal Society,
the second Lord Rothschild (1868—1937) died unmarried. He
was succeeded by his nephew. Also an eminent scientist and
Fellow of the Royal Society, the 3rd Lord Rothschild, unlike his
banking cousins, plays little or no part in Jewish affairs. His
heir is the son of his first wife who was brought into Judaism.
His present wife is out of the faith.*
Whatever may be the facts about the loosening of ties in the
faith of Jewry, there can be no question that the British Peerage
is now very much diluted with Jewish blood and has many con¬
nections among its most ancient and august families with those
who only a few generations ago were inhabitants of the Ghetto.
In view of the great world wide interlockings of the Jewish com¬
munity this may insure to the aristocracy a stronger hold on the
future. The power of money is very great and as almost every
liberal newspaper is under Jewish influence it follows that the
forces of revolution when directed against the peers are likely
THE ANGLO-JEWISH PEERAGE
223
to meet with as determined an opposition from the Jewish kins¬
folk of the aristocracy as tliey will in any other quarter.
EPILOGUE
I n writing of twelve famous peerage families one merely sam¬
ples a small portion of the vast wealth of interesting matter
which exists in the annals of the aristocracy. Sir Bernard Burke
devoted several volumes to the subject. The Rise of Great
Families was his first volume which he later remodelled and
revised under the title Reminiscences Ancestral, Anecdotal and
Historic. In 1869 he produced the Vicissitudes of Families in two
volumes, besides which he also wrote Family Romance.
When I look over the list of names which were suggested to
me for the compilation of this book I see several well-known
titles which could have been mentioned and which would have
been equally interesting with those about whom I have written.
Strathmore, the family of Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother
is a case in point. It has royal descent dating back 600 years
w’hen Sir John Lyon of Glamis married the Princess Jean, the
daughter of King Robert II of Scotland. Curious legends hang
about the Strathmore family; most people have heard of the
alleged curse which descended upon one of the earls who is
supposed to have diced with the Devil, and others again may
have heard the strange tale of a monster, rather like the tale of
Mr Rochester’s first wife, who at some time in the remote past
was supposed to be held in captivity in Glamis Castle. More
interesting are the true details of such events as the burning
alive on the Castle Hill, Edinburgh, of the widow of the 6th
Lord Glamis; and of the 80 beds which the Old Pretender had
224
EPILOGUE
225
made up for himself and his followers when he stayed at Glamis
in 1715. More prosaic but very pertinent was the marriage of the
9th Earl of Strathmore witli Mary Bowes, the heiress of Mr
George Bowes of Streatlam Castle in Durham. This lady was
described as the greatest heiress of her time in Eiu-ope and from
her comes the adoption of tlie additional siumame of the Strath¬
more family (Bowes-Lyon) and the arms of Bowes with tlie three
bow strings in pale, as the heraldic description goes, which are
of course a play on the name. In every generation since the
marriage of the heiress of Bowes, the head of the family has
married an Englishwoman and many members have lived in
Hertfordshire, particularly at St Paul’s Walden Bury near Hit-
chin where the Queen Mother was born.
Scottish families often possess legends and true stories which
in sheer stark ferocity pass right out of comparison with any¬
thing in the south. In the genealogy of the Dukes of Sutherland
murder and sudden death were quite commonplaces. The 11th
Earl of Sutherland was murdered by one of his kinswomen who
put poison in his ale. Another ancestor of the Sutherland line
(this time an Englishman) was Lawrence Gower, who was con¬
cerned in the murder of Piers Gaveston in Edward II's time.
The great house of Douglas, the Black and the Red, is now re¬
presented by the Duke of Hamilton, the premier peer of Scot¬
land. The Duke is himself a man of great deeds and was the
chief pilot of the Houston Everest Expedition which flew over
that mountain in 1933 before it had been climbed to the summit.
This great exploit brings the Duke into line with his ancestors
of whom it has been said that 'Douglases were heroes every age’.
One of the present Duke’s ancestors in the direct line was the
5th Earl of Angus, Old Archibald Bell the Cat, tlie hero of the
famous story that he destroyed a king’s favourite as an example
to the rest of his fellow nobles. Another line of the family was
that of the Earls of Douglas. This line contained Sir James Dou¬
glas, who was ordered by Bruce to take his heart to the Holy
Land and lay it in Christ’s sepulchre; another James Douglas
was the hero of Otterburn and then there was the young sixth
Earl of Douglas who with his brother David was murdered by
226 TALES OF THE BRITISH ARISTOCRACY
the King of Scots at a dinner in 1440 (this is the incident of the
Black Bull’s head).
The Duke of Richmond who is also Duke of Lennox and Duke
of Gordon stems from Charles II and Louise de Keroualle, who
was made Duchess of Portsmouth by the grateful king. The son
of this pair was Charles Lennox, first Duke of Richmond, and
visitors to Goodwood, the Duke’s magnificent seat near Chiches¬
ter, are shown many portraits of the Duchess of Portsmouth. The
ramifications of the Duke of Richmond’s family include nearly
the whole of the older peerage for after its royal beginning the
family has always married into great houses. The student of
illegitimacy in heraldry may note that the Royal arms as used
by the Dukes of Richmond are shown within a bordure, and not
as Munster vvuth a baton sinister lying across the shield. The
bordure is more properly the Scottish method of denoting
bastardy.
Perhaps in the whole of the peerage there is no more fascina¬
ting study than that of the Philipps family, the representative of
which is Viscount St. Davids. Their authentic pedigree goes
back to the time of the Norman Conquest but the descent is not
traced from anything as common as a Norman invader. The
ancestry is Welsh and even in the tenth century his family had
a tradition that they were descended from the hapless King of
Kent, Vorigern, who is supposed to have invited the Saxons,
Hengist and Horsa, into England with their followers. Vortigem s
name occurs in the legend of King Arthur and his Kmghts, but
the Philipps have not been content even with this early ancestry
for they went on to trace descent, or at least to assert it, from
Maximus the Roman General who set up a separate state in
Britain in the 4th century and made himself for a while master
of the Channel by controlling the Roman fleet. Although this
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The Editor and the Publishers wisJi to thank
Cassel & Co. Ltd. for their permission to
reproduce the extracts on pages 134, 135
and 136 from Sir Winston Churchill’s
THE GATHERING STORM.